With the regular season in the rearview mirror, it's time for a look back. We're going to go position-by-position identifying the players who provided the most value relative to their draft slot. I'll be using RotoWire's preseason ADP numbers and earned auction values.
Catcher: Liam Hicks, Miami Marlins/Tampa Bay Rays
ADP: 451.6, 81st among catchers
EAV: 8th among catchers
Hicks showed a keen batting eye in 2025 in his rookie season, drawing walks at an 11 percent clip while sporting just a 17.6 percent chase rate. However, between the lackluster quality of contact and the presence of Agustin Ramirez, there wasn't much optimism in the fantasy community that Hicks could be more than a placeholder type in two-catcher leagues. What we didn't count on was Hicks rejiggering his swing to produce more pull-side power, leading to the tripling of his home run total (six to 18) and nearly doubling of his RBI total (45 to 82). Hicks remained one of the weakest in baseball in terms of hard-hit rate (27.1 percent), barrel rate (3.7 percent) and average exit velocity (84.6 mph), but his pull rate (37.2 percent to 43.1 percent) and pull-air rate (14.9 percent to 20.4 percent) both went way up. He was able to accomplish this while sporting an elite 9.9 percent strikeout rate and a ridiculous 97.3 percent in-zone contact rate, which was the highest in all of baseball. Among qualifiers, Hicks was one of only four players with more walks (56) than
With the regular season in the rearview mirror, it's time for a look back. We're going to go position-by-position identifying the players who provided the most value relative to their draft slot. I'll be using RotoWire's preseason ADP numbers and earned auction values.
Catcher: Liam Hicks, Miami Marlins/Tampa Bay Rays
ADP: 451.6, 81st among catchers
EAV: 8th among catchers
Hicks showed a keen batting eye in 2025 in his rookie season, drawing walks at an 11 percent clip while sporting just a 17.6 percent chase rate. However, between the lackluster quality of contact and the presence of Agustin Ramirez, there wasn't much optimism in the fantasy community that Hicks could be more than a placeholder type in two-catcher leagues. What we didn't count on was Hicks rejiggering his swing to produce more pull-side power, leading to the tripling of his home run total (six to 18) and nearly doubling of his RBI total (45 to 82). Hicks remained one of the weakest in baseball in terms of hard-hit rate (27.1 percent), barrel rate (3.7 percent) and average exit velocity (84.6 mph), but his pull rate (37.2 percent to 43.1 percent) and pull-air rate (14.9 percent to 20.4 percent) both went way up. He was able to accomplish this while sporting an elite 9.9 percent strikeout rate and a ridiculous 97.3 percent in-zone contact rate, which was the highest in all of baseball. Among qualifiers, Hicks was one of only four players with more walks (56) than strikeouts (55). The 2026 season might have been a best-case scenario for Hicks in terms of his power output, and he will sit against most lefties, so the 27-year-old could be someone to fade in 2027 now that his cost will be elevated.
Runner-up: Gabriel Moreno, Arizona Diamondbacks
First Base: Jake Bauers, Milwaukee Brewers
ADP: 451.6, 75th among first basemen
EAV: 9th among first basemen
Bauers did enough in 2025 in essentially half a season's worth of plate appearances that the Brewers tendered him a contract last offseason (unlike the season before, when he wound up re-signing on a minor-league deal). He finished the 2026 campaign as the best offensive player on the team with the best record in baseball, slashing .266/.389/.484 with 26 home runs, 86 RBI, 93 runs scored and 11 stolen bases. Bauers ranked in the 91st percentile or higher in terms of hard-hit rate (51.9 percent), barrel rate (14 percent), average exit velocity (92.1 mph) and bat speed (76.5 mph), and only four other qualifiers had a higher walk rate than Bauers' 16.3 percent mark. It seems unlikely Bauers will re-sign with the Brewers after a career year, which might not be the worst thing considering he's slashed only .210/.328/.394 in his career at American Family Field.
Runner-up: Luis Garcia, Washington Nationals/New York Yankees
Second Base: Kody Clemens, Minnesota Twins
ADP: 409.3, 25th among second basemen
EAV: 7th among second baseman
Clemens did some interesting things in 2025 with the Twins after being acquired in an early-season trade that year, slugging 19 home runs over 112 contests while sporting healthy quality-of-contact metrics. He had done very little at the major-league level prior to that point, though, and was entering his age-30 season in 2026, so it was difficult to summon too much enthusiasm for his prospects this season. However, Clemens built upon that mini breakout in 2025 with a 27-homer showing in 2026 in his first-ever season as a big-league regular. Clemens again sported healthy batted-ball data, logging a 46.1 percent hard-hit rate, 11.3 percent barrel rate and 91.9 mph average exit velocity. He also continued to thrive when it came to pulling the ball in the air (22.9 percent) and did so while cutting his strikeout rate down to 21.8 percent. Clemens will cost more in 2027 drafts, but his age and batting-average risk should keep his price at a reasonable level.
Runner-up: Ezequiel Duran, Texas Rangers
Shortstop: Otto Lopez, Miami Marlins
ADP: 267.8, 25th among shortstops
EAV: 4th among shortstops
After going 15-15 in 2025, Lopez put up 11 home runs and 34 stolen bases in 2026 while also finishing with the third-best average in the National League at .305. Because Lopez rarely draws walks (5.8 percent) and finished with a whopping 687 plate appearances, that batting average is extra helpful for his fantasy managers. Also, while it might not be a .300 average again, Lopez should continue to be an asset in that category thanks to his elite contact skills. The rest of Lopez's fantasy upside could depend largely on how aggressive he wants to be as a baserunner in 2027. He was a very efficient 34-for-39 on stolen-base attempts in 2026 after going just 15-for-21 the year before. The good news for Lopez is that he presents a safe floor, thanks to his superb glove that will allow him to stay in the lineup and pile up counting stats.
Runner-up: Brooks Lee, Minnesota Twins
Third Base: Miguel Vargas, Chicago White Sox
ADP: 271.3, 15th among third basemen
EAV: 2nd among third basemen
It took him a while to settle in at the big-league level, but after showing encouraging signs in 2025, Vargas experienced a full-on breakout in 2026. There were five players this season to hit 30-plus home runs and steal 20-plus bases. Vargas was one of them, tallying 33 long balls and 22 stolen bases in addition to 93 RBI and 106 runs scored. Additionally, the improvement he made in 2025 with his strikeout rate stuck (he fanned at just a 17.9 percent clip), and he also upped his walk rate to a career-high 14.3 percent. The one downside with Vargas — if you can even call it that — is that he's such an extreme flyball hitter and extreme pull hitter that he's unlikely to hit for a great average even though he makes lots of contact. Of course, that profile is also the reason he was able to have a power breakout in 2026, and with an up-and-coming supporting cast around him, Vargas is well-positioned to load up on counting stats.
Runner-up: Nolan Arenado, Arizona Diamondbacks
Outfield: Jordan Walker, St. Louis Cardinals
ADP: 369, 84th among outfielders
EAV: 4th among outfielders
The Cardinals advertised a rebuild in 2026 and plenty of leash for key players to find out which ones they could count on to build around. Rather emphatically, Walker showed he's one of those players to build around, as the former top prospect slashed .269/.327/.466 with 29 home runs, 102 RBI and 22 stolen bases. Walker's strikeout rate went from 31.8 percent to 26.1 percent year-over-year, and he was able to cut that mark down while still hitting the ball as hard as ever, ranking in the 90th percentile or higher in hard-hit rate, barrel rate and average exit velocity. The 24-year-old did stumble late with a .519 OPS in September, though we found out after the season that he was playing through a hip injury. It was also Walker's first full season in the majors, so wearing down late in the year is a distinct possibility. He will always be held back to some degree by Busch Stadium — it's been the most difficult park to homer in over the last three seasons — and hit almost twice as many home runs on the road (19) as dhe did at home (10). However, Walker should be just fine as long as he keeps that strikeout rate at a reasonable level.
Jake McCarthy, Colorado Rockies
ADP: 419, 97th among outfielders
EAV: 9th among outfielders
The Rockies picked McCarthy up last offseason in a nondescript trade with the Diamondbacks. McCarthy was coming off a disastrous 2025 campaign which saw him post a sub-.600 OPS and spend a large chunk of the year in the minors. He wound up being the Rockies' Opening Day leadoff hitter, and while the playing time was a little iffy early on, by mid-May McCarthy was an everyday player. The 29-year-old established career highs across the board in his first season in Colorado, hitting .291/.334/.475 with 15 home runs, 83 RBI, 80 runs and 32 stolen bases. McCarthy's quality of contact remained poor, but his 45.9 percent groundball rate was easily the lowest of his career, and his 27.3 percent line-drive rate was easily the highest of his six seasons. The speed has always been there for McCarthy, and he's always been an efficient basestealer, as well. In the batter's box, his high contact rate and speed are perfect fits for Coors Field, allowing the outfielder to overcome his lackluster quality of contact.
Carson Benge, New York Mets
ADP: 334.3, 73rd among outfielders
EAV: 14th among outfielders
It was a disastrous season for the Mets, but not one that was without bright spots. One of them was Benge, who hit the ground running in his rookie season with a .282/.346/.430 batting line, 20 home runs and 22 stolen bases. He became the eighth rookie ever and first Mets rookie in history to record a 20-20 campaign. One worry with young players is their production can wane down the stretch as they experience the length of a major-league season for the first time. However, Benge seemed to just get better as the year went along. He slashed only .189/.247/.278 in April before hitting .299/.363/.457 the rest of the way, which included a .315/.381/.497 batting line in 50 contests from August on. Among his last nine tilts, Benge had multiple hits in six of them, including the final three. Something that tends to get lost in the shuffle is that Benge has been a full-time position player for only two seasons (he also pitched in college), so he might only be scratching the surface of his upside. That's a scary proposition for the rest of the league.
Runners-up: Mauricio Dubon, Atlanta Braves; Dominic Canzone, Seattle Mariners; Zack Gelof, Athletics
