Overall Steamer Ranks (Without Catcher Adjustment)

Yesterday I ran the Steamer hitter numbers and compared them to NFBC ADP. Today, I quickly ran Steamer’s numbers for pitchers and hitters through my formula, adjusting for closer scarcity in a hypothetical 12-team NFBC league and generated an overall list. I still haven’t adjusted catchers for position scarcity (or reduced DHs), so the hitters are by-the-numbers only. Moreover, I changed the dollar values for hitters slightly as I used a 66/34 split (what I discovered the NFBC drafters were using last year), rather than the 67/33 one I used last night. I also was lazy and just used last year’s $293.36 that was spent on closers for this year’s closer budget.

Here are the results:

Rk Name ADP $ Diff Rk Name ADP $ Diff Rk Name ADP $ Diff
1 Mike Trout 1.1 46.78 0 151 Michael Wacha 237.9 7.87 -87 301 Chris Stratton 537.6 -1.55 -237
2 Giancarlo Stanton 9 43.09 -7 152 Delino DeShields 220.8 7.77 -69 302 Jason Heyward 408.2 -1.64 -106
3 Clayton Kershaw 7 39.54 -4 153 Brett Gardner 180.8 7.69 -28 303 Dylan Bundy 193.4 -1.71 110
4 Nolan Arenado 5.3 37.99 -1 154 Brad Hand 117.1 7.69 37 304 Melky Cabrera 303.2 -1.94 1
5 Manny Machado 19.1 35.56 -14 155 Ryan Braun 111.9 7.67 43 305 Patrick Corbin 240.6 -1.96 64
6 Trea Turner 5.2 35.55 1 156 Lance McCullers 155.7 7.64 0 306 Kyle Gibson 467.1 -2.04 -161
7 Bryce Harper 8.4 34.91 -1 157 Ian Happ 139.7 7.63 17 307 Eduardo Nunez 129.9 -2.09 177
8 Mookie Betts 8.6 34.83 -1 158 Yoan Moncada 134.3 7.57 24 308 John Lackey 447.7 -2.16 -140
9 Paul Goldschmidt 4.3 34.17 5 159 Blake Snell 217.9 7.46 -59 309 Mike Foltynewicz 351.9 -2.19 -43
10 Chris Sale 12.8 33.54 -3 160 Trevor Bauer 145.6 7.41 14 310 Walker Buehler 362.4 -2.21 -52
11 Jose Altuve 2.1 33.44 9 161 Gio Gonzalez 142.9 7.39 18 311 Ben Zobrist 450.9 -2.24 -140
12 Max Scherzer 10.5 32.22 2 162 Chris Davis 248.1 7.34 -86 312 Kolten Wong 377.2 -2.29 -65
13 Kris Bryant 15.5 31.47 -3 163 Kole Calhoun 285.4 7.21 -122 313 Kirby Yates 461.3 -2.32 -148
14 Charlie Blackmon 8.4 31.38 6 164 David Robertson 286 7.18 -122 314 Joe Biagini 613.2 -2.43 -299
15 Anthony Rizzo 24.7 31.14 -10 165 Matt Carpenter 185.4 7.08 -20 315 Carl Edwards Jr. 340.5 -2.44 -26
16 Francisco Lindor 21.3 30.66 -5 166 Jay Bruce 163.8 7.06 2 316 Adalberto Mejia 588.1 -2.47 -272
17 Jose Ramirez 19.5 28.68 -3 167 Jorge Polanco 204.8 7.04 -38 317 Zack Godley 133.4 -2.64 184
18 Corey Kluber 13.5 28.43 5 168 Danny Salazar 172.3 7.02 -4 318 Zach Davies 295.5 -2.75 23
19 Craig Kimbrel 45.1 27.90 -26 169 Paul DeJong 150.6 6.98 18 319 Ervin Santana 183.9 -2.78 135
20 Noah Syndergaard 33.7 27.27 -14 170 Willson Contreras 53.7 6.97 116 320 Tommy Kahnle 455.3 -2.88 -135
21 Josh Donaldson 28.5 27.06 -8 171 Sonny Gray 145 6.85 26 321 Dillon Peters 529.5 -2.88 -209
22 Kenley Jansen 37.9 27.05 -16 172 Rick Porcello 236.2 6.82 -64 322 Tim Beckham 270 -2.99 52
23 Carlos Correa 13.9 26.73 9 173 Alex Wood 103.2 6.80 70 323 Steven Souza Jr. 180.5 -3.00 143
24 Joey Votto 18.5 26.52 6 174 Cesar Hernandez 252.7 6.75 -79 324 Devon Travis 404.6 -3.01 -81
25 Christian Yelich 69 26.49 -44 175 Jake Arrieta 94.4 6.69 81 325 Yadier Molina 148.7 -3.03 176
26 Jose Abreu 42.8 25.95 -17 176 Gregory Bird 154.9 6.67 21 326 Fernando Rodney 243.4 -3.07 83
27 Starling Marte 50.8 25.57 -24 177 Josh Reddick 264.1 6.64 -87 327 Jorge Bonifacio 399.1 -3.07 -72
28 George Springer 31 25.14 -3 178 Manuel Margot 149.8 6.63 28 328 Brad Peacock 212.2 -3.07 116
29 Jacob deGrom 34.8 24.77 -6 179 Jose Peraza 201.7 6.12 -23 329 Lance Lynn 217.2 -3.11 112
30 Marcell Ozuna 48.3 24.64 -18 180 Danny Duffy 177.9 5.89 2 330 Brad Brach 229.5 -3.21 101
31 Stephen Strasburg 25 24.54 6 181 Luis Castillo 105 5.88 76 331 Alex Cobb 222.8 -3.23 108
32 Nelson Cruz 54.2 24.34 -22 182 Jackie Bradley Jr. 282.7 5.82 -101 332 Jonathan Villar 187.8 -3.25 144
33 Aaron Judge 17.6 24.30 15 183 Drew Pomeranz 184.1 5.75 -1 333 Josh Hader 306.5 -3.26 27
34 Andrew Benintendi 42.2 23.98 -8 184 Kyle Schwarber 185.1 5.66 -1 334 Joc Pederson 369.2 -3.29 -35
35 Rhys Hoskins 50.8 23.86 -16 185 J.A. Happ 256.4 5.52 -71 335 Jacob Barnes 612.7 -3.31 -278
36 Freddie Freeman 22.1 23.14 14 186 Dexter Fowler 254.6 5.49 -69 336 Phil Maton 627.2 -3.35 -291
37 Aroldis Chapman 64.9 23.05 -28 187 Matt Chapman 280.6 5.01 -94 337 Juan Nicasio 420.9 -3.41 -84
38 Brian Dozier 38.5 22.87 -1 188 Billy Hamilton 58.6 4.98 129 338 CC Sabathia 352.8 -3.45 -15
39 Eric Hosmer 68.4 22.70 -29 189 Josh Harrison 267.1 4.95 -78 339 Adam Wainwright 459.5 -3.59 -121
40 Luis Severino 33.3 22.52 7 190 Salvador Perez 98.7 4.95 91 340 Adam Frazier 402 -3.63 -62
41 Cody Bellinger 24.5 22.36 17 191 Scott Schebler 276.8 4.87 -86 341 Yasmany Tomas 315.8 -3.80 25
42 Alex Bregman 33.2 22.15 9 192 Michael Brantley 250.5 4.84 -59 342 Tim Anderson 193.1 -3.84 149
43 J.D. Martinez 24.2 21.93 19 193 Joe Musgrove 393 4.73 -200 343 Brandon Woodruff 378.6 -3.89 -36
44 Chris Archer 52.3 21.85 -8 194 Starlin Castro 258.5 4.65 -65 344 Luis Perdomo 509.7 -3.92 -166
45 Jose Quintana 76.3 21.74 -31 195 Chris Devenski 290.4 4.41 -95 345 Lucas Duda 445.4 -3.93 -100
46 Justin Verlander 38 21.64 8 196 Kendrys Morales 297.7 4.38 -102 346 Victor Martinez 552.6 -3.94 -207
47 Edwin Encarnacion 56.6 20.35 -10 197 Charlie Morton 172.9 4.29 24 347 Jerad Eickhoff 376.7 -4.01 -30
48 Corey Knebel 61.3 20.34 -13 198 Dellin Betances 274.5 4.29 -77 348 Nick Markakis 428.7 -4.06 -81
49 Madison Bumgarner 26 20.30 23 199 Kevin Gausman 206.5 4.25 -8 349 Nate Jones 412.6 -4.10 -64
50 Carlos Carrasco 36.2 20.23 14 200 Michael Conforto 170.3 4.20 30 350 Jake Odorizzi 278.6 -4.10 71
51 Jonathan Schoop 62.8 20.10 -12 201 Garrett Richards 183.8 4.17 17 351 Vince Velasquez 370.7 -4.12 -20
52 Corey Seager 39 19.83 13 202 Mitch Haniger 212.1 4.03 -10 352 Brock Stewart 537.1 -4.12 -185
53 Ken Giles 98 19.60 -45 203 Willie Calhoun 271.4 3.99 -68 353 Logan Morrison 286.8 -4.25 66
54 Robinson Cano 83 19.48 -29 204 Clayton Richard 503.6 3.95 -300 354 Seth Lugo 546.8 -4.33 -193
55 Andrew Miller 210.2 19.23 -155 205 Andrelton Simmons 187.3 3.92 18 355 Yonder Alonso 306.8 -4.35 48
56 Andrew McCutchen 83.3 19.19 -27 206 Michael Fulmer 192.8 3.86 13 356 Daniel Norris 449.3 -4.36 -93
57 Wil Myers 71.7 19.11 -15 207 Jedd Gyorko 355.4 3.85 -148 357 Troy Tulowitzki 380.3 -4.41 -23
58 Edwin Diaz 90.9 18.73 -33 208 Taijuan Walker 222.3 3.73 -14 358 Jason Vargas 449.7 -4.44 -92
59 Ian Desmond 114.4 18.47 -55 209 Tyler Skaggs 372.5 3.73 -164 359 Blake Treinen 199.2 -4.50 160
60 A.J. Pollock 63.3 18.16 -3 210 Orlando Arcia 189.4 3.66 21 360 Drew Steckenrider 366.2 -4.52 -6
61 Jeff Samardzija 140.1 18.16 -79 211 Wade Davis 102.9 3.51 108 361 Chad Green 287.1 -4.53 74
62 Dee Gordon 28.1 17.98 34 212 Randal Grichuk 356.7 3.43 -145 362 Carlos Rodon 366.5 -4.55 -5
63 DJ LeMahieu 129.7 17.96 -67 213 Tanner Roark 262.6 3.35 -50 363 Brent Suter 536.3 -4.56 -173
64 Khris Davis 69.4 17.75 -5 214 Todd Frazier 287.4 3.16 -73 364 Joakim Soria 392.8 -4.57 -29
65 Felipe Rivero 92.5 17.67 -28 215 Jose Berrios 111 3.16 104 365 Austin Hays 361.3 -4.60 4
66 Joey Gallo 115.9 17.64 -50 216 Jason Kipnis 260.2 3.13 -44 366 Aaron Sanchez 222.9 -4.63 143
67 Zack Greinke 45.6 17.57 21 217 Bradley Zimmer 204.9 2.97 12 367 Alex Gordon 517.3 -4.74 -150
68 Nomar Mazara 160.5 17.40 -93 218 Joe Panik 376.5 2.96 -159 368 Ryon Healy 192.9 -4.76 175
69 Rougned Odor 110.9 17.40 -42 219 Luiz Gohara 287.8 2.95 -69 369 Mike Zunino 163.9 -4.85 205
70 David Price 123.1 17.16 -53 220 J.T. Realmuto 103.4 2.68 117 370 Mike Minor 302.4 -4.85 68
71 Justin Upton 46.6 16.88 24 221 Dinelson Lamet 216.9 2.65 4 371 Doug Fister 554.8 -4.85 -184
72 Yu Darvish 51.5 16.84 21 222 Kevin Pillar 318.3 2.57 -96 372 Darren O’Day 564.4 -4.94 -192
73 Yoenis Cespedes 96.4 16.81 -23 223 Kenta Maeda 199.5 2.52 24 373 Bryan Shaw 559.9 -5.22 -187
74 James Paxton 77.3 16.45 -3 224 Arodys Vizcaino 149.9 2.49 74 374 Nick Williams 271.1 -5.22 103
75 Anthony Rendon 57.8 16.36 17 225 Mitch Moreland 402 2.45 -177 375 Bryan Mitchell 525.5 -5.25 -151
76 Justin Turner 85.7 16.24 -10 226 Adam Duvall 170 2.42 56 376 C.J. Cron 394.8 -5.25 -19
77 Carlos Martinez 53.9 16.22 23 227 Max Kepler 273 2.34 -46 377 Matt Joyce 492.7 -5.32 -116
78 Miguel Cabrera 94.1 16.18 -16 228 Alex Colome 117.4 2.33 111 378 Tyler Mahle 407 -5.41 -29
79 Elvis Andrus 56.4 16.15 23 229 Jeurys Familia 176 2.30 53 379 Albert Almora Jr. 375.9 -5.42 3
80 Adam Jones 145.7 15.65 -66 230 Cole Hamels 236.5 2.15 -7 380 Santiago Casilla 623.5 -5.45 -244
81 Yasiel Puig 112.2 15.31 -31 231 Sean Manaea 252.4 2.08 -21 381 Jose Pirela 387.1 -5.52 -6
82 Eddie Rosario 118.4 15.16 -36 232 Mike Clevinger 218.5 1.97 14 382 Jhoulys Chacin 354.1 -5.90 28
83 Jon Lester 119.8 15.02 -37 233 Dan Straily 316.9 1.94 -84 383 Tommy Hunter 585.1 -5.91 -202
84 Dallas Keuchel 77.3 15.02 7 234 Kelvin Herrera 208 1.81 26 384 Kendall Graveman 483.6 -6.00 -100
85 Roberto Osuna 79.3 15.00 6 235 Brent Honeywell 275.3 1.64 -40 385 Tyler Lyons 419.5 -6.02 -35
86 Robbie Ray 45.9 14.94 40 236 Scott Alexander 632 1.54 -396 386 Mikie Mahtook 335 -6.05 51
87 Carlos Santana 172.8 14.88 -86 237 Cam Bedrosian 331.5 1.50 -95 387 Nick Goody 617.5 -6.13 -231
88 Gary Sanchez 20.7 14.86 67 238 Joe Mauer 392 1.47 -154 388 J.P. Crawford 378.6 -6.14 9
89 Lorenzo Cain 99 14.85 -10 239 Jordan Montgomery 250.4 1.45 -11 389 Tyler Glasnow 374.7 -6.18 14
90 Xander Bogaerts 86.4 14.83 4 240 Jaime Garcia 534.9 1.40 -295 390 Juan Minaya 336.9 -6.34 53
91 Sean Doolittle 132.6 14.61 -42 241 Brandon Crawford 327.9 1.27 -87 391 Andrew Triggs 486.2 -6.39 -95
92 Aaron Nola 67.9 14.42 24 242 Miles Mikolas 322.8 1.27 -81 392 Mychal Givens 395.1 -6.41 -3
93 Kyle Seager 134.2 14.42 -41 243 Marwin Gonzalez 114.7 1.23 128 393 Carson Smith 597.1 -6.53 -204
94 Tommy Pham 61.4 14.03 33 244 Hyun-Jin Ryu 340 1.18 -96 394 Jason Hammel 538.8 -6.53 -145
95 Domingo Santana 74.8 14.03 20 245 Stephen Piscotty 297.6 1.08 -53 395 Erasmo Ramirez 456.6 -6.58 -62
96 Nick Castellanos 103.7 13.84 -8 246 Sean Newcomb 326.7 1.04 -81 396 Jordy Mercer 505 -6.60 -109
97 Justin Smoak 147.2 13.70 -50 247 Archie Bradley 189.5 0.89 58 397 Ian Kennedy 457.5 -6.60 -61
98 Whit Merrifield 70.6 13.63 27 248 Nick Pivetta 434.7 0.68 -187 398 Hunter Renfroe 298 -6.63 100
99 Kevin Kiermaier 159.3 13.54 -60 249 David Dahl 247.4 0.67 2 399 Matt Harvey 367.8 -6.65 31
100 Josh Bell 178.2 13.40 -78 250 Evan Gattis 156.9 0.67 93 400 Jimmie Sherfy 550.2 -6.77 -150
101 Daniel Murphy 67.2 13.37 34 251 Jed Lowrie 427.1 0.61 -176 401 Raimel Tapia 389.2 -6.85 12
102 Adrian Beltre 158.9 13.28 -57 252 Felix Hernandez 287.2 0.60 -35 402 Erick Fedde 619.3 -6.91 -217
103 Jake Lamb 117.8 13.09 -15 253 Jake Faria 239.6 0.49 13 403 Kyle Freeland 533.8 -6.95 -131
104 Byron Buxton 53 13.08 51 254 Corey Dickerson 216 0.45 38 404 Nathan Karns 483.5 -6.99 -80
105 Evan Longoria 198.7 13.01 -94 255 Michael Taylor 217.8 0.43 37 405 Robert Stephenson 453.3 -7.13 -48
106 Masahiro Tanaka 104.4 12.96 2 256 Alex Reyes 258.8 0.42 -3 406 Matt Andriese 477.2 -7.14 -71
107 Shohei Ohtani 74.7 12.93 32 257 Tyler Anderson 423.2 0.37 -166 407 JC Ramirez 531.6 -7.20 -125
108 Mike Moustakas 109.8 12.79 -2 258 Hector Neris 144.1 0.21 114 408 Lonnie Chisenhall 390.1 -7.21 18
109 Odubel Herrera 212.4 12.34 -103 259 Ronald Acuna 133.2 0.04 126 409 Jose Urena 415.6 -7.23 -7
110 Brandon Morrow 225.1 12.09 -115 260 Aaron Altherr 251 0.04 9 410 Homer Bailey 531.8 -7.27 -122
111 Jon Gray 166.8 11.74 -56 261 Anthony Swarzak 457.8 -0.01 -197 411 Dominic Leone 543.4 -7.27 -132
112 Marcus Stroman 122.4 11.69 -10 262 Mark Trumbo 248.8 -0.01 13 412 Ryan Tepera 598.4 -7.27 -186
113 Trey Mancini 158.4 11.37 -45 263 Brad Boxberger 324.5 -0.10 -62 413 Mark Leiter 566.2 -7.33 -153
114 Trevor Story 115.1 11.28 -1 264 Jorge Soler 472.8 -0.13 -209 414 Steve Cishek 524.6 -7.35 -111
115 Cody Allen 102.3 11.12 13 265 Dustin Pedroia 438 -0.20 -173 415 Sam Dyson 522.7 -7.36 -108
116 Rafael Devers 128.3 11.02 -12 266 Aaron Hicks 237 -0.21 29 416 Jose Martinez 279 -7.45 137
117 Jameson Taillon 198.3 10.97 -81 267 Luke Gregerson 369.8 -0.25 -103 417 Michael Kopech 326.9 -7.75 90
118 Jean Segura 78.4 10.95 40 268 Chase Anderson 169.6 -0.29 98 418 Ross Stripling 632.5 -7.76 -215
119 Shin-Soo Choo 253.4 10.87 -134 269 Andrew Heaney 432.9 -0.32 -164 419 Will Harris 546.3 -7.86 -127
120 Avisail Garcia 192.2 10.78 -72 270 Brandon McCarthy 443.8 -0.34 -174 420 Jonathan Lucroy 180 -7.92 240
121 Matt Olson 120.7 10.66 0 271 Addison Russell 250.4 -0.34 21 421 Koda Glover 621.2 -7.97 -200
122 Rich Hill 121.2 10.58 1 272 Marco Estrada 313.4 -0.36 -41 422 Pedro Strop 606.5 -7.97 -185
123 Yulieski Gurriel 207.5 10.51 -85 273 Jakob Junis 385.7 -0.40 -113 423 Mike Fiers 529.4 -7.99 -106
124 Travis Shaw 94.6 10.24 29 274 Anthony DeSclafani 419.6 -0.52 -146 424 Josh Tomlin 453.5 -8.00 -30
125 Adam Eaton 155.1 10.03 -30 275 Chad Kuhl 401.5 -0.54 -127 425 Trevor Cahill 566.4 -8.03 -141
126 Eric Thames 187.1 10.03 -61 276 Mike Leake 324.3 -0.57 -48 426 Collin McHugh 334.4 -8.06 92
127 Gerrit Cole 90.5 9.99 37 277 Brandon Phillips 373.2 -0.58 -96 427 Nick Delmonico 460.9 -8.11 -34
128 David Peralta 253.3 9.66 -125 278 Hunter Pence 454.1 -0.64 -176 428 Matt Boyd 519.9 -8.12 -92
129 Ender Inciarte 118.5 9.59 11 279 Mark Melancon 177.1 -0.65 102 429 Curtis Granderson 527 -8.29 -98
130 Johnny Cueto 151.1 9.39 -21 280 Matt Shoemaker 332 -0.72 -52 430 Lewis Brinson 333.8 -8.38 96
131 Ryan Madson 430 9.29 -299 281 Ivan Nova 347.2 -0.74 -66 431 Brad Miller 459.9 -8.46 -29
132 Gregory Polanco 163.4 9.26 -31 282 Cheslor Cuthbert 577.8 -0.76 -296 432 A.J. Ramos 364.7 -8.57 67
133 Buster Posey 59.7 9.20 73 283 Asdrubal Cabrera 305.8 -0.81 -23 433 Logan Forsythe 427.5 -8.60 6
134 Chris Taylor 91.7 8.94 42 284 German Marquez 336 -0.86 -52 434 Seung Hwan Oh 502.1 -8.61 -68
135 Marcus Semien 230.5 8.93 -96 285 Ketel Marte 355.4 -0.90 -70 435 Matt Moore 441.5 -8.62 -7
136 Blake Parker 213.8 8.92 -78 286 Tyler Chatwood 289.4 -0.95 -3 436 Martin Prado 551.4 -8.66 -115
137 Maikel Franco 236.6 8.90 -100 287 Pat Neshek 514.9 -1.01 -228 437 Jordan Zimmermann 597.6 -8.74 -161
138 Raisel Iglesias 102.3 8.72 36 288 Zack Wheeler 440.2 -1.04 -152 438 Ben Gamel 424.8 -8.79 13
139 Justin Bour 192.2 8.62 -53 289 Neil Walker 411.5 -1.10 -123 439 Addison Reed 265.3 -8.80 174
140 Eugenio Suarez 190.6 8.47 -51 290 Scooter Gennett 197.6 -1.13 92 440 Dansby Swanson 385.4 -8.84 55
141 Kyle Hendricks 117.3 8.44 24 291 Shane Greene 242.5 -1.18 49 441 Steve Pearce 551.1 -8.89 -110
142 Ian Kinsler 191.1 8.30 -49 292 Zack Cozart 225.6 -1.18 66 442 Lucas Giolito 224.6 -8.96 217
143 Javier Baez 102.3 8.29 41 293 Jharel Cotton 397 -1.22 -104 443 Jimmy Nelson 292.1 -8.98 151
144 Luke Weaver 110.1 8.27 34 294 Albert Pujols 311 -1.25 -17 444 Trevor Williams 475.2 -9.13 -31
145 Miguel Sano 97.7 8.18 47 295 Justin Wilson 575.1 -1.33 -280 445 Russell Martin 321 -9.24 124
146 Hanley Ramirez 328.1 8.11 -182 296 Kyle Barraclough 315.2 -1.36 -19 446 Eduardo Rodriguez 343.9 -9.34 102
147 Ozzie Albies 145 8.04 2 297 Amed Rosario 232.8 -1.43 64 447 Jack Flaherty 372.1 -9.36 75
148 Ryan Zimmerman 126.2 7.97 22 298 Julio Teheran 238.5 -1.48 60 448 Brad Ziegler 406.9 -9.38 41
149 Brandon Belt 304.1 7.95 -155 299 A.J. Minter 443.1 -1.54 -144 449 Carlos Gonzalez 287.7 -9.49 161
150 Didi Gregorius 113.9 7.91 36 300 Mike Montgomery 364.6 -1.55 -65 450 Trevor Hildenberger 399.9 -9.69 50

Players with the biggest negative differential – (my formula’s interpretation of the Steamer Projections minus NFBC ADP) are the ones Steamer likes. Players with the biggest positive differentials are the ones NFBC drafters like. Keep in mind the differentials are not all created equal as those near the top carry much more weight, i.e., Stanton’s minus 7 from nine to two, is worth $9 (or at least he’s $9 more valuable per Steamer projections than No. 9 player Paul Goldschmidt.) Contrast that with 189th-ranked Josh Harrison worth $4.95, which is only $5.20 more than the 267th player (his NFBC ADP) worth -$.25. Nonetheless it’s worth seeing who the outliers are for both sides.

Here are the top-150 players (by Steamer’s ranks through my formula) sorted from most to least Steamer friendly relative to NFBC:

Rk Name ADP $ Diff Rk Name ADP $ Diff Rk Name ADP $ Diff
131 Ryan Madson 430 9.29 -299 19 Craig Kimbrel 45.1 27.90 -26 90 Xander Bogaerts 86.4 14.83 4
146 Hanley Ramirez 328.1 8.11 -182 27 Starling Marte 50.8 25.57 -24 18 Corey Kluber 13.5 28.43 5
55 Andrew Miller 210.2 19.23 -155 73 Yoenis Cespedes 96.4 16.81 -23 9 Paul Goldschmidt 4.3 34.17 5
149 Brandon Belt 304.1 7.95 -155 32 Nelson Cruz 54.2 24.34 -22 24 Joey Votto 18.5 26.52 6
119 Shin-Soo Choo 253.4 10.87 -134 130 Johnny Cueto 151.1 9.39 -21 14 Charlie Blackmon 8.4 31.38 6
128 David Peralta 253.3 9.66 -125 30 Marcell Ozuna 48.3 24.64 -18 85 Roberto Osuna 79.3 15.00 6
110 Brandon Morrow 225.1 12.09 -115 26 Jose Abreu 42.8 25.95 -17 31 Stephen Strasburg 25 24.54 6
109 Odubel Herrera 212.4 12.34 -103 78 Miguel Cabrera 94.1 16.18 -16 40 Luis Severino 33.3 22.52 7
137 Maikel Franco 236.6 8.90 -100 22 Kenley Jansen 37.9 27.05 -16 84 Dallas Keuchel 77.3 15.02 7
135 Marcus Semien 230.5 8.93 -96 35 Rhys Hoskins 50.8 23.86 -16 46 Justin Verlander 38 21.64 8
105 Evan Longoria 198.7 13.01 -94 103 Jake Lamb 117.8 13.09 -15 42 Alex Bregman 33.2 22.15 9
68 Nomar Mazara 160.5 17.40 -93 57 Wil Myers 71.7 19.11 -15 11 Jose Altuve 2.1 33.44 9
87 Carlos Santana 172.8 14.88 -86 5 Manny Machado 19.1 35.56 -14 23 Carlos Correa 13.9 26.73 9
123 Yulieski Gurriel 207.5 10.51 -85 20 Noah Syndergaard 33.7 27.27 -14 129 Ender Inciarte 118.5 9.59 11
117 Jameson Taillon 198.3 10.97 -81 48 Corey Knebel 61.3 20.34 -13 115 Cody Allen 102.3 11.12 13
61 Jeff Samardzija 140.1 18.16 -79 116 Rafael Devers 128.3 11.02 -12 52 Corey Seager 39 19.83 13
100 Josh Bell 178.2 13.40 -78 51 Jonathan Schoop 62.8 20.10 -12 50 Carlos Carrasco 36.2 20.23 14
136 Blake Parker 213.8 8.92 -78 112 Marcus Stroman 122.4 11.69 -10 36 Freddie Freeman 22.1 23.14 14
120 Avisail Garcia 192.2 10.78 -72 89 Lorenzo Cain 99 14.85 -10 33 Aaron Judge 17.6 24.30 15
63 DJ LeMahieu 129.7 17.96 -67 76 Justin Turner 85.7 16.24 -10 41 Cody Bellinger 24.5 22.36 17
80 Adam Jones 145.7 15.65 -66 15 Anthony Rizzo 24.7 31.14 -10 75 Anthony Rendon 57.8 16.36 17
126 Eric Thames 187.1 10.03 -61 47 Edwin Encarnacion 56.6 20.35 -10 43 J.D. Martinez 24.2 21.93 19
99 Kevin Kiermaier 159.3 13.54 -60 44 Chris Archer 52.3 21.85 -8 95 Domingo Santana 74.8 14.03 20
102 Adrian Beltre 158.9 13.28 -57 34 Andrew Benintendi 42.2 23.98 -8 72 Yu Darvish 51.5 16.84 21
111 Jon Gray 166.8 11.74 -56 96 Nick Castellanos 103.7 13.84 -8 67 Zack Greinke 45.6 17.57 21
59 Ian Desmond 114.4 18.47 -55 21 Josh Donaldson 28.5 27.06 -8 148 Ryan Zimmerman 126.2 7.97 22
139 Justin Bour 192.2 8.62 -53 2 Giancarlo Stanton 9 43.09 -7 79 Elvis Andrus 56.4 16.15 23
70 David Price 123.1 17.16 -53 29 Jacob deGrom 34.8 24.77 -6 49 Madison Bumgarner 26 20.30 23
140 Eugenio Suarez 190.6 8.47 -51 64 Khris Davis 69.4 17.75 -5 77 Carlos Martinez 53.9 16.22 23
97 Justin Smoak 147.2 13.70 -50 16 Francisco Lindor 21.3 30.66 -5 141 Kyle Hendricks 117.3 8.44 24
66 Joey Gallo 115.9 17.64 -50 3 Clayton Kershaw 7 39.54 -4 92 Aaron Nola 67.9 14.42 24
142 Ian Kinsler 191.1 8.30 -49 60 A.J. Pollock 63.3 18.16 -3 71 Justin Upton 46.6 16.88 24
113 Trey Mancini 158.4 11.37 -45 74 James Paxton 77.3 16.45 -3 98 Whit Merrifield 70.6 13.63 27
53 Ken Giles 98 19.60 -45 28 George Springer 31 25.14 -3 124 Travis Shaw 94.6 10.24 29
25 Christian Yelich 69 26.49 -44 10 Chris Sale 12.8 33.54 -3 107 Shohei Ohtani 74.7 12.93 32
69 Rougned Odor 110.9 17.40 -42 13 Kris Bryant 15.5 31.47 -3 94 Tommy Pham 61.4 14.03 33
91 Sean Doolittle 132.6 14.61 -42 17 Jose Ramirez 19.5 28.68 -3 101 Daniel Murphy 67.2 13.37 34
93 Kyle Seager 134.2 14.42 -41 108 Mike Moustakas 109.8 12.79 -2 62 Dee Gordon 28.1 17.98 34
83 Jon Lester 119.8 15.02 -37 7 Bryce Harper 8.4 34.91 -1 144 Luke Weaver 110.1 8.27 34
82 Eddie Rosario 118.4 15.16 -36 4 Nolan Arenado 5.3 37.99 -1 138 Raisel Iglesias 102.3 8.72 36
58 Edwin Diaz 90.9 18.73 -33 114 Trevor Story 115.1 11.28 -1 150 Didi Gregorius 113.9 7.91 36
132 Gregory Polanco 163.4 9.26 -31 8 Mookie Betts 8.6 34.83 -1 127 Gerrit Cole 90.5 9.99 37
45 Jose Quintana 76.3 21.74 -31 38 Brian Dozier 38.5 22.87 -1 118 Jean Segura 78.4 10.95 40
81 Yasiel Puig 112.2 15.31 -31 1 Mike Trout 1.1 46.78 0 86 Robbie Ray 45.9 14.94 40
125 Adam Eaton 155.1 10.03 -30 121 Matt Olson 120.7 10.66 0 143 Javier Baez 102.3 8.29 41
39 Eric Hosmer 68.4 22.70 -29 122 Rich Hill 121.2 10.58 1 134 Chris Taylor 91.7 8.94 42
54 Robinson Cano 83 19.48 -29 6 Trea Turner 5.2 35.55 1 145 Miguel Sano 97.7 8.18 47
37 Aroldis Chapman 64.9 23.05 -28 12 Max Scherzer 10.5 32.22 2 104 Byron Buxton 53 13.08 51
65 Felipe Rivero 92.5 17.67 -28 106 Masahiro Tanaka 104.4 12.96 2 88 Gary Sanchez 20.7 14.86 67
56 Andrew McCutchen 83.3 19.19 -27 147 Ozzie Albies 145 8.04 2 133 Buster Posey 59.7 9.20 73

Again, note the lack of catcher adjustment which is why Buster Posey and Gary Sanchez are the two most NFBC-friendly. Relief pitchers are also tricky because some of Steamer’s projections for saves are a little wacky and out of step with who NFBC drafters think is likely to secure the job. Still, for hitters and workhorse starting pitchers you can see where the two approaches diverge.