Dynasty Risers and Fallers: Week 4 Buys, Sells, and Holds

Jagger May breaks down the top Dynasty movers heading into Week 4, including a reminder yet again about what to do with Eagles running back Saquon Barkley.
Dynasty Risers and Fallers: Week 4 Buys, Sells, and Holds

We have three weeks of real stats and data that are now impossible to ignore. Thus, real dynasty moves and adjustments need to be made while there is still an advantage. This is the perfect opportunity to capitalize on fantasy's most volatile position, which is only second to tight ends in shallow depth: Running backs.

RISERS

Bhayshul Tuten, Jaguars

The window to buy Tuten is quickly closing, and you should still buy even with this slight creep up the rankings. Tuten has all the ability in the world and is proving that with extremely promising efficiency numbers. He's been fantasy relevant without big plays and few touchdowns. The casual will see that as a reason to fade. You, a scholarly and intellectual reader, will see these as indicators to buy even harder. I'm even putting my money where my mouth is.

BUY OR SELL: PRIORITY BUY

D'Andre Swift, RB, Bears

Swift is a Dynasty RB1, and it's time for the community to forgive him for not living up to expectations in Detroit. He has a quarterback, an explosive offense and elite usage. The "Ben Johnson hates him" narrative was silly even before the contract.

Swift is alongside very good company in both role and efficiency. Moreover, he's still 27 years old with at least two more seasons of production we can count on. Don't overthink it.

BUY OR SELL:  BUY

Jaylen Warren,

We have three weeks of real stats and data that are now impossible to ignore. Thus, real dynasty moves and adjustments need to be made while there is still an advantage. This is the perfect opportunity to capitalize on fantasy's most volatile position, which is only second to tight ends in shallow depth: Running backs.

RISERS

Bhayshul Tuten, Jaguars

The window to buy Tuten is quickly closing, and you should still buy even with this slight creep up the rankings. Tuten has all the ability in the world and is proving that with extremely promising efficiency numbers. He's been fantasy relevant without big plays and few touchdowns. The casual will see that as a reason to fade. You, a scholarly and intellectual reader, will see these as indicators to buy even harder. I'm even putting my money where my mouth is.

BUY OR SELL: PRIORITY BUY

D'Andre Swift, RB, Bears

Swift is a Dynasty RB1, and it's time for the community to forgive him for not living up to expectations in Detroit. He has a quarterback, an explosive offense and elite usage. The "Ben Johnson hates him" narrative was silly even before the contract.

Swift is alongside very good company in both role and efficiency. Moreover, he's still 27 years old with at least two more seasons of production we can count on. Don't overthink it.

BUY OR SELL:  BUY

Jaylen Warren, RB, Steelers

Warren is the Steelers' most explosive weapon outside of DK Metcalf, and he has yet to score a touchdown this season. Yes, people, it's true: Pittsburgh has running back production that isn't horrific to look at. If Mike McCarthy is smart (that's a big if), they'd allow Warren to continue to dominate touches even when Rico Dowdle is healthy. It's not just the rushing that's so meaningful; it's pass-catching that's both meaningful for fantasy and the Shadow GM they call Aaron Rodgers.

Warren will be 28 in November, so his expiration date is coming sooner rather than later. However, his play style offers some modest longevity, and the Steelers have bigger needs beyond drafting another running back who will undoubtedly play behind Warren. His two-year window and relatively affordable cost make him a low-risk, win-now buy and solid hold for those looking to immediately compete next season.

BUY OR SELL: CONTENDER BUY

Mike Washington, Jr. RB, Raiders

Washington is very real and deserves more touches, regardless of Ashton Jeanty's talent. It's no hot take to rank him as the third-best weapon in an offense that lacks talent outside of Brock Bowers and Jeanty. His efficiency is guaranteed to regress closer to the mean with more touches, but even a modest drop shows a very explosive threat, with both contingent upside attached to Jeanty's health and standalone value if HC Klint Kubiak wants to lean heavily into the run game. 

BUY OR SELL:  BUY

FALLERS

David Montgomery, RB, Texans

Get Montgomery off your roster. Yes, even contenders. He's a touchdown-dependent, 29-year-old committee back in an offense that won't be scoring at an elite rate.

Without red-zone touches and a three-touchdown game, it's absolutely horrendous. Montgomery wasn't efficient his last year in a much better offense, and the fantasy fallacy of touchdown cologne is covering up the stink of a dead-zone running back. He's more likely to tank your team into the middle of the pack than he is helping you "win now."

BUY OR SELL: PRIORITY SELL

De'Von Achane, RB, Dolphins

Your instincts will tell you "Achane is the perfect rebuild target." I implore you to ignore that instinct. Achane wasn't very good despite eating six targets per game, and then he tore his ACL. It's not been very cash money in Miami, and one offseason doesn't convince me that it'll get better. Miami needs a quarterback, and we can't be sure how committed they are to Malik Willis long-term. 

The offensive line is in shambles, and nobody should stop them from drafting Jeremiah Smith. We can't really anticipate things getting better with one offseason. I'd rather roll the dice and extract value now, or let some other rebuilder spend money on a trap.

BUY OR SELL:  SELL

Omarion Hampton, RB, Chargers

I'm already tired of talking about how disappointing the Chargers are, but Hampton has at least been average. Which isn't really good enough compared to his value.

A common theme of my running back analysis is:

A) Good usage;

B) Good play.

It's difficult to say if we're getting either of those things, and the passing offense is the squeakier wheel. We knew that Kimani Vidal and Keaton Mitchell would be involved, but that's only okay if we're getting 50-point games like Mike McDaniel cooked up in Miami. However, I can't help but want to give a first-round athletic runner with size more time to develop. The offensive line actually has room to improve, which will help Justin Herbert as much as Hampton. If he was horrendous, I'd be more tentative, but the modest output coupled with a price dip intrigues me.

BUY OR SELL:  BUY

Saquon Barkley, RB, Eagles

I am once again asking you to sell Barkley while you can still get a solid return. Is Barkley good? Yes. Is his team good? No. Is his team even using him properly during these trying times? Also no. This graph didn't improve much after another week.

He's quite literally as mid as can be. The Eagles aren't going to magically overhaul their offensive line this season, and Jalen Hurts isn't going to outplay the follies of a first-time play caller. Moving Barkley for stable long-term assets needs to be a massive priority. Managers still perceive his situation as having upside that isn't there.

BUY OR SELL:  PRIORITY SELL

Fantasy Pass
Want to Read More?
The Fantasy Pass unlocks this article and every other one.

Season-long rankings, start/sit calls, and waiver advice from the analysts who wrote this piece. Subscribers can also talk it through with the author in the comments.

Season-long rankings, start/sit calls, and waiver advice from the analysts who wrote this piece.