Guillotine League Waiver Wire: Week 5 Pickups & FAAB Strategy

Steve Bulanda shares the waiver-wire strategy that guillotine champs use. While others are targeting bigger names, this is how you can improve your team and advance on a budget.
Guillotine League Waiver Wire: Week 5 Pickups & FAAB Strategy

Congratulations for surviving another week! Hopefully, your team is strong enough that you can coast through the next week or two. If not, it's important to upgrade your team strategically so that you don't set yourself up for failure later.

Each week I highlight a big-name player that most of the teams in your league will at least consider putting a bid on and a player who is more likely to fly under the radar at each position. At least early in the season, most of those "Popular Pickups" are players that I'm avoiding at their expected cost, while the "Bargain Bin" buys are players who I am targeting as options who could at least give me a one-week boost at the right price.

After delivering quite a few cheap contributors the first two weeks of this column, last week's "bargains" were big disappointments. We'll get back on track this week. 

Below are some of the key players available in at least 13 percent of NFFC Eliminator Championship leagues.

Quarterback

Popular Pickup: Drake Maye, Patriots
Available in 14% of NFFC Eliminator leagues

I highlighted Maye in this series three weeks ago, explaining that at the time he was nothing more than a player to stash if you could somehow get him at a DEEP discount. I projected (correctly) that he would continue to struggle for a couple more weeks. In one of my leagues, I was shocked to see someone bid $354 on him! Don't be like that guy.

Congratulations for surviving another week! Hopefully, your team is strong enough that you can coast through the next week or two. If not, it's important to upgrade your team strategically so that you don't set yourself up for failure later.

Each week I highlight a big-name player that most of the teams in your league will at least consider putting a bid on and a player who is more likely to fly under the radar at each position. At least early in the season, most of those "Popular Pickups" are players that I'm avoiding at their expected cost, while the "Bargain Bin" buys are players who I am targeting as options who could at least give me a one-week boost at the right price.

After delivering quite a few cheap contributors the first two weeks of this column, last week's "bargains" were big disappointments. We'll get back on track this week. 

Below are some of the key players available in at least 13 percent of NFFC Eliminator Championship leagues.

Quarterback

Popular Pickup: Drake Maye, Patriots
Available in 14% of NFFC Eliminator leagues

I highlighted Maye in this series three weeks ago, explaining that at the time he was nothing more than a player to stash if you could somehow get him at a DEEP discount. I projected (correctly) that he would continue to struggle for a couple more weeks. In one of my leagues, I was shocked to see someone bid $354 on him! Don't be like that guy. Maye finally had a good game in Week 4, but that was against a Bills team that every QB has been able to exploit so far. 

With Patrick Mahomes and Bryce Young on bye in Week 5 and a number of significant QB injuries, Maye is a top 10 option this week, but I wouldn't pay a top 10 rest-of-season price for him. FAAB Recommendation: 2 percent of budget

Bargain Bin: Jacoby Brissett, Cardinals
Available in 29% of NFFC Eliminator leagues

What do Tyler Shough, Josh Allen, Geno Smith and Bryce Young have in common? They all scored at least 28 fantasy points against the Detroit Lions (in NFFC Eliminator scoring). A matchup between Arizona and Detroit sets up as a potential shootout, and Brissett has enough weapons to keep up. He's a player who I will be starting in multiple deeper leagues like guillotine leagues. His questionable full season outlook should still keep him as an affordable option. FAAB Recommendation: 2 percent of budget

For more resources to help you survive the chop, check out our Elimination Odds, Rankings, and FAAB ROI Tools.

Running Back

Popular Pickup: Saquon Barkley, Eagles
Available in 13% of NFFC Eliminator leagues

Like Maye, Barkley is making his second appearance in this series, which is not a good sign for him. Once again, you can blame an in-game injury for the low output that led to so many owners getting chopped, but the overall lack of production is discouraging. Zero touchdowns. Four total receptions for eight yards. If he's on your roster and he's in the Eagles' lineup, you're going to be tempted to start him, and right now you're better off letting someone else pay for the big name and (likely) live to regret it. The only redeeming quality so far has been his 5.1 yards per carry average, which makes him worth a "keep 'em honest" bid to see if he falls through the cracks. FAAB Recommendation: 3 percent of budget

Bargain Bin: Emanuel Wilson, Seahawks
Available in 28% of NFFC Eliminator leagues

After tallying 81 yards and a TD on 21 carries, it's going to be harder to get Wilson at a clearance price. However, I think it helps that the Seahawks brought in Joe Mixon for a visit. Even if Seattle was just looking to add depth, it gives the perception that the team is not satisfied with who they have now. Later this season I doubt there will be any Seattle RB that we even want to roster, but Wilson is a solid short-term option as long as he's getting 15+ touches. FAAB Recommendation: 3 percent of budget

For up-to-the-minute updates on injuries, news and everything going on around the NFL, head to RotoWire's NFL Fantasy Football News Today or follow @RotoWireNFL on X.

Wide Receiver

Popular Pickup: Jaxon Smith-Njigba
Available in 14% of NFFC Eliminator leagues

After a dominant three week run, Smith-Njigba came back down to Earth for at least one game, resulting in his availability in many guillotine leagues. JSN represents one of the few players that I'm willing to be aggressive to acquire at this point in the season. After getting a sampling of him with his backup QB, we can confidently say that he's one of the few difference-makers who will be a must-start for the rest of the season even if injuries strike around him. FAAB Recommendation: 35 percent of budget

Bargain Bin: Roman Wilson, Steelers
Available in 40% of NFFC Eliminator leagues

On the other hand, if you're just looking for a cheap option who could fill in for one week, consider Roman Wilson. Despite a lower snap share, he has received six targets in each game with at least 60 yards and a TD in each of the past two. While Michael Pittman and Aaron Rodgers can't seem to get on the same page, Wilson has emerged as a consistent contributor. Next up are the Colts, who rank fourth worst in the league in pass yards allowed. FAAB Recommendation: 1 percent of budget

Tight End

Popular Pickup: Kyle Pitts, Falcons
Available in 25% of NFFC Eliminator leagues

Maybe "popular" is the wrong word in this spot, but Pitts is still a big name who a lot of fantasy managers had hope for when Michael Penix returned at quarterback. Maybe you've already sworn him off, but for those who are considering giving him another chance, consider this an intervention. I am confident that Pitts still has an 80-yard and a TD game or two in him this season, but you'll never know when it's coming. It's better to just avoid him and opt for a more reliable, consistent option, even if the ceiling is lower... FAAB Recommendation: Avoid

Bargain Bin: Mike Gesicki, Bengals
Available in 49% of NFFC Eliminator leagues

I was surprised when I looked back to Gesicki's first year in Cincinnati and saw that he had 65 catches on 83 targets for 665 yards because I don't remember him having more than a flash week here and there in a Bengals uniform. This year has been a bit different, as he has at least 37 yards and a TD in three of four games. With injuries to Ja'Marr Chase (concussion), Tee Higgins (adductor) and Andrei Iosivas (thumb), Gesicki could be in position for a bigger role in Week 5. FAAB Recommendation: less than 1 percent of budget

*This is a good week for bargain tight ends, as T.J. Hockenson and Tyler Higbee also represent strong short-term options

Use RotoWire's Start/Sit tool to help decide who should be in your lineup. Our projections system runs 25,000 simulations to see who wins the most head-to-head battles in Week 5 to help you make an informed choice.

Kickers and DST

If your league uses kickers and/or team defense, don't spend more than 1 percent on any player or team. We should be looking in the bargain bin for both positions.

Bargain Bin: Chad Ryland, Cardinals
Available in 95% of NFFC Eliminator leagues

Ryland was one of the top kickers in 2024 with 28 field goals made in just 13 games. Only five players made more field goals and hit a higher percentage than he did (87.5%). This season he has at least nine points in three of four games, and now the Cardinals will face a Detroit team that they should be able to exploit. Bonus: his next four games will all be played indoors, so we won't have to worry about weather becoming a factor. FAAB Recommendation: less than 1 percent of budget

Bargain Bin: Cincinnati Bengals DST
Available in 52% of NFFC Eliminator leagues

The Bengals are currently fifth in NFFC scoring with a favorable matchup with Miami up next. They do have a Week 6 bye, so you'll need to plan for that, but then they could be facing a Ravens team without Lamar Jackson (ankle) followed by the lowly Titans. FAAB Recommendation: less than 1 percent of budget

Fantasy Pass
Want to Read More?
The Fantasy Pass unlocks this article and every other one.

Season-long rankings, start/sit calls, and waiver advice from the analysts who wrote this piece. Subscribers can also talk it through with the author in the comments.

Season-long rankings, start/sit calls, and waiver advice from the analysts who wrote this piece.