Top MLB Betting Picks for October 7: MLB Same-Game Parlays and Props
MLB 2026 betting record: 47-55-1, -9.06 units (playoffs included)
There's only one MLB postseason game Thursday, as three series wrapped up Wednesday, but there are several ways I'm looking to attack it from a betting standpoint.
I like the Cleveland Guardians to push this series to Game 5, and I'll provide two other picks for their must-win game against the Chicago White Sox, including a player prop recommendation.
Cash in on the best sportsbook promos available at the best MLB betting sites this baseball season. The BetMGM bonus code gets new players one of the best welcome bonuses in the industry.
Cleveland Guardians vs. Chicago White Sox Best Bets and Predictions
- Under 1.5 Runs, First Three Innings (+135 BetMGM)
While he didn't turn in his best performance in Game 1, Parker Messick still struck out six and held the White Sox to two runs over 4.1 innings. Great, no, but he got a lot of whiffs and was strong against Chicago in the regular season. Messick made four starts totaling 25.2 innings and compiled a 2.81 ERA while holding the club to a .198 batting average.
The 25-year-old southpaw had his best fastball velocity of the season in the series opener, per Brooks Baseball, and will be pitching on regular rest. On four days of rest this season, Messick posted a 2.63 ERA and held opponents to a .593 OPS. Even better for this wager, he dominated opponents his first time through the order, holding them to a .178/.224/.300 batting line.
Getting two runs across the board can happen in a moment, and that's especially true when both teams are involved. But there's not much more you can ask for from a pitcher when betting on a market like this. And there's more I like here, too. Messick keeps the ball in the yard, which inspires a bit more confidence if the power-hitting White Sox get runners on. He had the ninth-lowest HR/9 rate among qualified pitchers.
On the other side, the White Sox will deploy southpaw Hagen Smith, who has been a huge weapon for them, and he will get to feast on a lineup that scored the fewest runs per game among the playoff teams, and did poorly vs. lefties this season (91 wRC+).
Smith might only go two frames after throwing 21 pitches yesterday, and it's unclear who will follow him. But in a best-case scenario, Smith does his job and hands it off to a bullpen arm who will primarily get the bottom of the Guardians' lineup.
Check out Caesars Sportsbook this MLB season and use the Caesars Sportsbook promo code for one of the top MLB betting promos.
Cleveland is largely devoid of power, ranking 27th in ISO and home runs in the regular season, and Smith has allowed just one home run in 21 appearances (playoffs included). Smith has walked multiple batters in his two outings this series and did allow a run in Game 3, but he had a pristine walk rate in the regular season and has big strikeout stuff.
At +135, this is a strong value play for an isolated wager that will see the two starting pitchers I'm bullish on factor heavily in how the bet settles.
- Guardians Moneyline (-112 Caesars)
Messick can provide more length than Smith — and he will, as long as he doesn't get torched in the opening frames, which I suspect is unlikely based on my previous recommendation. And from there, the Guardians have the edge. Their bullpen is in better shape and it's quite frankly better, especially with Smith not being an option late because he's opening.
Cleveland will have to bridge the gap to get to Cade Smith, but he's the best reliever in this series. Despite throwing two innings yesterday, there's no doubt he's available Thursday night. He only threw 19 pitches and struck out five. Smith hasn't allowed a hit in the ALDS and has given up one hit over his last 10 appearances. The last time he allowed a run was Aug. 24, and he led all relievers in win probability added (per FanGraphs). He's as automatic as they come.
Check out Fanatics Sportsbook to bet on MLB odds and use the Fanatics Sportsbook promo for a great welcome offer.
The Guardians, of course, have to bridge the gap from Messick to Smith, but the margin for the White Sox to strike big looks small. Because of that, I think Cleveland is the better pick to win this game.
While the White Sox certainly have the more dangerous lineup, particularly in their ability to hit homers, they have a significantly higher strikeout rate. As unimposing as Cleveland's lineup is, take a look at these second-half splits:
White Sox: .230/.322/.396, 103 wRC+
Guardians: .252/.324/.397, 103 wRC+
Cleveland also stole 19 more bases over that stretch and graded out as the better defensive team, per FanGraphs. I'm not saying I like the Guardians' lineup more, but the data shows the White Sox are the better home run-hitting team, but might not be better anywhere else.
- Jo Adell Over 1.5 Hits + Runs + RBIs (+110 BetMGM)
Adell has big holes, but he's also one of the few Guardians players with legit power, and he occupies the cleanup spot in their lineup. While his .736 OPS over the last two seasons is unremarkable, he's just outside of the Top 15 in home runs and ranks eighth in RBI.
Cleveland's designated hitter has topped this line in two of three games this series and was 10-5 against it to close out the regular season.
Adell has destroyed lefties the last three years (.877 OPS, .931 OPS and .971 OPS this season), so he could enjoy a real platoon advantage if he finds himself in that situation — and it's possible it starts early against Smith. The White Sox surely know that, but Adell will likely be surrounded by switch-hitters and left-handed bats, so it might be hard for Chicago to force him into right-on-right matchups.
Check out on one of the top sports betting apps when you sign up with the bet365 bonus code for your baseball betting.
MLB Picks Recap
- Under 1.5 runs, First Three Innings (+135 BetMGM)
- Guardians Moneyline (-112 Caesars Sportsbook)
- Jo Adell Over 1.5 Hits + Runs + RBIs (+110 BetMGM)
All Plays for 1 Unit















