Fantasy Football Waiver Wire Week 5: High-Stakes & Deep League Adds (FFPC/NFFC)

Theo Gremminger analyzes the top Week 5 waiver-wire adds for high-stakes and deep leagues, including the possible return of wide receiver Tyreek Hill to Kansas City.
Fantasy Football Waiver Wire Week 5: High-Stakes & Deep League Adds (FFPC/NFFC)

Injuries continue to torment fantasy managers week-in and week-out. Not only are starters going down, even our high-end handcuffs are getting injured.

We planned for Tank Bigsby's contingent upside all offseason and talked about him early on in this column. Saquon Barkley gets injured and Bigsby is the next man up. Easy thesis to follow. Now Bigsby is IR-bound himself, leaving a huge opportunity for Will Shipley in Philadelphia.

Keep those RB3s on speed dial. 

Sometimes the waiver wire is a luxury. You make it through the week unscathed, add some depth and move on. Not this year. Players are getting picked up and put directly into our starting lineups. At least some of the replacements delivered last week, with Ollie Gordon and Emanuel Wilson both producing.

And now we have to deal with dreaded bye weeks.

At least Week 5 only takes two teams away from us before the bye-week gauntlet really gets going over the following few weeks.

Let's go find some players and improve our rosters. 

UPCOMING BYE WEEKS

Week 5: Panthers, Chiefs

Week 6: Bengals, Lions, Dolphins, Vikings

Week 7: Bills, Jaguars, Chargers, Commanders

Week 8: Texans, Saints, Giants, 49ers

PRIORITY ADDS

1. Will Shipley, RB, Eagles 

2. Emanuel Wilson, RB, Seahawks 

3. Keon Coleman, WR, Bills 

4. Tre' Harris, WR, Chargers

5. Tyreek Hill, WR, Free Agent 

6. Mike Gesicki, TE, Bengals (must start if Chase or

Injuries continue to torment fantasy managers week-in and week-out. Not only are starters going down, even our high-end handcuffs are getting injured.

We planned for Tank Bigsby's contingent upside all offseason and talked about him early on in this column. Saquon Barkley gets injured and Bigsby is the next man up. Easy thesis to follow. Now Bigsby is IR-bound himself, leaving a huge opportunity for Will Shipley in Philadelphia.

Keep those RB3s on speed dial. 

Sometimes the waiver wire is a luxury. You make it through the week unscathed, add some depth and move on. Not this year. Players are getting picked up and put directly into our starting lineups. At least some of the replacements delivered last week, with Ollie Gordon and Emanuel Wilson both producing.

And now we have to deal with dreaded bye weeks.

At least Week 5 only takes two teams away from us before the bye-week gauntlet really gets going over the following few weeks.

Let's go find some players and improve our rosters. 

UPCOMING BYE WEEKS

Week 5: Panthers, Chiefs

Week 6: Bengals, Lions, Dolphins, Vikings

Week 7: Bills, Jaguars, Chargers, Commanders

Week 8: Texans, Saints, Giants, 49ers

PRIORITY ADDS

1. Will Shipley, RB, Eagles 

2. Emanuel Wilson, RB, Seahawks 

3. Keon Coleman, WR, Bills 

4. Tre' Harris, WR, Chargers

5. Tyreek Hill, WR, Free Agent 

6. Mike Gesicki, TE, Bengals (must start if Chase or Higgins miss) 

7. Dohnte Meyers, WR, Bengals (short-term streamer HAS Week 5 value) 

8. Jacoby Brissett, QB, Cardinals (Matchup based Week 5 streamer) 

9. Michael Mayer, TE, Raiders (FFPC priority)

9 (TIE). Tyler Higbee, TE, Rams (short-term value)

10. Roman Wilson, WR, Steelers (NFFC priority) 

10 (TIE).  Kirk Cousins, QB, Raiders

PLAYERS TO CHECK AND MAKE SURE NOT AVAILABLE/SHALLOW LEAGUE ADDS: Jordyn Tyson, WR, Saints (off IR soon), Keaton Mitchell, RB, Chargers, Malik Washington, WR, Dolphins, Brian Robinson, RB, Falcons, Jonah Coleman, RB, Broncos (on IR), Kenyon Sadiq, TE, Jets (If someone rage dropped after Week 4's 0)

QUARTERBACKS

C.J. Stroud, Texans: Stroud had his best game of the season, passing for 347 yards and two TDs against Dallas. He is fifth among all QBs in passing yards and has yet to throw an interception this season. Houston is extremely pass-heavy. This has been a very positive start for Stroud, and he should be rostered in all formats.

Kirk Cousins, Raiders: Cousins passed for 365 yards and two TDs against Kansas City. He is thriving in the Kubiak offense and already has 11 TD passes this season.

Jalon Daniels, Buccaneers: Daniels is fantasy-friendly because of his rushing ability, totaling 55 yards on eight carries while adding 148 through the air. He gets Dallas this week.

Aaron Rodgers, Steelers: Great matchup this week against Indianapolis. Rodgers is on a heater with 290+ passing yards and six TDs over his last two games.

Deshaun Watson, Browns: Bench-depth QB for bye weeks.

Michael Penix, Falcons: Superflex starter. 

Jacoby Brissett, Cardinals: Brissett threw three interceptions against New York, including a pick-six at the end of the game. This week he gets a get-right matchup against a soft Lions defense that has been shredded by Geno Smith and Bryce Young over the last two weeks.

Tyson Bagent, Bears: Bagent passed for 268 yards against the Jets in a game when the Bears ran for about a million yards. There was not a ton of passing volume needed here, but Bagent did his job. He immediately enters the superflex conversation this week.

Tyler Huntley, Ravens: Huntley becomes a must-add option for superflex managers and a consideration for single-QB managers in a bad spot. He has rushing ability, and the Zay Flowers/Derrick Henry skill-position combination is about as good as it gets. There is immediate fantasy appeal here.

RUNNING BACKS

Emanuel Wilson, Seahawks: Wilson delivered when given the opportunity: 21 carries for 81 yards and a TD, plus three catches for 39 yards. Jadarian Price is on IR, so Wilson is a must-add in any league where managers were asleep at the wheel late in the week.

Joe Mixon, Seahawks: Mixon signed with Seattle. Worst case scenario? He is needed depth for a team dealing with multiple RB injuries. Best case? He can be this year's version of 2024 Kareem Hunt and provide some utility for managers desperate at the position. How much juice does Mixon have left? 

Kaleb Johnson, Packers: Johnson had eight carries for 42 yards. Chris Brooks is hurt, which could open the door for Johnson to see a larger workload in Week 5.

Austin Ekeler, Commanders: Rachaad White missed Week 4, and Ekeler showed some positives in his season debut with four carries for 29 yards and two targets. Jacory Croskey-Merritt has been struggling. Ekeler could overtake him.

Jaylen Wright, Dolphins: Wright was badly outproduced by Ollie Gordon. He should still be rostered while we wait to see where this backfield heads.

Najee Harris, Giants: Harris needs to be rostered in case his role grows. He has nine carries in back-to-back games. If Cam Skattebo were to miss time, Harris could immediately see 15+ touches per game.

Justice Hill, Ravens: Deep-league roster consideration.

Tyler Goodson, Cowboys: Deep-league roster consideration.

Seth McGowan, Colts: Deep-league roster consideration.

Will Shipley, Eagles: The Eagles offense is reeling and decimated, but Shipley could step into a valuable role if injuries continue to pile up. He is also a plus pass catcher, giving him another path to fantasy production. Shipley is one of this week's better Waiver Wire options in deeper high-stakes leagues and is still widely available.

Travis Homer, Steelers: Rico Dowdle is hurt, Jaylen Warren already has an extremely valuable — and higher-than-normal volume — role, but Homer now has a path to touches behind him. He is a deeper-league addition and a name high-stakes managers should have on their radar.

Samaje Perine, Bengals: The direct handcuff to Chase Brown, Perine is the kind of player who should be rostered before you need him, especially in deeper and high-stakes formats.

WIDE RECEIVERS

Malik Washington, Dolphins: Check and make sure he is not available. He had five catches for 67 yards and four carries the last two weeks. 11+ PPR points back to back games. 

Tyreek Hill, Free Agent / Cyrus Allen, Chiefs / Jalen Royals, Chiefs: Both Rashee Rice and Tyquan Thornton left Sunday's game with injuries. The latest on Rice is that he should be available after Kansas City's bye week, but there is still reason for pessimism. That has created a direct path for Allen — one of the buzz guys of the summer — and Royals to potentially play sizable roles. Or maybe it has created a reentry point for one of the best "stacks" in fantasy history.

A Tyreek Hill reunion would be WILD.

The Chiefs are 4-0. Andy Reid has had this scenario play out before and went back to a former Chief in Kareem Hunt. Could he do it again with Hill?

Allen is the top addition and will crack my top-10 overall, and Royals should be scooped up in WR-heavy formats. Hill is a an awesome speculative add.

Keon Coleman, Bills: Coleman is my top-rated addition at WR this week. He played very well in Sunday's loss and took on a larger role when DJ Moore was injured. He finished with six catches for 116 yards and a TD. He also had six catches in Week 2.

The statistics have been very promising. Coleman can be a near-impact fill-in starter if Moore misses time.

Adonai Mitchell, Jets: Add him if he was cut.

Tre' Harris, Chargers: One of my favorite adds this week. The Chargers have issues, and Ladd McConkey's foot injury is a new one, as he was already dealing with a rib injury. Harris is trending up after having three catches for 60 yards in Week 4 and a 6-76 line in Week 3.

Antonio Williams, Commanders: Has juice and a full-time snap share with Terry McLaurin missing Week 4. Williams had an 87-yard TD overturned, seven targets and a 70%+ route participation. 

Roman Wilson, Steelers: Wilson should be rostered in WR-heavy formats. Has had six targets in every single game (literally not an average) and has TD grabs in back-to-back games. 

Malachi Fields, Giants: Fields has a full-time role and posted a season-high 52 receiving yards in Week 4. He is a depth piece and a "let's see if the usage increases" type of add, but the rookie has talent.

Dohnte Meyers, Bengals: Meyers, a 26-year-old rookie who previously played in the CFL, should be added as a strong short-term contributor. Ja'Marr Chase left the game with a concussion, and Tee Higgins was also banged up. Myers finished with seven catches for 82 yards on nine targets.

He belongs on the deeper-league radar for the rest of the season because of his contingent upside and will be a streamer in multiple formats this week if Chase and/or Higgins are out. He should be prioritized if you need a player at WR for THIS WEEK. 

Troy Franklin, Broncos: Pat Bryant is hurt. Franklin had some very strong games last season and will have a more prominent role. 

Efton Chism, Patriots: DeMario Douglas isn't a thing, and Mack Hollins injured his calf. Chism could have a larger-than-normal role simply because of attrition. He also caught the game-winning TD against Buffalo. In deeper leagues, that is enough to make him an interesting add.

Darius Cooper, Eagles: Cooper caught two TDs without DeVonta Smith and led the Eagles with seven targets. He massively outperformed Dontayvion Wicks and Makai Lemon. Could this be nothing more than an outlier performance? Absolutely. Or it could be the start of a larger role.

The Eagles offense is in shambles, but seven targets and two TDs are impossible to ignore. Cooper needs to be added in deeper formats while we find out.

Konata Mumpfield, Rams: Next-man-up handcuff of sorts to both Puka Nacua, who has already missed time this season, and Davante Adams, who is old. Mumpfield is the type of player to roster before an opportunity opens up.

TIGHT ENDS

Mike Gesicki, Bengals: Gesicki is off to a strong start this season, averaging 11.1 PPG, and he could have a much larger role if Chase and/or Higgins miss time. We have seen Gesicki thrive in short-term roles in years past. He is one of the more interesting TE adds this week.

Michael Mayer, Raiders: Mayer's production has increased in games with Brock Bowers. He is a must-roster player in TE-premium leagues and can also be rostered in formats like the NFFC. Vegas is using multiple TEs at a high rate and Cousins is targeting them a lot. Raiders TEs combined for 22 targets this week. 

Pat Freiermuth and Darnell Washington, Steelers: Freiermuth is playing well and provides a solid PPR floor, especially during the bye weeks. Washington is a TE-premium add. His role continues to grow in what has become a pass-happy Steelers offense.

Tyler Higbee, Rams: Higbee is a must-add short-term option in TE-premium leagues where managers were asleep at the wheel. Terrance Ferguson is on IR, and Higbee has 13 catches on 17 targets over his last two games.

Chig Okonkwo, Commanders: Okonkwo returned this week in London. The early snap rate was promising, but the usage was minimal. He should become more involved as the season progresses.

Fantasy Pass
Want to Read More?
The Fantasy Pass unlocks this article and every other one.

Season-long rankings, start/sit calls, and waiver advice from the analysts who wrote this piece. Subscribers can also talk it through with the author in the comments.

Season-long rankings, start/sit calls, and waiver advice from the analysts who wrote this piece.