In most fantasy leagues you've probably heard the comment "the carnage this year is unbelievable" and had fellow league members lament all the first-round busts. But is this year that much different than the past? The answer may surprise you.
A few years back I did a study with my friend Jeff Buchbinder called Don't Buck History With Your Pick that compared the statistical results to the preseason conventional wisdom. It showed the top pick in the draft earns so much, for example, that it's not worth trading down in almost any scenario.
The 2007 preseason top 25 features four busts this season (based on APD data from www.mockdraftcentral.com):
| ADP |
Player |
|
Pos |
Team |
Value* |
| 1 |
LaDainian |
Tomlinson |
RB |
SD |
69 |
| 2 |
Steven |
Jackson |
RB |
STL |
0 |
| 3 |
Larry |
Johnson |
RB |
KC |
6 |
| 4 |
Frank |
Gore |
RB |
SF |
7 |
| 5 |
Joseph |
Addai |
RB |
IND |
25 |
| 6 |
Shaun |
Alexander |
RB |
SEA |
6 |
| 7 |
Brian |
Westbrook |
RB |
PHI |
34 |
| 8 |
Reggie |
Bush |
RB |
NO |
2 |
| 9 |
Willie |
Parker |
RB |
PIT |
10 |
| 10 |
Rudi |
Johnson |
RB |
CIN |
0 |
| 11 |
Laurence |
Maroney |
RB |
NE |
0 |
| 12 |
Peyton |
Manning |
QB |
IND |
19 |
| 13 |
Travis |
Henry |
RB |
DEN |
10 |
| 14 |
Willis |
McGahee |
RB |
BAL |
28 |
| 15 |
Chad |
Johnson |
WR |
CIN |
32 |
| 16 |
Maurice |
Jones-Drew |
RB |
JAX |
12 |
| 17 |
Steve |
Smith |
WR |
CAR |
44 |
| 18 |
Marvin |
Harrison |
WR |
IND |
0 |
| 19 |
Cedric |
Benson |
RB |
CHI |
5 |
| 20 |
Edgerrin |
James |
RB |
AZ |
32 |
| 21 |
Terrell |
Owens |
WR |
DAL |
26 |
| 22 |
Reggie |
Wayne |
WR |
IND |
17 |
| 23 |
Torry |
Holt |
WR |
STL |
12 |
| 24 |
Larry |
Fitzgerald |
WR |
AZ |
17 |
| 25 |
Ronnie |
Brown |
RB |
MIA |
67 |
* Thanks to data from Profootballreference.com.
I define a bust as someone who wouldn't qualify as a starter at the end of the season in a 12-team league that starts 1 QB and 2 RB and 2 WR(so top-12 for a QB, top-24 for RB or WR). No flex players to keep things simple.
How does that compare to previous seasons?
Year Zeros
2007 4
2006 9
2005 9
2004 6
2003 6
2002 4
2001 8
1999 10
1998 10
1997 5
1996 8
1995 4
1994 5
1993 10
As you can see, 2007 actually has less carnage than most seasons - well below the average of seven busts per season since 1993. The 1999 season was ugly. Four of the top five projected picks were all busts:
1. Terrell Davis - Season-ending knee injury
2.
Fred Taylor - Just 10 games due to hamstring injury.
3. Jamal Anderson - Torn ACL
4. Dorsey Levens - Finished 12th overall
5. Steve Young QB - Career-ending concussion
How soon we forget. Or maybe most were not playing fantasy football back then.
This year's top-25 projected picks (based on ADP) are producing less than the last few years, however. So far the average 2007 player in the top 25 has produced just 11 percent on average compared to the top overall player. That figure hasn't been below 20 percent since 1994 and often is as high as 30 percent.
The 2007 data is a bit skewed because not everyone in the top 25 has had a bye week yet, so it's not a true comparison. So while there may not be more busts than in previous years, it's possible this year's preseason conventional wisdom was worse overall than in the past decade. But as Week 6 performances from Tomlinson and Larry Johnson show, it's pretty early for some of the top picks to be called busts.
But if Randy Moss or Tom Brady can keep their current pace they may accomplish something we haven't seen since Terry Allen in 1996 - a number one overall fantasy point producer who wasn't in the preseason top 20.
Posted by Peter Schoenke at 10/16/2007 10:24:00 PM