Overall Steamer Ranks (Without Catcher Adjustment)

Written by

Published on February 7, 2018

Yesterday I ran the Steamer hitter numbers and compared them to NFBC ADP. Today, I quickly ran Steamer's numbers for pitchers and hitters through my formula, adjusting for closer scarcity in a hypothetical 12-team NFBC league and generated an overall list. I still haven't adjusted catchers for position scarcity (or reduced DHs), so the hitters are by-the-numbers only. Moreover, I changed the dollar values for hitters slightly as I used a 66/34 split (what I discovered the NFBC drafters were using last year), rather than the 67/33 one I used last night. I also was lazy and just used last year's $293.36 that was spent on closers for this year's closer budget.

Here are the results:

Rk	Name	ADP	$	Diff	Rk	Name	ADP	$	Diff	Rk	Name	ADP	$	Diff
1	Mike Trout	1.1	46.78	0	151	Michael Wacha	237.9	7.87	-87	301	Chris Stratton	537.6	-1.55	-237
2	Giancarlo Stanton	9	43.09	-7	152	Delino DeShields	220.8	7.77	-69	302	Jason Heyward	408.2	-1.64	-106
3	Clayton Kershaw	7	39.54	-4	153	Brett Gardner	180.8	7.69	-28	303	Dylan Bundy	193.4	-1.71	110
4	Nolan Arenado	5.3	37.99	-1	154	Brad Hand	117.1	7.69	37	304	Melky Cabrera	303.2	-1.94	1
5	Manny Machado	19.1	35.56	-14	155	Ryan Braun	111.9	7.67	43	305	Patrick Corbin	240.6	-1.96	64
6	Trea Turner	5.2	35.55	1	156	Lance McCullers	155.7	7.64	0	306	Kyle Gibson	467.1	-2.04	-161
7	Bryce Harper	8.4	34.91	-1	157	Ian Happ	139.7	7.63	17	307	Eduardo Nunez	129.9	-2.09	177
8	Mookie Betts	8.6	34.83	-1	158	Yoan Moncada	134.3	7.57	24	308	John Lackey	447.7	-2.16	-140
9	Paul Goldschmidt	4.3	34.17	5	159	Blake Snell	217.9	7.46	-59	309	Mike Foltynewicz	351.9	-2.19	-43
10	Chris Sale	12.8	33.54	-3	160	Trevor Bauer	145.6	7.41	14	310	Walker Buehler	362.4	-2.21	-52
11	Jose Altuve	2.1	33.44	9	161	Gio Gonzalez	142.9	7.39	18	311	Ben Zobrist	450.9	-2.24	-140
12	Max Scherzer	10.5	32.22	2	162	Chris Davis	248.1	7.34	-86	312	Kolten Wong	377.2	-2.29	-65
13	Kris Bryant	15.5	31.47	-3	163	Kole Calhoun	285.4	7.21	-122	313	Kirby Yates	461.3	-2.32	-148
14	Charlie Blackmon	8.4	31.38	6	164	David Robertson	286	7.18	-122	314	Joe Biagini	613.2	-2.43	-299
15	Anthony Rizzo	24.7	31.14	-10	165	Matt Carpenter	185.4	7.08	-20	315	Carl Edwards Jr.	340.5	-2.44	-26
16	Francisco Lindor	21.3	30.66	-5	166	Jay Bruce	163.8	7.06	2	316	Adalberto Mejia	588.1	-2.47	-272
17	Jose Ramirez	19.5	28.68	-3	167	Jorge Polanco	204.8	7.04	-38	317	Zack Godley	133.4	-2.64	184
18	Corey Kluber	13.5	28.43	5	168	Danny Salazar	172.3	7.02	-4	318	Zach Davies	295.5	-2.75	23
19	Craig Kimbrel	45.1	27.90	-26	169	Paul DeJong	150.6	6.98	18	319	Ervin Santana	183.9	-2.78	135
20	Noah Syndergaard	33.7	27.27	-14	170	Willson Contreras	53.7	6.97	116	320	Tommy Kahnle	455.3	-2.88	-135
21	Josh Donaldson	28.5	27.06	-8	171	Sonny Gray	145	6.85	26	321	Dillon Peters	529.5	-2.88	-209
22	Kenley Jansen	37.9	27.05	-16	172	Rick Porcello	236.2	6.82	-64	322	Tim Beckham	270	-2.99	52
23	Carlos Correa	13.9	26.73	9	173	Alex Wood	103.2	6.80	70	323	Steven Souza Jr.	180.5	-3.00	143
24	Joey Votto	18.5	26.52	6	174	Cesar Hernandez	252.7	6.75	-79	324	Devon Travis	404.6	-3.01	-81
25	Christian Yelich	69	26.49	-44	175	Jake Arrieta	94.4	6.69	81	325	Yadier Molina	148.7	-3.03	176
26	Jose Abreu	42.8	25.95	-17	176	Gregory Bird	154.9	6.67	21	326	Fernando Rodney	243.4	-3.07	83
27	Starling Marte	50.8	25.57	-24	177	Josh Reddick	264.1	6.64	-87	327	Jorge Bonifacio	399.1	-3.07	-72
28	George Springer	31	25.14	-3	178	Manuel Margot	149.8	6.63	28	328	Brad Peacock	212.2	-3.07	116
29	Jacob deGrom	34.8	24.77	-6	179	Jose Peraza	201.7	6.12	-23	329	Lance Lynn	217.2	-3.11	112
30	Marcell Ozuna	48.3	24.64	-18	180	Danny Duffy	177.9	5.89	2	330	Brad Brach	229.5	-3.21	101
31	Stephen Strasburg	25	24.54	6	181	Luis Castillo	105	5.88	76	331	Alex Cobb	222.8	-3.23	108
32	Nelson Cruz	54.2	24.34	-22	182	Jackie Bradley Jr.	282.7	5.82	-101	332	Jonathan Villar	187.8	-3.25	144
33	Aaron Judge	17.6	24.30	15	183	Drew Pomeranz	184.1	5.75	-1	333	Josh Hader	306.5	-3.26	27
34	Andrew Benintendi	42.2	23.98	-8	184	Kyle Schwarber	185.1	5.66	-1	334	Joc Pederson	369.2	-3.29	-35
35	Rhys Hoskins	50.8	23.86	-16	185	J.A. Happ	256.4	5.52	-71	335	Jacob Barnes	612.7	-3.31	-278
36	Freddie Freeman	22.1	23.14	14	186	Dexter Fowler	254.6	5.49	-69	336	Phil Maton	627.2	-3.35	-291
37	Aroldis Chapman	64.9	23.05	-28	187	Matt Chapman	280.6	5.01	-94	337	Juan Nicasio	420.9	-3.41	-84
38	Brian Dozier	38.5	22.87	-1	188	Billy Hamilton	58.6	4.98	129	338	CC Sabathia	352.8	-3.45	-15
39	Eric Hosmer	68.4	22.70	-29	189	Josh Harrison	267.1	4.95	-78	339	Adam Wainwright	459.5	-3.59	-121
40	Luis Severino	33.3	22.52	7	190	Salvador Perez	98.7	4.95	91	340	Adam Frazier	402	-3.63	-62
41	Cody Bellinger	24.5	22.36	17	191	Scott Schebler	276.8	4.87	-86	341	Yasmany Tomas	315.8	-3.80	25
42	Alex Bregman	33.2	22.15	9	192	Michael Brantley	250.5	4.84	-59	342	Tim Anderson	193.1	-3.84	149
43	J.D. Martinez	24.2	21.93	19	193	Joe Musgrove	393	4.73	-200	343	Brandon Woodruff	378.6	-3.89	-36
44	Chris Archer	52.3	21.85	-8	194	Starlin Castro	258.5	4.65	-65	344	Luis Perdomo	509.7	-3.92	-166
45	Jose Quintana	76.3	21.74	-31	195	Chris Devenski	290.4	4.41	-95	345	Lucas Duda	445.4	-3.93	-100
46	Justin Verlander	38	21.64	8	196	Kendrys Morales	297.7	4.38	-102	346	Victor Martinez	552.6	-3.94	-207
47	Edwin Encarnacion	56.6	20.35	-10	197	Charlie Morton	172.9	4.29	24	347	Jerad Eickhoff	376.7	-4.01	-30
48	Corey Knebel	61.3	20.34	-13	198	Dellin Betances	274.5	4.29	-77	348	Nick Markakis	428.7	-4.06	-81
49	Madison Bumgarner	26	20.30	23	199	Kevin Gausman	206.5	4.25	-8	349	Nate Jones	412.6	-4.10	-64
50	Carlos Carrasco	36.2	20.23	14	200	Michael Conforto	170.3	4.20	30	350	Jake Odorizzi	278.6	-4.10	71
51	Jonathan Schoop	62.8	20.10	-12	201	Garrett Richards	183.8	4.17	17	351	Vince Velasquez	370.7	-4.12	-20
52	Corey Seager	39	19.83	13	202	Mitch Haniger	212.1	4.03	-10	352	Brock Stewart	537.1	-4.12	-185
53	Ken Giles	98	19.60	-45	203	Willie Calhoun	271.4	3.99	-68	353	Logan Morrison	286.8	-4.25	66
54	Robinson Cano	83	19.48	-29	204	Clayton Richard	503.6	3.95	-300	354	Seth Lugo	546.8	-4.33	-193
55	Andrew Miller	210.2	19.23	-155	205	Andrelton Simmons	187.3	3.92	18	355	Yonder Alonso	306.8	-4.35	48
56	Andrew McCutchen	83.3	19.19	-27	206	Michael Fulmer	192.8	3.86	13	356	Daniel Norris	449.3	-4.36	-93
57	Wil Myers	71.7	19.11	-15	207	Jedd Gyorko	355.4	3.85	-148	357	Troy Tulowitzki	380.3	-4.41	-23
58	Edwin Diaz	90.9	18.73	-33	208	Taijuan Walker	222.3	3.73	-14	358	Jason Vargas	449.7	-4.44	-92
59	Ian Desmond	114.4	18.47	-55	209	Tyler Skaggs	372.5	3.73	-164	359	Blake Treinen	199.2	-4.50	160
60	A.J. Pollock	63.3	18.16	-3	210	Orlando Arcia	189.4	3.66	21	360	Drew Steckenrider	366.2	-4.52	-6
61	Jeff Samardzija	140.1	18.16	-79	211	Wade Davis	102.9	3.51	108	361	Chad Green	287.1	-4.53	74
62	Dee Gordon	28.1	17.98	34	212	Randal Grichuk	356.7	3.43	-145	362	Carlos Rodon	366.5	-4.55	-5
63	DJ LeMahieu	129.7	17.96	-67	213	Tanner Roark	262.6	3.35	-50	363	Brent Suter	536.3	-4.56	-173
64	Khris Davis	69.4	17.75	-5	214	Todd Frazier	287.4	3.16	-73	364	Joakim Soria	392.8	-4.57	-29
65	Felipe Rivero	92.5	17.67	-28	215	Jose Berrios	111	3.16	104	365	Austin Hays	361.3	-4.60	4
66	Joey Gallo	115.9	17.64	-50	216	Jason Kipnis	260.2	3.13	-44	366	Aaron Sanchez	222.9	-4.63	143
67	Zack Greinke	45.6	17.57	21	217	Bradley Zimmer	204.9	2.97	12	367	Alex Gordon	517.3	-4.74	-150
68	Nomar Mazara	160.5	17.40	-93	218	Joe Panik	376.5	2.96	-159	368	Ryon Healy	192.9	-4.76	175
69	Rougned Odor	110.9	17.40	-42	219	Luiz Gohara	287.8	2.95	-69	369	Mike Zunino	163.9	-4.85	205
70	David Price	123.1	17.16	-53	220	J.T. Realmuto	103.4	2.68	117	370	Mike Minor	302.4	-4.85	68
71	Justin Upton	46.6	16.88	24	221	Dinelson Lamet	216.9	2.65	4	371	Doug Fister	554.8	-4.85	-184
72	Yu Darvish	51.5	16.84	21	222	Kevin Pillar	318.3	2.57	-96	372	Darren O'Day	564.4	-4.94	-192
73	Yoenis Cespedes	96.4	16.81	-23	223	Kenta Maeda	199.5	2.52	24	373	Bryan Shaw	559.9	-5.22	-187
74	James Paxton	77.3	16.45	-3	224	Arodys Vizcaino	149.9	2.49	74	374	Nick Williams	271.1	-5.22	103
75	Anthony Rendon	57.8	16.36	17	225	Mitch Moreland	402	2.45	-177	375	Bryan Mitchell	525.5	-5.25	-151
76	Justin Turner	85.7	16.24	-10	226	Adam Duvall	170	2.42	56	376	C.J. Cron	394.8	-5.25	-19
77	Carlos Martinez	53.9	16.22	23	227	Max Kepler	273	2.34	-46	377	Matt Joyce	492.7	-5.32	-116
78	Miguel Cabrera	94.1	16.18	-16	228	Alex Colome	117.4	2.33	111	378	Tyler Mahle	407	-5.41	-29
79	Elvis Andrus	56.4	16.15	23	229	Jeurys Familia	176	2.30	53	379	Albert Almora Jr.	375.9	-5.42	3
80	Adam Jones	145.7	15.65	-66	230	Cole Hamels	236.5	2.15	-7	380	Santiago Casilla	623.5	-5.45	-244
81	Yasiel Puig	112.2	15.31	-31	231	Sean Manaea	252.4	2.08	-21	381	Jose Pirela	387.1	-5.52	-6
82	Eddie Rosario	118.4	15.16	-36	232	Mike Clevinger	218.5	1.97	14	382	Jhoulys Chacin	354.1	-5.90	28
83	Jon Lester	119.8	15.02	-37	233	Dan Straily	316.9	1.94	-84	383	Tommy Hunter	585.1	-5.91	-202
84	Dallas Keuchel	77.3	15.02	7	234	Kelvin Herrera	208	1.81	26	384	Kendall Graveman	483.6	-6.00	-100
85	Roberto Osuna	79.3	15.00	6	235	Brent Honeywell	275.3	1.64	-40	385	Tyler Lyons	419.5	-6.02	-35
86	Robbie Ray	45.9	14.94	40	236	Scott Alexander	632	1.54	-396	386	Mikie Mahtook	335	-6.05	51
87	Carlos Santana	172.8	14.88	-86	237	Cam Bedrosian	331.5	1.50	-95	387	Nick Goody	617.5	-6.13	-231
88	Gary Sanchez	20.7	14.86	67	238	Joe Mauer	392	1.47	-154	388	J.P. Crawford	378.6	-6.14	9
89	Lorenzo Cain	99	14.85	-10	239	Jordan Montgomery	250.4	1.45	-11	389	Tyler Glasnow	374.7	-6.18	14
90	Xander Bogaerts	86.4	14.83	4	240	Jaime Garcia	534.9	1.40	-295	390	Juan Minaya	336.9	-6.34	53
91	Sean Doolittle	132.6	14.61	-42	241	Brandon Crawford	327.9	1.27	-87	391	Andrew Triggs	486.2	-6.39	-95
92	Aaron Nola	67.9	14.42	24	242	Miles Mikolas	322.8	1.27	-81	392	Mychal Givens	395.1	-6.41	-3
93	Kyle Seager	134.2	14.42	-41	243	Marwin Gonzalez	114.7	1.23	128	393	Carson Smith	597.1	-6.53	-204
94	Tommy Pham	61.4	14.03	33	244	Hyun-Jin Ryu	340	1.18	-96	394	Jason Hammel	538.8	-6.53	-145
95	Domingo Santana	74.8	14.03	20	245	Stephen Piscotty	297.6	1.08	-53	395	Erasmo Ramirez	456.6	-6.58	-62
96	Nick Castellanos	103.7	13.84	-8	246	Sean Newcomb	326.7	1.04	-81	396	Jordy Mercer	505	-6.60	-109
97	Justin Smoak	147.2	13.70	-50	247	Archie Bradley	189.5	0.89	58	397	Ian Kennedy	457.5	-6.60	-61
98	Whit Merrifield	70.6	13.63	27	248	Nick Pivetta	434.7	0.68	-187	398	Hunter Renfroe	298	-6.63	100
99	Kevin Kiermaier	159.3	13.54	-60	249	David Dahl	247.4	0.67	2	399	Matt Harvey	367.8	-6.65	31
100	Josh Bell	178.2	13.40	-78	250	Evan Gattis	156.9	0.67	93	400	Jimmie Sherfy	550.2	-6.77	-150
101	Daniel Murphy	67.2	13.37	34	251	Jed Lowrie	427.1	0.61	-176	401	Raimel Tapia	389.2	-6.85	12
102	Adrian Beltre	158.9	13.28	-57	252	Felix Hernandez	287.2	0.60	-35	402	Erick Fedde	619.3	-6.91	-217
103	Jake Lamb	117.8	13.09	-15	253	Jake Faria	239.6	0.49	13	403	Kyle Freeland	533.8	-6.95	-131
104	Byron Buxton	53	13.08	51	254	Corey Dickerson	216	0.45	38	404	Nathan Karns	483.5	-6.99	-80
105	Evan Longoria	198.7	13.01	-94	255	Michael Taylor	217.8	0.43	37	405	Robert Stephenson	453.3	-7.13	-48
106	Masahiro Tanaka	104.4	12.96	2	256	Alex Reyes	258.8	0.42	-3	406	Matt Andriese	477.2	-7.14	-71
107	Shohei Ohtani	74.7	12.93	32	257	Tyler Anderson	423.2	0.37	-166	407	JC Ramirez	531.6	-7.20	-125
108	Mike Moustakas	109.8	12.79	-2	258	Hector Neris	144.1	0.21	114	408	Lonnie Chisenhall	390.1	-7.21	18
109	Odubel Herrera	212.4	12.34	-103	259	Ronald Acuna	133.2	0.04	126	409	Jose Urena	415.6	-7.23	-7
110	Brandon Morrow	225.1	12.09	-115	260	Aaron Altherr	251	0.04	9	410	Homer Bailey	531.8	-7.27	-122
111	Jon Gray	166.8	11.74	-56	261	Anthony Swarzak	457.8	-0.01	-197	411	Dominic Leone	543.4	-7.27	-132
112	Marcus Stroman	122.4	11.69	-10	262	Mark Trumbo	248.8	-0.01	13	412	Ryan Tepera	598.4	-7.27	-186
113	Trey Mancini	158.4	11.37	-45	263	Brad Boxberger	324.5	-0.10	-62	413	Mark Leiter	566.2	-7.33	-153
114	Trevor Story	115.1	11.28	-1	264	Jorge Soler	472.8	-0.13	-209	414	Steve Cishek	524.6	-7.35	-111
115	Cody Allen	102.3	11.12	13	265	Dustin Pedroia	438	-0.20	-173	415	Sam Dyson	522.7	-7.36	-108
116	Rafael Devers	128.3	11.02	-12	266	Aaron Hicks	237	-0.21	29	416	Jose Martinez	279	-7.45	137
117	Jameson Taillon	198.3	10.97	-81	267	Luke Gregerson	369.8	-0.25	-103	417	Michael Kopech	326.9	-7.75	90
118	Jean Segura	78.4	10.95	40	268	Chase Anderson	169.6	-0.29	98	418	Ross Stripling	632.5	-7.76	-215
119	Shin-Soo Choo	253.4	10.87	-134	269	Andrew Heaney	432.9	-0.32	-164	419	Will Harris	546.3	-7.86	-127
120	Avisail Garcia	192.2	10.78	-72	270	Brandon McCarthy	443.8	-0.34	-174	420	Jonathan Lucroy	180	-7.92	240
121	Matt Olson	120.7	10.66	0	271	Addison Russell	250.4	-0.34	21	421	Koda Glover	621.2	-7.97	-200
122	Rich Hill	121.2	10.58	1	272	Marco Estrada	313.4	-0.36	-41	422	Pedro Strop	606.5	-7.97	-185
123	Yulieski Gurriel	207.5	10.51	-85	273	Jakob Junis	385.7	-0.40	-113	423	Mike Fiers	529.4	-7.99	-106
124	Travis Shaw	94.6	10.24	29	274	Anthony DeSclafani	419.6	-0.52	-146	424	Josh Tomlin	453.5	-8.00	-30
125	Adam Eaton	155.1	10.03	-30	275	Chad Kuhl	401.5	-0.54	-127	425	Trevor Cahill	566.4	-8.03	-141
126	Eric Thames	187.1	10.03	-61	276	Mike Leake	324.3	-0.57	-48	426	Collin McHugh	334.4	-8.06	92
127	Gerrit Cole	90.5	9.99	37	277	Brandon Phillips	373.2	-0.58	-96	427	Nick Delmonico	460.9	-8.11	-34
128	David Peralta	253.3	9.66	-125	278	Hunter Pence	454.1	-0.64	-176	428	Matt Boyd	519.9	-8.12	-92
129	Ender Inciarte	118.5	9.59	11	279	Mark Melancon	177.1	-0.65	102	429	Curtis Granderson	527	-8.29	-98
130	Johnny Cueto	151.1	9.39	-21	280	Matt Shoemaker	332	-0.72	-52	430	Lewis Brinson	333.8	-8.38	96
131	Ryan Madson	430	9.29	-299	281	Ivan Nova	347.2	-0.74	-66	431	Brad Miller	459.9	-8.46	-29
132	Gregory Polanco	163.4	9.26	-31	282	Cheslor Cuthbert	577.8	-0.76	-296	432	A.J. Ramos	364.7	-8.57	67
133	Buster Posey	59.7	9.20	73	283	Asdrubal Cabrera	305.8	-0.81	-23	433	Logan Forsythe	427.5	-8.60	6
134	Chris Taylor	91.7	8.94	42	284	German Marquez	336	-0.86	-52	434	Seung Hwan Oh	502.1	-8.61	-68
135	Marcus Semien	230.5	8.93	-96	285	Ketel Marte	355.4	-0.90	-70	435	Matt Moore	441.5	-8.62	-7
136	Blake Parker	213.8	8.92	-78	286	Tyler Chatwood	289.4	-0.95	-3	436	Martin Prado	551.4	-8.66	-115
137	Maikel Franco	236.6	8.90	-100	287	Pat Neshek	514.9	-1.01	-228	437	Jordan Zimmermann	597.6	-8.74	-161
138	Raisel Iglesias	102.3	8.72	36	288	Zack Wheeler	440.2	-1.04	-152	438	Ben Gamel	424.8	-8.79	13
139	Justin Bour	192.2	8.62	-53	289	Neil Walker	411.5	-1.10	-123	439	Addison Reed	265.3	-8.80	174
140	Eugenio Suarez	190.6	8.47	-51	290	Scooter Gennett	197.6	-1.13	92	440	Dansby Swanson	385.4	-8.84	55
141	Kyle Hendricks	117.3	8.44	24	291	Shane Greene	242.5	-1.18	49	441	Steve Pearce	551.1	-8.89	-110
142	Ian Kinsler	191.1	8.30	-49	292	Zack Cozart	225.6	-1.18	66	442	Lucas Giolito	224.6	-8.96	217
143	Javier Baez	102.3	8.29	41	293	Jharel Cotton	397	-1.22	-104	443	Jimmy Nelson	292.1	-8.98	151
144	Luke Weaver	110.1	8.27	34	294	Albert Pujols	311	-1.25	-17	444	Trevor Williams	475.2	-9.13	-31
145	Miguel Sano	97.7	8.18	47	295	Justin Wilson	575.1	-1.33	-280	445	Russell Martin	321	-9.24	124
146	Hanley Ramirez	328.1	8.11	-182	296	Kyle Barraclough	315.2	-1.36	-19	446	Eduardo Rodriguez	343.9	-9.34	102
147	Ozzie Albies	145	8.04	2	297	Amed Rosario	232.8	-1.43	64	447	Jack Flaherty	372.1	-9.36	75
148	Ryan Zimmerman	126.2	7.97	22	298	Julio Teheran	238.5	-1.48	60	448	Brad Ziegler	406.9	-9.38	41
149	Brandon Belt	304.1	7.95	-155	299	A.J. Minter	443.1	-1.54	-144	449	Carlos Gonzalez	287.7	-9.49	161
150	Didi Gregorius	113.9	7.91	36	300	Mike Montgomery	364.6	-1.55	-65	450	Trevor Hildenberger	399.9	-9.69	50

Players with the biggest negative differential - (my formula's interpretation of the Steamer Projections minus NFBC ADP) are the ones Steamer likes. Players with the biggest positive differentials are the ones NFBC drafters like. Keep in mind the differentials are not all created equal as those near the top carry much more weight, i.e., Stanton's minus 7 from nine to two, is worth $9 (or at least he's $9 more valuable per Steamer projections than No. 9 player Paul Goldschmidt.) Contrast that with 189th-ranked Josh Harrison worth $4.95, which is only $5.20 more than the 267th player (his NFBC ADP) worth -$.25. Nonetheless it's worth seeing who the outliers are for both sides.

Here are the top-150 players (by Steamer's ranks through my formula) sorted from most to least Steamer friendly relative to NFBC:

Rk	Name	ADP	$	Diff	Rk	Name	ADP	$	Diff	Rk	Name	ADP	$	Diff
131	Ryan Madson	430	9.29	-299	19	Craig Kimbrel	45.1	27.90	-26	90	Xander Bogaerts	86.4	14.83	4
146	Hanley Ramirez	328.1	8.11	-182	27	Starling Marte	50.8	25.57	-24	18	Corey Kluber	13.5	28.43	5
55	Andrew Miller	210.2	19.23	-155	73	Yoenis Cespedes	96.4	16.81	-23	9	Paul Goldschmidt	4.3	34.17	5
149	Brandon Belt	304.1	7.95	-155	32	Nelson Cruz	54.2	24.34	-22	24	Joey Votto	18.5	26.52	6
119	Shin-Soo Choo	253.4	10.87	-134	130	Johnny Cueto	151.1	9.39	-21	14	Charlie Blackmon	8.4	31.38	6
128	David Peralta	253.3	9.66	-125	30	Marcell Ozuna	48.3	24.64	-18	85	Roberto Osuna	79.3	15.00	6
110	Brandon Morrow	225.1	12.09	-115	26	Jose Abreu	42.8	25.95	-17	31	Stephen Strasburg	25	24.54	6
109	Odubel Herrera	212.4	12.34	-103	78	Miguel Cabrera	94.1	16.18	-16	40	Luis Severino	33.3	22.52	7
137	Maikel Franco	236.6	8.90	-100	22	Kenley Jansen	37.9	27.05	-16	84	Dallas Keuchel	77.3	15.02	7
135	Marcus Semien	230.5	8.93	-96	35	Rhys Hoskins	50.8	23.86	-16	46	Justin Verlander	38	21.64	8
105	Evan Longoria	198.7	13.01	-94	103	Jake Lamb	117.8	13.09	-15	42	Alex Bregman	33.2	22.15	9
68	Nomar Mazara	160.5	17.40	-93	57	Wil Myers	71.7	19.11	-15	11	Jose Altuve	2.1	33.44	9
87	Carlos Santana	172.8	14.88	-86	5	Manny Machado	19.1	35.56	-14	23	Carlos Correa	13.9	26.73	9
123	Yulieski Gurriel	207.5	10.51	-85	20	Noah Syndergaard	33.7	27.27	-14	129	Ender Inciarte	118.5	9.59	11
117	Jameson Taillon	198.3	10.97	-81	48	Corey Knebel	61.3	20.34	-13	115	Cody Allen	102.3	11.12	13
61	Jeff Samardzija	140.1	18.16	-79	116	Rafael Devers	128.3	11.02	-12	52	Corey Seager	39	19.83	13
100	Josh Bell	178.2	13.40	-78	51	Jonathan Schoop	62.8	20.10	-12	50	Carlos Carrasco	36.2	20.23	14
136	Blake Parker	213.8	8.92	-78	112	Marcus Stroman	122.4	11.69	-10	36	Freddie Freeman	22.1	23.14	14
120	Avisail Garcia	192.2	10.78	-72	89	Lorenzo Cain	99	14.85	-10	33	Aaron Judge	17.6	24.30	15
63	DJ LeMahieu	129.7	17.96	-67	76	Justin Turner	85.7	16.24	-10	41	Cody Bellinger	24.5	22.36	17
80	Adam Jones	145.7	15.65	-66	15	Anthony Rizzo	24.7	31.14	-10	75	Anthony Rendon	57.8	16.36	17
126	Eric Thames	187.1	10.03	-61	47	Edwin Encarnacion	56.6	20.35	-10	43	J.D. Martinez	24.2	21.93	19
99	Kevin Kiermaier	159.3	13.54	-60	44	Chris Archer	52.3	21.85	-8	95	Domingo Santana	74.8	14.03	20
102	Adrian Beltre	158.9	13.28	-57	34	Andrew Benintendi	42.2	23.98	-8	72	Yu Darvish	51.5	16.84	21
111	Jon Gray	166.8	11.74	-56	96	Nick Castellanos	103.7	13.84	-8	67	Zack Greinke	45.6	17.57	21
59	Ian Desmond	114.4	18.47	-55	21	Josh Donaldson	28.5	27.06	-8	148	Ryan Zimmerman	126.2	7.97	22
139	Justin Bour	192.2	8.62	-53	2	Giancarlo Stanton	9	43.09	-7	79	Elvis Andrus	56.4	16.15	23
70	David Price	123.1	17.16	-53	29	Jacob deGrom	34.8	24.77	-6	49	Madison Bumgarner	26	20.30	23
140	Eugenio Suarez	190.6	8.47	-51	64	Khris Davis	69.4	17.75	-5	77	Carlos Martinez	53.9	16.22	23
97	Justin Smoak	147.2	13.70	-50	16	Francisco Lindor	21.3	30.66	-5	141	Kyle Hendricks	117.3	8.44	24
66	Joey Gallo	115.9	17.64	-50	3	Clayton Kershaw	7	39.54	-4	92	Aaron Nola	67.9	14.42	24
142	Ian Kinsler	191.1	8.30	-49	60	A.J. Pollock	63.3	18.16	-3	71	Justin Upton	46.6	16.88	24
113	Trey Mancini	158.4	11.37	-45	74	James Paxton	77.3	16.45	-3	98	Whit Merrifield	70.6	13.63	27
53	Ken Giles	98	19.60	-45	28	George Springer	31	25.14	-3	124	Travis Shaw	94.6	10.24	29
25	Christian Yelich	69	26.49	-44	10	Chris Sale	12.8	33.54	-3	107	Shohei Ohtani	74.7	12.93	32
69	Rougned Odor	110.9	17.40	-42	13	Kris Bryant	15.5	31.47	-3	94	Tommy Pham	61.4	14.03	33
91	Sean Doolittle	132.6	14.61	-42	17	Jose Ramirez	19.5	28.68	-3	101	Daniel Murphy	67.2	13.37	34
93	Kyle Seager	134.2	14.42	-41	108	Mike Moustakas	109.8	12.79	-2	62	Dee Gordon	28.1	17.98	34
83	Jon Lester	119.8	15.02	-37	7	Bryce Harper	8.4	34.91	-1	144	Luke Weaver	110.1	8.27	34
82	Eddie Rosario	118.4	15.16	-36	4	Nolan Arenado	5.3	37.99	-1	138	Raisel Iglesias	102.3	8.72	36
58	Edwin Diaz	90.9	18.73	-33	114	Trevor Story	115.1	11.28	-1	150	Didi Gregorius	113.9	7.91	36
132	Gregory Polanco	163.4	9.26	-31	8	Mookie Betts	8.6	34.83	-1	127	Gerrit Cole	90.5	9.99	37
45	Jose Quintana	76.3	21.74	-31	38	Brian Dozier	38.5	22.87	-1	118	Jean Segura	78.4	10.95	40
81	Yasiel Puig	112.2	15.31	-31	1	Mike Trout	1.1	46.78	0	86	Robbie Ray	45.9	14.94	40
125	Adam Eaton	155.1	10.03	-30	121	Matt Olson	120.7	10.66	0	143	Javier Baez	102.3	8.29	41
39	Eric Hosmer	68.4	22.70	-29	122	Rich Hill	121.2	10.58	1	134	Chris Taylor	91.7	8.94	42
54	Robinson Cano	83	19.48	-29	6	Trea Turner	5.2	35.55	1	145	Miguel Sano	97.7	8.18	47
37	Aroldis Chapman	64.9	23.05	-28	12	Max Scherzer	10.5	32.22	2	104	Byron Buxton	53	13.08	51
65	Felipe Rivero	92.5	17.67	-28	106	Masahiro Tanaka	104.4	12.96	2	88	Gary Sanchez	20.7	14.86	67
56	Andrew McCutchen	83.3	19.19	-27	147	Ozzie Albies	145	8.04	2	133	Buster Posey	59.7	9.20	73

Again, note the lack of catcher adjustment which is why Buster Posey and Gary Sanchez are the two most NFBC-friendly. Relief pitchers are also tricky because some of Steamer's projections for saves are a little wacky and out of step with who NFBC drafters think is likely to secure the job. Still, for hitters and workhorse starting pitchers you can see where the two approaches diverge.