Fantasy Football Start/Sit: Week 2 Matchup Analysis & Streamers

Jerry Donabedian breaks down the best and worst matchups of Week 2, highlighting Aaron Jones and Jalen Coker as 'Upgrades' while Travis Etienne and Josh Downs get 'Downgrades'.
Fantasy Football Start/Sit: Week 2 Matchup Analysis & Streamers

A high-scoring Week 1 with relatively few major injuries means a lot of us feel better about our fantasy lineups than we did at the same point in 2025 or 2024. As much as I love playing the Grinch, there really is a lot to be excited about.

We can't promise it will last all season, but the Panthers and Packers notably displayed more aggression on offense compared to last year — in terms of pass rate and pace — while consolidating volume among their top receivers. Meanwhile, rushing attacks led the way for most of the league, including a smattering of fantasy RB2s who produced like RB1s.

David Montgomery, D'Andre Swift and Bucky Irving should now be locked into lineups in even the shallowest of leagues. Bhayshul Tuten and Jadarian Price aren't there, but both played well in Week 1 while operating as the clear lead in their respective committees. More work could be coming soon, especially in Price's case with the combination of a backup QB and a favorable Week 2 matchup (at ARZ).

For the upcoming slate, we'll look at a couple of other running backs who don't have the same kind of long-term upside but seem to have their stars aligning for Week 2. I see at least 26 RBs that I'd have no issue starting in 12-team leagues, and at least a handful of others that grade as acceptable options. Chaos will reign, eventually, as it always does, but the reality for many fantasy

A high-scoring Week 1 with relatively few major injuries means a lot of us feel better about our fantasy lineups than we did at the same point in 2025 or 2024. As much as I love playing the Grinch, there really is a lot to be excited about.

We can't promise it will last all season, but the Panthers and Packers notably displayed more aggression on offense compared to last year β€” in terms of pass rate and pace β€” while consolidating volume among their top receivers. Meanwhile, rushing attacks led the way for most of the league, including a smattering of fantasy RB2s who produced like RB1s.

David Montgomery, D'Andre Swift and Bucky Irving should now be locked into lineups in even the shallowest of leagues. Bhayshul Tuten and Jadarian Price aren't there, but both played well in Week 1 while operating as the clear lead in their respective committees. More work could be coming soon, especially in Price's case with the combination of a backup QB and a favorable Week 2 matchup (at ARZ).

For the upcoming slate, we'll look at a couple of other running backs who don't have the same kind of long-term upside but seem to have their stars aligning for Week 2. I see at least 26 RBs that I'd have no issue starting in 12-team leagues, and at least a handful of others that grade as acceptable options. Chaos will reign, eventually, as it always does, but the reality for many fantasy players this week is choosing between two good options for lineup spots. Enjoy it while it lasts.

I use several RotoWire tools to analyze matchups, starting with my weekly recap articleΒ Box Score Breakdown, which provides a clear view of snaps, routes and other usage stats from the previous week.Β NFL defense vs. positionΒ stats can help identify exploitable matchups later in the season, andΒ NFL advanced statsΒ show emerging trends early in the year. Most important of all, I monitor theΒ NFL injury reportΒ andΒ NFL player newsΒ to see how roles andΒ NFL depth chartsΒ may shift for the current week.

Unless otherwise noted, references to "fantasy points" are based on PPR scoring with 25/10 yards per point and 4/6 points for TDs. Start % comes from Yahoo, as of Wednesday night / Thursday morning.

Start/Upgrade πŸ‘

Quarterbacks πŸ‘

Start Over β€” Justin Herbert (vs. LV), Bo Nix (vs. JAX), Jared Goff (at BUF), Patrick Mahomes (vs. IND)

The Giants have too much talent in the front seven for their defense to be as bad as it was last year, but they still need more help on the back end to be any better than mediocre. Allowing just 20 points to Dallas in Week 1 sounds good, until you realize the Cowboys had six real drives (plus a seventh that started with 14 seconds remaining in the second quarter). Three of those six series ended with TDs, and two others might've also yielded scores if not for drops by George Pickens. Now the Giants will travel cross-country to face a team that won't be so easily bullied out of possession.

It all sets up nicely as a get-right spot for Stafford, who has a healthy offense around him after the Week 1 misadventure in Australia. The Rams have an implied total of 27.5 points, tied with Baltimore for third-highest of Week 2. There's even sneaky shootout potential for this game, now that Malik Nabers is healthy and Myles Garrett (IR) isn't.

Running Backs πŸ‘

Start Over β€” Jaylen Warren / Rico Dowdle (at NE), Quinshon Judkins (at TB), Jadarian Price (at ARZ)

Jordan Mason (thumb) will miss at least four games on injured reserve, leaving Jones as the clear lead back until a Week 6 bye. The schedule also works in Jones' favor, starting this Sunday against a Chicago outfit that appears even more shootout-prone than it was last season. After that, the Vikings play at Tampa Bay (Week 3), home against Miami (Week 4) and away at New Orleans (Week 5). We still need to see exactly what Jones' role looks like without Mason, but it's probably safe to say that DeeJay Dallas and Demond Claiborne won't take over all of Mason's usual workload.

Jones can definitely still play; it's less clear whether he can do so without suffering an injury every few weeks. Keeping that in mind, we may be looking at 15 touches rather than 20. That's fine, given the matchup and how cheap he came in drafts.

Start Over β€” Bhayshul Tuten (at DEN), MarShawn Lloyd (at NYJ), Quinshon Judkins (at TB), Warren/Dowdle (at NE)

Rachaad White was largely relegated to passing downs after Washington's third series of Sunday's loss to Philadelphia, which means Croskey-Merritt took on a 61 percent snap share and 13 of 17 RB carries during a lengthy stretch from the start of the second quarter to the four-minute mark of the fourth quarter. That's when JCM coughed up the football, and while Washington recovered, Kaytron Allen then came in for the final three carries and had gains of 4, 4 and 3 yards to help set up an almost-tying TD.

Allen's involvement is something to watch moving forward, but the key here is that Croskey-Merritt quickly buried White on early downs and then took advantage with a 16-63-1 rushing line, including a one-yard TD. Croskey-Merritt now lines up as the lead runner against a Dallas defense that lost two starters to injuries (LB DeMarvion Overshown, S Malik Hooker) in the process of taking a Week 1 beating from the Giants (56.3 yards, 4.0 points per drive).

There is some game-script risk with the Cowboys being 3.5-point favorites on account of their strong offense and Washington's questionable defense. Even then, only a true blowout or injury should stop Croskey-Merritt from taking double-digit carries against what looks like one of the league's worst defenses (again).

Wide Receivers πŸ‘

Start Over β€” DJ Moore (vs. DET), Rashee Rice (vs. IND), Tee Higgins (at HOU), Drake London (vs. CAR)

Matthew Golden piled up targets once the Packers fell behind last week, but Watson had most of the production (6-147-2) and finished with strong market shares β€”Β 80% routes, 20% targets, 28% air yards β€” even after Golden's late flurry. Enthusiasm about one of the Green Bay WRs needn't dull optimism about the other, especially in Watson's case when there's a long history of strong production on both a per-route and per-target basis.Β 

His route volume rose last year and now seems to be bumping even higher, just in time for a favorable schedule over the first half of the season: W2 (at NYJ), W3 (vs. ATL), W4 (at TB), W5 (at CHI), W6 (vs. DAL), W7 (at DET), W8 (at CAR). This week, Watson takes aim at a Jets secondary that isn't expected to have S Minkah Fitzpatrick (groin). Wheels up.

Start Over β€” Luther Burden (vs. MIN), Emeka Egbuka (vs. CLE), Jaylen Waddle (vs. JAX)

Without leaving his division, McLaurin goes directly from one of the worst possible matchups (at Philadelphia) to one of the best. He'll be playing at climate-controlled Jerry World against Jerry's banged-up defense, likely seeing plenty of struggling cornerback DaRon Bland. Expect a strong rebound from the Week 1 disappointment, even if solid showings from Stefon Diggs and Antonio Williams increase the risk that McLaurin lands closer to 20 percent than 25 percent this year. He might only need 5-6 looks to get it done in Dallas.

Start Over β€” Β Rome Odunze (vs. MIN), Stefon Diggs (at DAL), Deebo Samuel (vs. MIA), Chris Godwin (vs. CLE)

Coker seems ready to play through his ankle sprain, and while his Week 1 performance demands respect, he should nonetheless see favorable coverage looks while playing indoors against the Falcons in Week 2. Atlanta used single-high coverages at the third-highest rate in Week 1 (69%) after also logging the third-highest rate in 2025 (61%).Β 

Last year, the plan contributed to an opponent aDOT of 8.9, second-highest in the league, with 61.2 percent of opponent targets (8th most) going to WRs as Atlanta allowed the 11th-most PPR points to the position on the 19th-most opponent pass attempts. Both Coker and Tetairoa McMillan will get plenty of chances to win 1-on-1s, health permitting.

Tight Ends πŸ‘

Start Over β€” Tucker Kraft (at NYJ), Harold Fannin (at TB), Kyle Pitts (vs. CAR)

Joe Brady's first game as head coach saw Kincaid handle his largest snap share (77%) since Week 9 of 2024. It paid off for the Bills big time in the fourth quarter when their tight end broke off gains of 40 and 35 to finish with a career-high 130 yards. He won't have those kinds of huge plays every week, but the route and target volume should stick now that Kincaid's knee is healthy and Sean McDermott is gone.Β 

Even with the big jump in playing time last week, Kincaid took just 23 percent of his snaps aligned tight to the formation. He logged 20 snaps in "13 personnel", which was really more like 12 personnel because Kincaid lined up out wide on 12 of those plays (60%) and was in the slot or backfield on a few others. Regardless of the exact grouping, he should run plenty of routes Thursday night against a porous Detroit secondary that's dealing with a short week on the road after facing a league-high 86 plays in Week 1.

Sit/Downgrade πŸ‘Ž

Quarterbacks πŸ‘Ž

Start Instead β€” Trevor Lawrence (at DEN), Brock Purdy (vs. MIA), Jaxson Dart (at LAR), Matthew Stafford (vs. NYG)

With pocket passers, I tend to lean into betting odds for start/sit decisions because individual fantasy outlooks closely correspond with the overall team outlooks. Burrow, to be fair, accounts for a larger portion of his team's offense than a typical pocket passer. Still, it's alarming to see him with an implied team total of 21.5 (45.5 O/U, HOU -2.5). The Bengals live in the mid-to-high 20s and are healthy right now, so it seems there's not too much concern about Houston's disappointing defensive performance in Week 1.

I think that's correct, given the unique beast that is Josh Allen (and the Buffalo running game). For Week 1, the Texans led the NFL in single-high coverage rate (78%) and use of Cover 3 (56%), after ranking right around league average for both metrics in 2024 and 2025. It doesn't take a genius to figure out that Burrow, with a mediocre run game at his side, will see far more two-high looks. Plus, he's dealing with a minor back injury, and Nico Collins' likely absence on the other side of the game decreases the odds of a shootout like the one we saw last week between Houston and Buffalo.Β 

Running Backs πŸ‘Ž

Start Instead β€” Aaron Jones (at CHI), Chuba Hubbard (at ATL), Bhayshul Tuten (at DEN), Jadarian Price (at ARZ)

Etienne finished with 14.8 PPR points last week, despite getting just 49 percent of snaps and 50 percent of the Saints' RB opportunities before halftime. It seemed like Alvin Kamara's absence pushed Etienne towards more work on passing downs and fewer carries, which created early concerns but ultimately got the job done for fantasy managers.

This week, Kamara is back, and the Saints are again set up as considerable underdogs (-8.5), with an implied total of 19.0 points (26th). Etienne should get more of the snaps on early downs, which is good in general, but it might not work out in this game if many of last week's routes/targets shift to Kamara instead.Β 

I'll also add that last week's disappointing early usage raises some questions about how the coaches view Etienne, Kamara and Kendre Miller. I'm not ready to bury Etienne after one week, but it's definitely fair to question preseason assumptions about his role. Even if it works out OK for him, Etienne will be up against it this week, playing on the road against Jesse Minter's defense.

Wide Receivers πŸ‘Ž

Start Instead β€” Parker Washington (at DEN), Mike Evans (vs. MIA), DJ Moore (vs. DET)

Last week, Williams had the surrounding factors working in his favor but played poorly, including a couple of drops. He'll likely play better Thursday night, but now he's in a tougher situation, playing outdoors with major O-line concerns. The Lions won't have LG Christian Mahogany (hip) or RT Blake Miller (knee) on Thursday night, and while the over/under for the game is a whopping 54.5, the Lions' implied total of 24.5 points is actually south of where they land for basically any home game. We're of course still starting Williams in relatively deep leagues, but for shallower formats there are definitely WRs drafted after Williams who should be started over him in Week 2.Β 

Start Instead β€” Matthew Golden (at NYJ), Quentin Johnston (vs. LV), Michael Pittman (at NE)

Week 1 suggests Downs and Pierce will both be full-time players, so one or the other should emerge as a reliable fantasy starter eventually. My money is on Pierce, but I don't love him for Week 2, playing in a primetime game at Arrowhead Stadium in circumstances where both teams will want to run the ball. Maybe negative game script will lead to extra volume, or maybe it'll go like last week β€” for both the Colts and Chiefs β€” where the losing team doesn't see enough of the ball to pile up pass attempts.Β 

Editor's Note: Pierce missed Thursday's practice with a heel injury.

Other Tough Matchups: Ja'Marr Chase & Tee Higgins (at HOU); Malik Nabers (at LAR); Jameson Williams (at BUF); Drake London & Jahan Dotson (vs. CAR); Brian Thomas (at DEN)

Tight Ends πŸ‘Ž

Start Instead β€” Dallas Goedert (at TEN), Travis Kelce (vs. IND), Isaiah Likely (at LAR), Mark Andrews (vs. NO)

This is admittedly more about Deshaun Watson than the matchup, though Watson isn't the only concern for Fannin coming out of Week 1. The tight end looked fine from a real-life standpoint in the Week 1 loss at Jacksonville, but it's hard to make a fantasy argument when he's dealing with league-worst QB play and competing against KC Concepcion for the type of easy, schemed touches that helped make Fannin fantasy-relevant as a rookie.

Fannin is kind of like Tony Pollard in that Week 1 killed any slim hope for fantasy value in the current situation. For Pollard, it'll take a trade or Tyjae Spears missing time. For Fannin, the fix would be a stabilizing veteran QB like Mac Jones or Joe Flacco. That seems unlikely, but even Shedeur Sanders would probably be better than Watson for supporting Fannin's target volume. While not necessarily a big upgrade overall, Sanders at least can put the easy, quick passes where they need to be (for the most part) rather than turning one out of every three dropbacks into an adventure the way Watson does.

Streaming Picks

For Shallow Leagues (Under 65 Percent Rostered)

QB Baker Mayfield (vs. CLE)

RB Woody Marks (vs. DEN)

RB Kaelon Black (vs. MIA)

WR Jakobi Meyers (at DEN)

WR Khalil Shakir (vs. DET)

WR Devaughn Vele (at BAL)

TE Hunter Henry (vs. PIT)

TE Dalton Schultz (vs. CIN)

D/ST Buccaneers (vs. CLE)

D/ST 49ers (vs. MIA)

D/ST Chargers (vs. LV)

K Harrison Mevis (vs. NYG)

K Eddy Pineiro (vs. MIA)

Β  Β  Β 

For Medium-depth Leagues (Under 35 Percent Rostered)

QB Bryce Young (at ATL)

RB Tyjae Spears (vs. PHI)

RB Braelon Allen (vs. GB)

WR Pat Bryant (vs. JAX)

WR Malik Washington (at SF)

TE Brenton Strange (at DEN)

TE Michael Mayer (at LAC)

TE Pat Freiermuth (at NE)

K Chase McLaughlin (vs. CLE)

D/ST Bears (vs. MIN)

Β  Β 

For Deep Leagues (Under 10 Percent Rostered)

QB Carson Wentz (at CHI)

QB Geno Smith (vs. GB)

QB Drew Lock (at ARZ)

RB George Holani (at ARZ)

RB Chris Brooks (at NYJ)

RB Justice Hill (vs. NO)

RB Sione Vaki (at BUF)

WR Mack Hollins (vs. PIT)

WR Rashod Bateman (vs. NO)

WR Tre' Harris (vs. LV) - if McConkey is out

WR Demarcus Robinson (vs. MIA)

WR DeMario Douglas (vs. PIT)

WR Chris Moore (vs. NO) - if Flowers is out

WR Jauan Jennings (at CHI)

TE Cade Otton (vs. CLE)

TE Darren Waller (at ATL)

TE Gunnar Helm (vs. PHI)

K Ryan Fitzgerald (at ATL)

K Nick Folk (vs. CAR)

K Drew Stevens (at DAL)

D/ST Panthers (at ATL)

Β  Β  Β 

Fantasy Pass
Want to Read More?
The Fantasy Pass unlocks this article and every other one.

Season-long rankings, start/sit calls, and waiver advice from the analysts who wrote this piece. Subscribers can also talk it through with the author in the comments.

Season-long rankings, start/sit calls, and waiver advice from the analysts who wrote this piece.