Dynasty Risers and Fallers: Week 6 Buys, Sells, and Holds

Jagger May breaks down the top Dynasty movers heading into Week 6, including some hard realizations about Broncos quarterback Bo Nix.
Dynasty Risers and Fallers: Week 6 Buys, Sells, and Holds

Now that we're onto Week 6, we're officially in the Copium, Hopium, and Denial stage of analysis. We need to absorb truths that challenge our priors and make major fantasy decisions. 1-4 teams and 4-1 teams usually trade with each other, and many of those debates will come down to the same question: the quarterback situation.

So we need to analyze the quarterbacks themselves. We often have chicken-and-egg scenarios for players like Justin Herbert, while we need to discuss whether some are just bad eggs like Bo Nix. So here are six of the biggest quarterback movers and whether you should buy or sell.

Risers

Drake Maye, Patriots

I've probably said this before, but feel the need to say it again: we were being incredibly silly about Maye. A six-game sample washed out 28 games of great play on a worse roster, all in the name of strength of schedule. Make no mistake: Maye made egregious plays. But Romeo Doubs also made several primetime errors, and the entire offense was playing poorly. Despite an offensive line that hasn't improved much and another rookie in Caleb Lomu still working his way into the offense, Maye is pressured on 43 percent of dropbacks and still manages to post an elite EPA.

These numbers are coming off of two bad games and without A.J. Brown. Let that sink in when you hear the good news about Brown's return.

Now that we're onto Week 6, we're officially in the Copium, Hopium, and Denial stage of analysis. We need to absorb truths that challenge our priors and make major fantasy decisions. 1-4 teams and 4-1 teams usually trade with each other, and many of those debates will come down to the same question: the quarterback situation.

So we need to analyze the quarterbacks themselves. We often have chicken-and-egg scenarios for players like Justin Herbert, while we need to discuss whether some are just bad eggs like Bo Nix. So here are six of the biggest quarterback movers and whether you should buy or sell.

Risers

Drake Maye, Patriots

I've probably said this before, but feel the need to say it again: we were being incredibly silly about Maye. A six-game sample washed out 28 games of great play on a worse roster, all in the name of strength of schedule. Make no mistake: Maye made egregious plays. But Romeo Doubs also made several primetime errors, and the entire offense was playing poorly. Despite an offensive line that hasn't improved much and another rookie in Caleb Lomu still working his way into the offense, Maye is pressured on 43 percent of dropbacks and still manages to post an elite EPA.

These numbers are coming off of two bad games and without A.J. Brown. Let that sink in when you hear the good news about Brown's return.

And if you needed more reasons to be impressed, he's been fairly sturdy with the cast of receivers he's had even without Brown. For what it's worth, I don't think that a receiving room of Doubs, Kyle Williams, Efton Chism and DeMario Douglas is the best out there (hot take), but it certainly isn't the worst. The last two games have made them look elite. 

The buy window for Maye is likely firmly shut, but never underestimate the power of a scorned fantasy manager who was looking to confirm priors. Continue trying to buy players of this caliber because you never know who might accept.

BUY OR SELL: BUY....(IF YOU CAN)

Kyler Murray, Vikings

Murray had a slow start for the same reasons he was rather disappointing in Arizona: He's erratic and often injured. However, it's encouraging that he finally has modest rushing yardage under his belt to help the "Konami Code" QB title hold water. The rushing and flashy plays have always been the tantalizing feature, and we even got the fastest ball carry of the season last game. 

However, I'm still concerned about his long-term value. Murray tends to only succeed outside of structure, and the stats and tape prove it.

Making things happen when things are bad is what separates solid quarterbacks from the elite. But being on time and on target is what makes average athletes elite, and the elite athletes below-average quarterbacks. Murray is dangerously close to that last bucket because he's quick to bail instead of letting plays develop a second longer.

Plays like the above create negative yardage or turnovers, which eliminate multiple cool runs and throws. I was a major Murray supporter throughout the offseason and want to give injury some benefit of the doubt. However, my aggression in acquiring shares has drastically waned.

BUY OR SELL: HOLD (SOFT SELL)

Michael Penix Jr., Falcons

Penix has been a lifesaver for the Falcons' offense, yet I still come away believing it's because he's playing just at baseline talent. Much of his yardage can be attributed to Drake London doing Drake London things, and broken coverage. It's an incredibly small sample size, but worth looking at on the graph.

Am I saying Penix is bad? Absolutely not. But I want to see more against tougher competition because plays like the one below could just as easily be INTs. I'm using him to trade up if possible, and I'm reluctant to buy.

BUY OR SELL: TRADE UP OR HOLD

Fallers

Jayden Daniels, Commanders

I'm worried about Daniels. Yes, he leads all QBs in rushing, but he's close to leading in QB missed time, and it's killing his dynasty value. A direct quote from Deepak Chona, our Injury Expert: 

"Ominous reports about likelihood of re-injury in-season. "If, not when" may be more than we would say, but re-injury risk is likely = very high."

Again, Daniels is playing well, and the value hit is solely from reporting and the same injury popping back up (or out of place). He's an objectively good quarterback who may have some locker room and press makeup to do after an OT gaff.

You should feel good about the results on the field, and everything surrounding Daniels is noise. Quarterbacks like Deshaun Watson have two-mile leashes. Watch the injury, but seize the opportunity to buy the highest upside in the quarterback department.

BUY OR SELL: CAUTIOUS BUY

Justin Herbert, Chargers

I've taken heat for this, but Herbert is simply not playing good football, and he should absolutely shoulder some blame. This is where I bring up the Chicken-and-Egg scenario.

Twitter did NOT like the fun charts I'm showing you right now, but it's quite objective that even when things are good, they're bad. Moreover, we've seen good quarterbacks still manage to create something.

Herbert has taken on more pressure than ever before this season, and I certainly find this to be a major catalyst. However, he needs to get rid of the ball quicker and have trust in his receivers. Rushing would also keep the defense honest to open things up downfield. He just hasn't been a playmaker.

With all this being said and the same bad charting, we need to take the bad with the good. Many traits put him in the upper tier of the "Jared Goff" tier of players, with the exception of his added athleticism. Herbert is more of a trailer than he is a truck, and he may never get what he deserves in LA. I still believe his weapons are better than we give them credit. With all the negatives being said, I still find him to be a buy for contenders because he has enough upside to have job security.

BUY OR SELL: BUY (I know I just crapped all over him, but multiple things can be true)

Bo Nix, Broncos

Nix is playing even worse than Herbert but without any of the excuses. The Broncos have a solid offensive line. They made a huge trade for Jaylen Waddle. Nix just doesn't make plays downfield.

Moreover, Nix's big upside was rushing, and we're not getting that either. It's hard for me to point to what fantasy value he's really giving you with the Justin Fields-like stat lines. And again, I need to point out that his receivers aren't terrible.

Nix is exactly the quarterback he was in college: only comfortable with passes near the line of scrimmage and won't push the ball downfield to make big plays. He sometimes rushes when he isn't recovering from injury, but the lack of downfield passing negates that. He's not helping you as a contender, and he was already a fifth-year senior who likely won't improve. This is the easiest sell-low quarterback in history. 

BUY OR SELL: SELL

Fantasy Pass
Want to Read More?
The Fantasy Pass unlocks this article and every other one.

Season-long rankings, start/sit calls, and waiver advice from the analysts who wrote this piece. Subscribers can also talk it through with the author in the comments.

Season-long rankings, start/sit calls, and waiver advice from the analysts who wrote this piece.