Week 2 is here! Time to overreact to 60 minutes of football!
I'll break down my weekly TE rankings and tiers each and every week *with* some bigger-picture questions sprinkled in along the way. This week's additional topics feature:
- Is it time to fully buy into Dalton Kincaid as a top-5 fantasy TE?
- Was Isaiah Likely's Week 1 boom another fluke?
- Who have been the league's most-productive tight ends the last half season?
- Which defenses have been the worst at defending tight ends the last 12 months?
- Who are the best prospective under-owned TE bench stashes?
As always: It's a great day to be great.
Tier 1: The Big Three
- TE1: Trey McBride (vs. SEA). Trails only Puka Nacua, Jaxon Smith-Njigba and Amon-Ra St. Brown in PPR points per game among wide receivers and tight ends since Week 1, 2025. Do you realize how insane that is? McBride is out-scoring Ja'Marr Chase the last 19 weeks. And alleged fantasy experts like myself still found reasons to not draft this man as much as possible in August. I need a drink.
- TE2: Colston Loveland (vs. MIN). The Week 1 goose-egg heard round the world could have been better with a bit more accuracy from Caleb Williams on Loveland's two targets, but still: We'll need more than two targets to live up to the hype here. That said, R-e-l-a-x. Loveland actually led all Bears pass-catchers with an 89 percent route rate in Week 1, and the fact Ben Johnson and
Week 2 is here! Time to overreact to 60 minutes of football!
I'll break down my weekly TE rankings and tiers each and every week *with* some bigger-picture questions sprinkled in along the way. This week's additional topics feature:
- Is it time to fully buy into Dalton Kincaid as a top-5 fantasy TE?
- Was Isaiah Likely's Week 1 boom another fluke?
- Who have been the league's most-productive tight ends the last half season?
- Which defenses have been the worst at defending tight ends the last 12 months?
- Who are the best prospective under-owned TE bench stashes?
As always: It's a great day to be great.
Tier 1: The Big Three
- TE1: Trey McBride (vs. SEA). Trails only Puka Nacua, Jaxon Smith-Njigba and Amon-Ra St. Brown in PPR points per game among wide receivers and tight ends since Week 1, 2025. Do you realize how insane that is? McBride is out-scoring Ja'Marr Chase the last 19 weeks. And alleged fantasy experts like myself still found reasons to not draft this man as much as possible in August. I need a drink.
- TE2: Colston Loveland (vs. MIN). The Week 1 goose-egg heard round the world could have been better with a bit more accuracy from Caleb Williams on Loveland's two targets, but still: We'll need more than two targets to live up to the hype here. That said, R-e-l-a-x. Loveland actually led all Bears pass-catchers with an 89 percent route rate in Week 1, and the fact Ben Johnson and Caleb Williams looked so good as a whole is ultimately a good thing for everyone involved in this offense. I'm not panicking, and if your leaguemates are, go get yourself one of the game's best young tight ends at a discount.
- TE3: Dalton Kincaid (vs. DET on TNF). Dalton Kincaid TE3? In this economy? Hear me out …
Key question: Is it time to fully buy into Dalton Kincaid as a top-5 fantasy TE?
I said top 5 instead of top 3 because maybe we do see Brock Bowers (knee) return this week, but yeah: Kincaid's season-opening role was the single-biggest storyline among tight ends and puts him in a position to finally live up to the hype that has always gone hand-in-hand with a first-round pass-catcher playing alongside Josh Allen.
Just look at what this man pulled off in Week 1:
- Snaps: 77%
- Routes: 69%
- Targets per route run: 27%
- Target share: 23%
And MAN was Kincaid impressive with the opportunities. His 5-130-0 receiving line doesn't even tell the whole story. There was the jump ball win over ace Texans CB Derek Stingley. The big-time YAC moment late in the fourth quarter. Simply being too big and fast for mere mortals to keep up with.
I am fully buying the breakout performance. The Bills threw more than last year in Week 1 (+7% improvement in dropback rate over expected) and have the sort of depth chart to set up Kincaid as Allen's No. 2 pass-game option. Reminder: This man has put up per-route efficiency that is up there with some of the game's best receivers the last 12 months. The ceiling is the moon with this newfound full-time role.
Tier 2: Cemented TE1s You can Feel Good About
- TE4: Tyler Warren (at KC on SNF). Found his way into the end zone even in a tough matchup against Kyle Hamilton and the Ravens. Up next is a Chiefs defense that he didn't exactly eviscerate in Week 12 last season (5-45-0), but the 2026 edition did manage to give up Evan Engram's yearly touchdown in Week 1. Note that we're keeping an eye on Keenan Allen (6 targets in Week 1) becoming a thorn in everyone's side here, but for now Warren is a big-time talent with a full-time role (88% route rate) in a passing game very willing to feed him designed targets.
- TE5: Isaiah Likely (at LAR on MNF). More on if Likely's season-opening 8-78-2 boom was real or a fugazzi shortly!
- TE6: Dallas Goedert (at TEN). The savvy vet has scored 15 touchdowns in his last 17 games. Madness! There's a low floor if Goedert ever decided to not score a touchdown — he's only cleared 50 yards in four of his last 16 games — but his consistent red-zone opportunities also don't appear to be drying up anytime soon. Look for Goedert to stay hot against a Titans defense that allowed the eighth-most scores to the position in 2025.
- TE7: Sam LaPorta (at BUF on TNF). Season-opening 5-48-0 receiving line came on an elite 83 percent route rate. We saw Jameson Williams out-target LaPorta 9 vs. 8, but even having a 2A/2B situation in this high-octane passing game should be more than enough to provide consistent TE1 production. Get your popcorn ready for LaPorta's Thursday night shootout — Bills-Lions has the highest game total on the slate. These two squads went for 90 points the last time they matched up!
Key question: Was Isaiah Likely's Week 1 boom another fluke?
I say another fluke because we've seen this story before: Likely erupted with a season-opening 9-111-1 receiving line (an inch away from another touchdown) in 2024 … and proceeded to finish the season as the TE20 in PPR points per game.
However, this time: I'm thinking it's different. After all, there's no Mark Andrews to share the field with in New York. Theo Johnson is fine, but make no mistake about it: Likely is THE non-Nabers focal point of this Giants passing attack:
- 68% routes
- 35% targets per route run
- 29% target share
- 28% air yard share
The walking mismatch is too fast for linebackers and too big for cornerbacks to deal with. Maybe certain stud safeties can hang, but future star Cowboys S Caleb Downs wasn't up to the task in Week 1.
Ultimately: Likely has a near full-time role in an offense without a clear No. 2 target with a young QB who has objectively played quite well to start his career. That's a pretty great combo, and accordingly I don't need two full hands to count the number of tight ends I'd rather have on the fantasy squad the rest of the way.
Tier 3: Studs with Questions
- TE8: Tucker Kraft (at NYJ). Ran a route on just 48 percent of Jordan Love's dropbacks in Week 1. The Packers wanted to limit Kraft to 40 snaps, but he wound up playing 45. Expect this to continue to rise as the season goes on — he'd be my TE4 this week if there were *zero* playing time concerns. Either way: It was intriguing to see the manner in which Kraft was used: Last year Kraft posted a lowly 4.8-yard average target depth (pretty easily the lowest mark among the top-24 highest-scoring tight ends) but in Week 1 he sat at 11.8! He had three targets on passes thrown 15-plus yards downfield after only having six all of last season! That's nucking futs, people!
- TE9: George Kittle (vs. MIA). Similar story here: Kittle played a part-time role (47% routes), but was targeted plenty when he was out there (29% targets per route run). It was a minor miracle that Kittle was even on the field in Week 1 in Australia, let alone healthy enough to earn five targets and look decent enough with the football in his hands. Don't expect the 49ers to need to keep their foot on the gas for 60 minutes in this one, but at the same time, 5-6 targets might be all the future Hall of Famer needs to pay off this ranking. We'll continue to see Kraft and Kittle rise up these ranks as their playing time increases.
- TE10: Mark Andrews (vs. NO). Sent 4-49-0 to start the season and didn't look totally washed. Throw in Lamar Jackson looking quite good, and a full-time 77 percent route rate, and Andrews is deserving of top-10 treatment as the potential No. 2 pass-game option in an offense implied to score the third-most points in Week 2.
- TE11: Juwan Johnson (at BAL). Since Week 8 last season, Johnson has finished as a top-10 TE on six occasions. While Noah Fant was plenty involved from a target perspective as well in Week 1, Johnson still easily led the way in routes (81% vs. 29%). The problem: Kyle Hamilton and the Ravens present a MUCH steeper challenge than the Lions without both of their starting safeties.
- TE12: Harold Fannin (at TB). Good news: Fannin played a near full-time role (77% routes) and is a certified good football player. Bad news: Deshaun Watson is not, and KC Concepcion appears to be eating into some of Fannin's designed underneath targets.
- TE13: Travis Kelce (vs. IND on SNF). Season-opening 3-71-0 line was almost entirely thanks to a 59-yard play … that realistically should have been called back by a pretty obvious Rashee Rice hold. I'm refraining from being too optimistic about the fantasy upside of ANY Chiefs not named Kenneth Walker until this passing game shows any signs of life.
- TE14: Kyle Pitts Sr. (vs. CAR). Pitts could've had a 30-plus yard chunk gain if Cooper Rush knew how to throw a football. Sadly, that's not the case, and the potential for the NFL's worst starting QB to again be under center in Week 2 makes Pitts a VERY rough start. I'd move Pitts up to at least TE10 if we get Michael Penix or Tua Tagovailoa under center this week.
Key question: Who have been the league's most-productive tight ends the last half season?
The top-12 tight ends in PPR points per game since Week 10 of last season (min. 5 games):
- Trey McBride (21.1)
- George Kittle (16.4)
- Kyle Pitts (13.7)
- Brock Bowers (12.8)
- Dallas Goedert (12)
- Colby Parkinson (11.8)
- Juwan Johnson (11.7)
- Harold Fannin (11.6)
- Colston Loveland (11.3)
- Brenton Strange (11)
- Dalton Schultz (10.9)
- Hunter Henry (10.5)
Main takeaways: FREE KYLE PITTS, keep on keeping on Dallas, Colby Parkinson lol, Juwan Johnson TE7 and you could do worse on a flyer than Strange or Schultz. Speaking of …
Tier 4: Would be a Lot Cooler if You had a Better Option
- TE15: Dalton Schultz (vs. CIN). The Bengals shut down Cade Otton in Week 1, which … isn't really saying much. Schultz has weekly upside to work as this passing game's No. 2 option and finds himself with a great matchup against a defense that was historically bad against tight ends all the way back in 2025.
- TE16: Jake Ferguson (vs. WAS). The Commanders gave up two scores to Dallas Goedert in Week 1, but Ferguson simply hasn't been much of a factor when CeeDee Lamb has been healthy the last two seasons.
- TE17: Michael Mayer (at LAC). Carries upside to lead the Raiders in targets, though I'm pessimistic about Mayer having as much success against Derwin James as Trey McBride managed in Week 1.
- TE18: Brenton Strange (at DEN). Went 5-39-1 against this very Broncos defense last season. Strange has scored four touchdowns in his last seven games. Don't be surprised if that continues as long as Trevor Lawrence keeps playing like one of the best QBs in football.
- TE19: T.J. Hockenson (at CHI). Had a near full-time role (77%) in Week 1 and gets to match up against a Bears secondary that allowed two (nullified) touchdowns to tight ends last week.
- TE20: Hunter Henry (vs. PIT). Could be back to being a featured pass-game option with A.J. Brown sidelined, though his routes (60%) took a hit from rookie Eli Raridon (24%) in Week 1.
- TE21: Chig Okonkwo (at DAL). Questionable with a hamstring injury, but set up for success if active against a Cowboys defense that still looks awfully mediocre in the year 2026.
- TE22: Kenyon Sadiq (vs. GB). It was good to see the Jets find creative ways to get the football in their first-round tight end's hands in Week 1. It was not good to see Mason Taylor run more routes (62% vs. 46%). Hopefully the absence of Omar Cooper (ankle) leads to more of a full-time role for Sadiq moving forward.
Key question: Which defenses have been the worst at defending tight ends the last 12 months?
Spoiler: The Bengals.
If you need a flyer, Dalton Schultz is your guy!
Tier 5: You Never Know
- TE23: Pat Freiermuth (at NE). Posted a stellar 74 percent route rate on his way to scoring 15.6 fantasy points in Week 1. A tougher matchup with the Patriots awaits, but Muth will rise up the ranks if Darnell Washington remains a clear No. 2 as opposed to a 1B in the passing game.
- TE24: Mike Gesicki (at HOU). Boomed with 18.8 fantasy points in Week 1 … on a 46 percent route rate. Don't count on Gesicki out-producing both Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins many (any?) more times this season.
- TE25: Greg Dulcich (at SF). The Dolphins have a lot of work to do on offense in general, but it was at least good to see Dulcich have a near full-time 76 percent route rate. Of course, that doesn't mean as much inside RotoWire's lowest projected passing game entering Week 2.
- TE26: Colby Parkinson (vs. NYG on MNF). Led the way in routes (62%) over T-Ferg (45%). Sigh. Tyler Higbee (14%) and Davis Allen (14%) were also involved because why not. Can you tell I drafted too much Terrance Ferguson this offseason? While the rising second-year talent probably still offers the most best-case upside of anyone in this room, us fantasy nerds simply didn't see the Week 1 usage we were hoping for. I'm trying to keep Ferguson stashed for one more week just in case, but it's not looking good.
- TE27: Terrance Ferguson (vs. NYG on MNF).
Key question: Who are the best prospective under-owned TE bench stashes?
Ferguson still applies, but I'm also intrigued about Oronde Gadsden. Sure, the Chargers prioritized David Njoku in the passing game in Week 1, but it was at least good news that Gadsden out-targeted Charlie Kolar. The team tried out Marquez Valdes-Scantling this week with Ladd McConkey (ribs) banged up. At some point, wouldn't it make sense to get Gadsden on the field more often?
Much like Week 1 darlings Kincaid and Likely: Gadsden fits the bill as a talented receiver who just needs a full-time role to skyrocket up the fantasy ranks. That role isn't here today, but who's to say what tomorrow might look like?
