The 2026 regular season is over, and the 2026 postseason rages on. Yet there are already some sickos doing draft and hold drafts over at NFBC, because, as one person put it, "There are only two seasons: baseball season or draft season." I am doing my best to not jump in, as I typically wait until I return from First Pitch Arizona to do so, but that will also, admittedly, be influenced by how long the Rays last into October.
One exercise I like to do before diving back into draft season is looking back to see where the values were in the most current season, both overall and for my own team. We are often told that nobody cares about our fantasy team, so I will be brief with my league-winning draft and hold team to say getting players such as Bryan Baker, Jacob Latz, Kody Clemens, Nick Martinez, Chase Meidroth, Sam Antonacci, Casey Schmitt and Nasim Nunez with picks outside the top 350 made it easier to win a league that included me using top-15 picks on Brent Rooker, Ryan Helsley, Trevor Story, Luis Robert Jr., Ryan Pepiot and Brenton Doyle.
I was by no means alone in getting a poor return on investment from early picks, as there were several foundational busts in 2026 due to performance issues, injury issues, or a combination of both. I put together a comprehensive sheet showing the final ADP from the
The 2026 regular season is over, and the 2026 postseason rages on. Yet there are already some sickos doing draft and hold drafts over at NFBC, because, as one person put it, "There are only two seasons: baseball season or draft season." I am doing my best to not jump in, as I typically wait until I return from First Pitch Arizona to do so, but that will also, admittedly, be influenced by how long the Rays last into October.
One exercise I like to do before diving back into draft season is looking back to see where the values were in the most current season, both overall and for my own team. We are often told that nobody cares about our fantasy team, so I will be brief with my league-winning draft and hold team to say getting players such as Bryan Baker, Jacob Latz, Kody Clemens, Nick Martinez, Chase Meidroth, Sam Antonacci, Casey Schmitt and Nasim Nunez with picks outside the top 350 made it easier to win a league that included me using top-15 picks on Brent Rooker, Ryan Helsley, Trevor Story, Luis Robert Jr., Ryan Pepiot and Brenton Doyle.
I was by no means alone in getting a poor return on investment from early picks, as there were several foundational busts in 2026 due to performance issues, injury issues, or a combination of both. I put together a comprehensive sheet showing the final ADP from the 339 Draft Champions drafts from this past winter and where those players finished in the overall final top-500 rankings here at RotoWire as well as the player's earned auction values. For the purpose of this article, I filled in anyone outside the top 500 with a 501 rating and a -$10 earned auction value.
I will be looking at pockets of rounds in this article, but there is a source chart on the aforementioned sheet showing the average final ranking and earned auction value by round.
The Early Rounds
The first five rounds form the foundation of your team. You hope to get the five players that will anchor your roster across the statistical categories. This, however, was a tough season for that plan, with so many top-75 players by ADP failing to come close to expectations. Consider the following:
- Six players with ADPs inside the top 75 finished outside the top 500 overall rankings:
- Garrett Crochet (11th)
- Edwin Diaz (29th)
- Cole Ragans (47th)
- Brent Rooker (48th)
- Roman Anthony (60th)
- Ryan Helsley (75th)
- 32 percent of the players drafted inside the top 75 pitches finished outside the top 150 overall
- 46 percent of hitters taken in the top 75 returned at least $20 of value while finishing the season in the top 60. There were just three hitters — Maikel Garcia, Brent Rooker and Roman Anthony — who finished with negative auction value. This group was nearly a coin flip for success, but the ones who did not pan out were very notable:
| PLAYER | ADP | FINAL RANK | FINAL $ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aaron Judge | 2 | 306 | $2 |
| Cal Raleigh | 18 | 292 | $2 |
| Francisco Lindor | 21 | 258 | $4 |
| Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | 17 | 217 | $6 |
Surprisingly, early pitching was a decent return on investment. There were 29 pitchers in the top 75 by ADP. 11 of them earned at least $20 in value and ranked inside the top 60 overall, while 12 returned less than $10 of value, with seven players returning negative value:
- Devin Williams (-$1)
- George Kirby (-$3)
- Kyle Bradish (-$5)
- Garrett Crochet, Edwin Diaz, Cole Ragans, Ryan Helsley (-$10)
Top-100 Picks
Nine percent of top-100 picks were busts that did not finish in the final top 500, with 14 percent of the top 100 failing to return even a dollar of auction value. 9 of the 14 from the unprofitable pool were pitchers:
- Starters: Framber Valdez, George Kirby, Garrett Crochet, Cole Ragans, Nick Pivetta
- Relievers: Devin Williams, Edwin Diaz, Ryan Helsley, Carlos Estevez
Estevez and Williams came into draft season with plenty of risks but both had jobs (on paper) early in draft season, so the projected saves drove their value. Rooker, Anthony, Garcia, as well as Agustin Ramirez, were the only position players to return negative auction values.
11 of the top 100 earned at least $30 of value in season, and all finished inside the top 15 overall. Cade Smith, Mason Miller and Yoshinobu Yamamoto were the only full-time pitchers to reach that level while Randy Arozarena was the latest drafted among that group, earning $30 from the 93rd overall ADP spot. Two players inside the top 20 overall earned $30 or more, albeit on different paths. Junior Caminero did it from the 16th overall spot and was productive all season. Fernando Tatis Jr. did it despite not hitting the first of his 25 home runs this season until May 30.
The Next 100
The second most valuable fantasy player in 2026, Jacob Misiorowski, was found here with an ADP of 127. He went as high as 68 and as low as 176 in drafts, yet finished behind only Pete Crow-Armstrong in overall rankings while earning fantasy managers $43 of value this season. Cam Schlittler was just behind him ranking third overall with $38 of value while Drew Rasmussen's 138 ADP saw him finish 19th overall with $29 of value. Throw in Zack Wheeler, Sonny Gray, Gavin Williams, and Chase Burns, and managers who went heavy on hitting in the first six rounds before shifting to pitching saw all of those pitchers between picks 112 and 138 do well.
However, there were 18 busts in this tier who failed to finish in the top 500 overall, while 34 of the 100 players in tier failed to return positive fantasy value. 19 of those 34 were pitchers with notables such as Spencer Strider (104), Hunter Greene (110), Ryan Pepiot (131), as well as closers such as Daniel Palencia (106), Dennis Santana (134) and Ryan Walker (148). Those latter two names should reinforce the risks of waiting too long to address saves as they were widely considered the line of demarcation for the closer cliff this season and both lost their jobs rather quickly in 2026. Overall, nearly three times as many players (34) return zero or negative fantasy value than the 13 players who returned at least $20 of value in this tier.
Last Five Rounds (19-23)
In a regular draft, this is the end game, but in a Draft and Hold format, no such thing exists. There were just four players who returned at least $20 of fantasy value in this range and all four finished in the top 60 overall rankings. They were:
| PLAYER | ADP | FINAL RANK | FINAL $ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jordan Walker | 346 | 12 | $31 |
| Miguel Vargas | 274 | 16 | $30 |
| Parker Messick | 306 | 36 | $24 |
| Carson Benge | 358 | 53 | $21 |
Ryan Bloomfield from BaseballHQ holds an annual social media poll asking people to guess what player outside the first 12 rounds will become a first-round value. There is always one player who does so, and this year, that was Walker. It should not surprise you than nobody in the poll nominated Walker, and I was even able to purchase Walker for $2 in a dynasty league this past winter, which tells you just how low his value was before the season started.
35 of the 75 players in these rounds failed to finish inside the top 500 overall, while 46 of the 75 failed to return any positive fantasy value. Other players who returned between $10 and $19 of value in these late rounds included:
| PLAYER | ADP | FINAL RANK | FINAL $ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cade Cavalli | 336 | 61 | $19 |
| Reid Detmers | 339 | 73 | $17 |
| Braxton Ashcraft | 281 | 82 | $16 |
| Josh Bell | 348 | 87 | $16 |
| Brooks Lee | 325 | 93 | $16 |
| Logan Henderson | 293 | 99 | $15 |
| Chase DeLauter | 307 | 123 | $13 |
| Grant Taylor | 323 | 127 | $13 |
| Chase Meidroth | 339 | 132 | $13 |
| Dominic Canzone | 338 | 141 | $12 |
| Brandon Marsh | 345 | 146 | $12 |
| Ryan O'Hearn | 278 | 166 | $10 |
There is an even mix of American and National League players on that list, including a few of my bold predictions (Bell, Taylor, Canzone) who panned out and one (Detmers) who did much better than I predicted. However, 61 percent of the players from this tier failed to return positive fantasy value. This is a primary reason many pundits refer to this part of the draft as the churn and burn section, because it's unlikely the players drafted here will remain on your roster for an extended period of time. 33 of the 50 players taken from 300 through 350 failed to return any positive value. This reinforces the importance of getting your production early and filling in the gaps with late-round options rather than banking on production being there in the end game.
Post-350
Even this late in the game, there was still some value to be found. Speaking from first-hand experience, finding multiple values in this round is how you survive the in-season attrition that comes along with the draft and hold format. 30 players taken after pick 350 earned at least $10 in fantasy value while 11 finished inside the final top 100 rankings:
| PLAYER | ADP | FINAL RANK | FINAL $ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Louis Varland | 553 | 15 | $30 |
| Bryan Baker | 647 | 20 | $29 |
| Jake McCarthy | 442 | 29 | $26 |
| Jacob Latz | 447 | 41 | $23 |
| Jake Bauers | 532 | 46 | $22 |
| Nolan Arenado | 390 | 66 | $19 |
| Eduardo Rodriguez | 518 | 83 | $16 |
| Kody Clemens | 399 | 84 | $16 |
| Nick Martinez | 507 | 91 | $16 |
| Ezequiel Duran | 659 | 95 | $15 |
Three of the top four bargains in this tier were closers, which may embolden some fantasy managers to further punt saves hoping this trend repeats in 2027. Even though I personally benefitted from taking Baker and Latz in multiple leagues, I will not be one of those managers in 2027. Bauers, Arenado, Rodriguez, and Martinez are good examples of the old axiom, "once you display a skill, you own it," even if that skill had been lost for some time. Clemens and Duran were likely more valuable to some fantasy managers with their multi-positional eligibility and production this season, which was an undervalued part of the draft and hold format.
In all, there were values to be found in every single group of picks from 1-50 all the way to 701-750:
ADP Range | Highest Earned Value |
|---|---|
1-50 | $48 |
51-100 | $35 |
101-150 | $43 |
151-200 | $29 |
201-250 | $26 |
251-300 | $30 |
301-350 | $31 |
351-400 | $19 |
401-450 | $26 |
451-500 | $23 |
501-550 | $30 |
551-600 | $14 |
601-650 | $29 |
651-700 | $15 |
701-750 | $2 |
While I cannot recommend a strategy of counting on the late rounds to deliver value, I can underscore the importance of looking for skills and potential opportunities in those later rounds. This is particularly applicable to the volative bullpen situations which perpetuates around the league. It is my hope that this work helps you plan for your upcoming early drafts, and who knows, maybe I see you in one of them!
