2026 All-Bust Fantasy Team: Position Players

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. was one of many several early-round hitters who disappointed in 2026. Should we buy back in on the season's biggest busts in 2027?
2026 All-Bust Fantasy Team: Position Players

With the regular season in the rearview mirror, it's time for a look back. So far, we've examined the position players, starting pitchers and relief pitchers who provided the most value relative to their draft slot. This week, we're shifting our focus to busts. First up are the position players who disappointed this season. I'll be using RotoWire's preseason ADP numbers (sorted by NFBC 12-team leagues) and earned auction values.

Disclaimer: You won't find guys who had their seasons derailed by a major injury (i.e. UCL, ACL) in this space. We know what went wrong there.


Catcher: Cal Raleigh, Seattle Mariners
ADP: 17.4, 1st among catchers
EAV: 14th among catchers

Raleigh provided such a massive return on investment during his historic 2025 campaign that he was pushed up to the second round with regularity and sometimes slipped into the first round in drafts this past spring. The 29-year-old then slashed a woeful .164/.271/.308 with 11 home runs during the first four months of the 2026 season, as he required a strong .811 OPS with 12 long balls from August on just to finish inside the top-15 at his position. Raleigh's quality of contact remained strong, but he made a lot less of it, seeing his strikeout rate spike to a career-high 30.9 percent. The switch-hitting catcher underwent debridement surgery on the AC joint in his left shoulder just after the season, and it's possible that injury affected the catcher's production. Raleigh's defensive metrics were also way down

With the regular season in the rearview mirror, it's time for a look back. So far, we've examined the position players, starting pitchers and relief pitchers who provided the most value relative to their draft slot. This week, we're shifting our focus to busts. First up are the position players who disappointed this season. I'll be using RotoWire's preseason ADP numbers (sorted by NFBC 12-team leagues) and earned auction values.

Disclaimer: You won't find guys who had their seasons derailed by a major injury (i.e. UCL, ACL) in this space. We know what went wrong there.


Catcher: Cal Raleigh, Seattle Mariners
ADP: 17.4, 1st among catchers
EAV: 14th among catchers

Raleigh provided such a massive return on investment during his historic 2025 campaign that he was pushed up to the second round with regularity and sometimes slipped into the first round in drafts this past spring. The 29-year-old then slashed a woeful .164/.271/.308 with 11 home runs during the first four months of the 2026 season, as he required a strong .811 OPS with 12 long balls from August on just to finish inside the top-15 at his position. Raleigh's quality of contact remained strong, but he made a lot less of it, seeing his strikeout rate spike to a career-high 30.9 percent. The switch-hitting catcher underwent debridement surgery on the AC joint in his left shoulder just after the season, and it's possible that injury affected the catcher's production. Raleigh's defensive metrics were also way down this season, which would seem to support the theory that he wasn't right physically. There's also a chance he was worn down after he absorbed a massive workload in 2026. A market correction for Raleigh is coming for 2027, and fantasy managers would be wise to treat the 2025 season as an outlier.

Runner-up: Agustin Ramirez, Miami Marlins


First Base: Vladimir Guerrero, Toronto Blue Jays
ADP: 18.1, 1st among first basemen
EAV: 35th among first basemen

It's still difficult to wrap my head around Vlad Jr.'s 2026 season. The 27-year-old slashed .354/.438/.469 in April, but over the final five months he managed just a .235/.303/.326 batting line with seven home runs. He finished with only nine homers, and he hit his one and only long ball at home on Sept. 13. Though his contact skills remained elite with just a 13.3 percent strikeout rate, Guerrero's quality of contact lagged, as his hard-hit rate (44.3 percent), barrel rate (6.9 percent) and average exit velocity (90.3 mph) were all easily the worst marks since his rookie season. Shortly after the conclusion of this season, Guerrero underwent laser eye surgery. It feels convenient to place blame for Vlad Jr.'s struggles on poor vision. After all, a guy who isn't seeing the ball well is probably going to be striking out more often than Vlad did. That said, sometimes you just have to trust that a guy as young and as talented as Guerrero is bound to bounce back.

Runner-up: Josh Naylor, Seattle Mariners


Second Base: Jose Altuve, Houston Astros
ADP: 107.7, 5th among second basemen
EAV: 34th among second basemen

It's been clear for a few years now that Altuve's best days are behind him, but prior to the 2026 season he had generally been able to avoid a steep fall-off in his production. However, Altuve never really got going in his age-36 season, and a guy who we'd become used to seeing five-category production out of was not an asset in any category in 2026. A 19.9 percent strikeout rate like the one Altuve had in 2026 is good by itself, but less so when you consider he had a career 13 percent strikeout rate coming into the year and hadn't previously had a full-season strikeout rate higher than 17.4 percent. The former MVP has never been a Statcast standout, so he needs that elite contact ability to be a viable fantasy producer. Additionally, Altuve no longer looks like he can be counted on to deliver stolen bases, having pilfered just five this season and having tallied only one 20-steal showing across his last nine seasons.

Runner-up: Ketel Marte, Arizona Diamondbacks


Shortstop: Gunnar Henderson, Baltimore Orioles
ADP: 13.6, 3rd among shortstops
EAV: 20th among shortstops

After sinking to 17 home runs during the 2025 season, Henderson appeared determined to bounce back in the power department when he slugged nine long balls in April of this season. That came with an atypical 30.3 percent strikeout rate, however, and he proceeded to swat only 15 more over the boards the rest of the way, sporting a disappointing .230/.318/.384 batting line in the process. Henderson's 22.8 percent pull-air rate this season was far and away the highest of his career, lending credence to the theory that he might have been too focused on a power rebound. Also, after swiping a career-high 30 bases in 2025, Henderson managed just one-third of that total in 2026 with 10 pilfers (and he was caught five times both years). The truncated aggressiveness could have been a directive from new manager Craig Albernaz, as the Orioles ranked 25th in steals one year after they finished in the top-half of the league. Henderson will not turn 26 until next June, so he'll probably bounce back to some degree in 2027, but his 2024 campaign could wind up going down as his best.

Runner-up: Francisco Lindor, New York Mets


Third Base: Austin Riley, Atlanta Braves
ADP: 61.6, 4th among third basemen
EAV: 29th among third basemen

Riley has now delivered three disappointing seasons in a row, and the 2026 season was the first of those that couldn't be blamed at least in part due to injuries. The 29-year-old remained healthy this season but finished with fewer than 20 home runs for the third straight year, and that's after he averaged 36 homers per season from 2021 to 2023. Riley's batted-ball data also took a significant step back this season, and his strikeout rate continued to trend in the wrong direction as it reached 31.9 percent. When Riley finished in the top seven in MVP voting for three straight years from 2021 to 2023, his strikeout rate never got higher than 25.4 percent. Riley will turn 30 just after Opening Day next year, so he's young enough and talented enough to right the ship. That said, if he was going to rebound to his previous heights, it might have happened already.

Runner-up: Maikel Garcia, Kansas City Royals


Outfield: Ronald Acuna, Atlanta Braves
ADP: 6.6, 3rd among outfielders
EAB: 36th among outfielders

Few other players have displayed the fantasy upside of Acuna. In his two full, healthy seasons, he's batted .309 while averaging 41 home runs, 55 stolen bases, 104 RBI and 138 runs scored. Unfortunately, the 28-year-old has had just those two full seasons, and the 107 games he played in 2026 was his highest total in three years. Acuna made two separate trips to the injured list this season with hamstring problems, and much of his injuries over the years have been to his lower half. Perhaps that's part of the reason why Acuna doesn't run as well as he used to, as his sprint speed has steadily fallen over the years and in 2026 was below league average for the first time. Acuna's quality of contact also dipped noticeably in 2026, as his hard-hit rate dropped eight percentage points (52.5 percent to 43.5 percent) and his average exit slipped more than three mph (92.7 mph to 89.6 mph). It's not difficult to envision Acuna returning to fantasy superstardom in 2027, but confidence he can get back there seems to be waning.

Kyle Tucker, Los Angeles Dodgers
ADP: 14, 6th among outfielders
EAV: 35th among outfielders

There was a collective eyeroll from baseball fans when Tucker landed with the Dodgers in January on a four-year, $240 million contract. Tucker then produced more eyerolls from fantasy managers that used a pick on him as he suffered through his worst season in the big leagues. Tucker hit five fewer home runs and stole 13 fewer bases year-over-year despite accruing 32 more plate appearances. Also, while his plate discipline remained terrific, Tucker's batted-ball data was down across the board. He did finally show signs of life in September and in the postseason, so it's possible Tucker just needed some time to settle in after inking his first big free-agent contract. He's no longer a slam-dunk first-round pick in fantasy, but Tucker remains in his theoretical prime and has an excellent supporting cast and a favorable ballpark.

Jarren Duran, Boston Red Sox
ADP: 66.7, 14th among outfielders
EAV: 44th among outfielders

Heading into last offseason, it seemed like a forgone conclusion that Duran would be traded as the Red Sox looked to free up their outfield/designated hitter logjam. Boston never found a deal they liked, though, so Duran stayed put. The 30-year-old is expected to be on the trade block again this winter, but the offers aren't going to be better after Duran slashed a woeful .207/.266/.361 this season. It was feast or famine for the streaky Duran, who had an .879 OPS in May and .789 OPS in August but an OPS no higher than .587 in the other four months. Duran has been very durable, clocking in for more than 150 games three years running, which helped him reach the 20-20 level even though his rate stats were horrid. However, the left-handed batter was benched often late in the year versus lefties, and his continued struggles versus southpaws could make him more of a strong-side platoon bat moving forward, particularly if he lands with a new team.

Runners-up: Wyatt Langford, Texas Rangers; George Springer, Toronto Blue Jays; Luis Robert, New York Mets

Fantasy Pass
Want to Read More?
The Fantasy Pass unlocks this article and every other one.

Season-long rankings, start/sit calls, and waiver advice from the analysts who wrote this piece. Subscribers can also talk it through with the author in the comments.

Season-long rankings, start/sit calls, and waiver advice from the analysts who wrote this piece.