Streaming Defenses: D/ST Picks for Week 5

Jerry Donabedian runs through his favorite D/ST plays for Week 5, including the Bengals, Jaguars and Cowboys. Plus, a look-ahead to Week 6 and updated ROS ranks.
Streaming Defenses: D/ST Picks for Week 5

Injuries to quarterbacks often drive headlines around here, but the top options this week are two defenses up against offenses with injury issues in other areas. It should be a good slate for streaming, as many of the top matchups go to D/STs that are widely available in fantasy leagues.

Note: These recommendations are limited to team defenses that are rostered on less than 50 percent of teams on Yahoo or 60 percent on FFPC. Any references to fantasy points are based on Yahoo standard scoring, which doesn't include yards allowed.

Top Streaming Options for Week 5

1. Cincinnati Bengals (at MIA)

  • 24% Yahoo, 54% FFPC
  • Team implied total: 24.75     Opponent implied total: 17.75
  • Upcoming Ranks (Projected) — Week 6: BYE,  Week 7: 25th (at BAL)

The Bengals have a competent defense for the first time in years, ranking in the top half of the league for a slew of traditional and advanced metrics. Matchups have helped, but the Bengals also held their own this past Sunday in what many expected to be a shootout against the Jags. Next up is a trip to Miami, where the home team is a seven-point underdog and has given up the sixth-most fantasy points to D/STs. Every defense that's faced the Dolphins this year has scored at least eight fantasy points, and any hope for a respectable offense went out the door with De'Von Achane's ACL tear

2. Jacksonville Jaguars (vs. PHI) - in London

  • 55% Yahoo, 79% FFPC
  • Team

Injuries to quarterbacks often drive headlines around here, but the top options this week are two defenses up against offenses with injury issues in other areas. It should be a good slate for streaming, as many of the top matchups go to D/STs that are widely available in fantasy leagues.

Note: These recommendations are limited to team defenses that are rostered on less than 50 percent of teams on Yahoo or 60 percent on FFPC. Any references to fantasy points are based on Yahoo standard scoring, which doesn't include yards allowed.

Top Streaming Options for Week 5

1. Cincinnati Bengals (at MIA)

  • 24% Yahoo, 54% FFPC
  • Team implied total: 24.75     Opponent implied total: 17.75
  • Upcoming Ranks (Projected) — Week 6: BYE,  Week 7: 25th (at BAL)

The Bengals have a competent defense for the first time in years, ranking in the top half of the league for a slew of traditional and advanced metrics. Matchups have helped, but the Bengals also held their own this past Sunday in what many expected to be a shootout against the Jags. Next up is a trip to Miami, where the home team is a seven-point underdog and has given up the sixth-most fantasy points to D/STs. Every defense that's faced the Dolphins this year has scored at least eight fantasy points, and any hope for a respectable offense went out the door with De'Von Achane's ACL tear

2. Jacksonville Jaguars (vs. PHI) - in London

  • 55% Yahoo, 79% FFPC
  • Team implied total: 24.75     Opponent implied total: 17.75
  • Upcoming Ranks (Projected) — Week 6: 8th (vs. HOU),  Week 7: BYE

This matchup opened at -3.5 on Sunday evening and had already moved to -7 by Tuesday morning. The Eagles have looked that bad on offense, and it's unclear whether any of the following will play this week: RB Saquon Barkley (hamstring), WR DeVonta Smith (hamstring), TE Dallas Goedert (knee), RT Lane Johnson (personal), LG Cam Jurgens (concussion). That's five starters down, and none of them looks any better than 50/50 at the start of the week. Even the depth is shot, with OT Fred Johnson (knee), RB Tank Bigsby (core muscle) and WR Hollywood Brown (ankle) also unlikely/uncertain for Week 5.

Note: After writing this, I realized the Jaguars don't quite qualify for this article, based on the rostered thresholds mentioned above. However, they're available in a bunch of my 12-team leagues, including on FFPC, so I'll leave them here as an unofficial pick and include an "official" sixth defense below. The distinction only matters for when I run numbers at the end of the season to confirm that we had another successful year of streaming.

3. Dallas Cowboys (vs. TB)

  • 16% Yahoo, 18% FFPC
  • Team implied total: 27.75     Opponent implied total: 19.75
  • Upcoming Ranks (Projected) — Week 6: 19th (at GB),  Week 7: 14th (at PHI)

This is obviously a pure matchup play, betting that undrafted rookie Jalon Daniels will make mistakes even against one of the worst defenses in the league. In his first start, he threw two interceptions and took three sacks in a home loss to a subpar Packers team. The Dallas defense is even worse than Green Bay's, but the Cowboys have home-field advantage and are favored by eight points, setting up the possibility that Tampa is forced to abandon the run and take more risks with an overmatched rookie QB.

4. New York Jets (vs. CLE)

  • 3% Yahoo, 13% FFPC
  • Team implied total: 21.0     Opponent implied total: 19.0
  • Upcoming Ranks (Projected) — Week 6: 25th (at NE),  Week 7: 3rd (vs. MIA)

I'm not sure I buy the Jets as a two-point favorite here, given that Cleveland is the healthier of the two teams and playing better of late. I also don't buy Deshaun Watson, whose accuracy on short and intermediate passes remains sub-backup level. He can still throw a decent deep ball, for whatever reason, but any other success for the Cleveland offense has been despite Watson, not because of him. There's an argument to start either defense from this game, as the Jets are banged up and playing poorly on offense. In fact, I likely would've listed the Browns here instead of the Jets if Cleveland hadn't just lost star defensive tackle Mason Graham to a knee sprain. As is, the Jets get a slight advantage, based on Watson being much worse than even Geno Smith.

5. Washington Commanders (vs. NYG)

  • 1% Yahoo, 6% FFPC
  • Team implied total: 23.5    Opponent implied total: 20.0
  • Upcoming Ranks (Projected) — Week 6: 27th (at SF),  Week 7: BYE

I initially saw this spot as a toss-up between the Commanders and Falcons, both favored by 3.5 points for home games against backup quarterbacks. Atlanta's defense is perhaps a bit more trustworthy than Washington's, but the Falcons will face a caretaker backup (Tyler Huntley) with just 10 INTs on 551 career attempts, whereas the Commanders get mistake-prone Jameis Winston. The flip side, of course, is that Winston is more capable of pushing the ball downfield. Let's hope he tries, as those risky throws/playcalls are where we make our living with sacks and turnovers for D/ST scoring.

6. Cleveland Browns (at NYJ)

  • 15% Yahoo, 46% FFPC
  • Team implied total: 19.0    Opponent implied total: 21.0
  • Upcoming Ranks (Projected) — Week 6: 17th (vs. BAL),  Week 7: BYE

There are plenty of similarly good options at this point, and the Browns could end up at the front of their tier if Gang Green's injury reports hint at continued trouble. Last week, the Jets didn't have RB Breece Hall (groin), WR Adonai Mitchell (finger), LG Dylan Parham (knee) or TE Mason Taylor (thumb). They may not be standouts, besides Hall, but the Jets aren't exactly drowning in quality depth and didn't fare well last week with those 200 or so combined snaps taken off the table.

Week 5 Rankings

Tier 1: HOU, CIN, JAX 

Tier 2: DAL, DEN

Tier 3: NYJ, MIN, WAS, CLE, PIT, ATL, CHI, NE, NO

  1. Texans (at TEN)
  2. Bengals (at MIA) 
  3. Jaguars (vs. PHI)  
  4. Cowboys (vs. TB) 
  5. Broncos (at LAC)  
  6. Jets (vs. CLE) 
  7. Vikings (at NO) 
  8. Commanders (vs. NYG) - assuming QB Jayden Daniels plays 
  9. Browns (at NYJ) - treating Hall/Parham/Mitchell/Taylor as 50/50
  10. Steelers (vs. IND)
  11. Falcons (vs. BAL) - assuming QB Lamar Jackson is out 
  12. Bears (at GB) 
  13. Patriots (vs. LV)
  14. Saints (vs. MIN) - treating WR Justin Jefferson as 50/50
  15. Seahawks (vs. SF) 
  16. Ravens (at ATL)
  17. Packers (vs. CHI) 
  18. Colts (at PIT) 
  19. Giants (at WAS) - assuming Jayden Daniels plays
  20. Chargers (vs. DEN)

Looking Ahead to Week 6

  1. Colts (vs. TEN)
  2. Ravens (at CLE)
  3. Rams (vs. ARZ)
  4. Patriots (vs. NYJ)
  5. Chiefs (vs. LAC)
  6. Steelers (at TB) 
  7. 49ers (vs. WAS) 
  8. Jaguars (vs. HOU)
  9. Seahawks (at DEN)
  10. Broncos (vs. SEA)
  11. Buccaneers (vs. PIT)
  12. Saints (at NYG)
  13. Giants (vs. NO)
  14. Panthers (at PHI)
  15. Eagles (vs. CAR)
  16. Texans (at JAX) 
  17. Browns (vs. BAL)
  18. Bears (at ATL)
  19. Falcons (vs. CHI)
  20. Cowboys (at GB)

Rest-of-Season Rankings

  1. Seattle Seahawks 
  2. Minnesota Vikings 
  3. Denver Broncos   
  4. Los Angeles Rams 
  5. Baltimore Ravens  
  6. Houston Texans 
  7. Jacksonville Jaguars  
  8. Kansas City Chiefs 
  9. Cincinnati Bengals 
  10. Pittsburgh Steelers  
  11. Philadelphia Eagles  
  12. New England Patriots
  13. Buffalo Bills
  14. Detroit Lions
  15. San Francisco 49ers 
  16. Cleveland Browns  
  17. New York Giants 
  18. Washington Commanders 
  19. Los Angeles Chargers 
  20. Tampa Bay Buccaneers  

           

Fantasy Pass
Want to Read More?
The Fantasy Pass unlocks this article and every other one.

Season-long rankings, start/sit calls, and waiver advice from the analysts who wrote this piece. Subscribers can also talk it through with the author in the comments.

Season-long rankings, start/sit calls, and waiver advice from the analysts who wrote this piece.