Week 5 Fantasy Football WR Ranks & Tiers: Happy George Pickens BOOM Week

Ian Hartitz analyzes wide receiver matchups with rankings and tiers for Week 5. This is the week for George Pickens. A boom game awaits.
Week 5 Fantasy Football WR Ranks & Tiers: Happy George Pickens BOOM Week

The Saints have multiple top-16 fantasy receivers, something named Dohnte Meyers is getting legit steam and Deebo Samuel is partying like it's 2023 again. Football! Yeah!

I'll break down my weekly WR rankings and tiers each and every week *with* some bigger-picture questions sprinkled in along the way. This week's additional topics feature:

  • Who have been the best real-life receivers this season on a per-route basis?
  • Who have been the position's best surprises this season?
  • Which defenses look like pass funnel units through four weeks?
  • Which wide receivers have the best and worst upcoming schedules?
  • Who have been the best and worst defenses against WRs this season?

As always: It's a great day to be great.

Tier 1: The Big Nine

  • WR1: Jaxon Smith-Njigba (vs. SF). Scored more fantasy points than any human being on the planet this season. Last year JSN went 9-124-0, 6-84-0 and 3-19-1 against the 49ers – don't be surprised if we get his biggest boom yet against the Seahawks' NFC West rival.
  • WR2: Puka Nacua (vs. BUF on MNF). Returned with a 9-125-0 receiving line (plus a two-yard TD run) on 12 targets. Pretty, pretty, pretty good! The potential problem: Puka is dealing with a lower-body "pre-hernia" condition that I just found out existed in the last four days. Don't love that! Maybe it all works out fine, but it's not ideal, you know? Treat Puka as the elite WR1 he's been his entire career for however long this potential hernia doesn't

The Saints have multiple top-16 fantasy receivers, something named Dohnte Meyers is getting legit steam and Deebo Samuel is partying like it's 2023 again. Football! Yeah!

I'll break down my weekly WR rankings and tiers each and every week *with* some bigger-picture questions sprinkled in along the way. This week's additional topics feature:

  • Who have been the best real-life receivers this season on a per-route basis?
  • Who have been the position's best surprises this season?
  • Which defenses look like pass funnel units through four weeks?
  • Which wide receivers have the best and worst upcoming schedules?
  • Who have been the best and worst defenses against WRs this season?

As always: It's a great day to be great.

Tier 1: The Big Nine

  • WR1: Jaxon Smith-Njigba (vs. SF). Scored more fantasy points than any human being on the planet this season. Last year JSN went 9-124-0, 6-84-0 and 3-19-1 against the 49ers – don't be surprised if we get his biggest boom yet against the Seahawks' NFC West rival.
  • WR2: Puka Nacua (vs. BUF on MNF). Returned with a 9-125-0 receiving line (plus a two-yard TD run) on 12 targets. Pretty, pretty, pretty good! The potential problem: Puka is dealing with a lower-body "pre-hernia" condition that I just found out existed in the last four days. Don't love that! Maybe it all works out fine, but it's not ideal, you know? Treat Puka as the elite WR1 he's been his entire career for however long this potential hernia doesn't actually become a real hernia.
  • WR3: CeeDee Lamb (vs. TB on TNF). Started the season on FIRE with 5-44-1, 8-143-2, 7-112-0 and most recently 17-189-1 receiving lines. The man is on pace for 2,078 receiving yards! Up next is a Buccaneers defense that has yet to allow 250 passing yards in a game this season, but we are talking about a Cowboys offense that ranks fifth in points per drive through four weeks dating back to 2000 (h/t Anthony Dabbundo).
  • WR4: Amon-Ra St. Brown (at ARI). Tied with CeeDee Lamb and Trey McBride for the second most targets in the NFL at 46. Wheels up ahead of this potential shootout — Cardinals-Lions' 54.5 game total is tied for the highest in Week 5 — against an Arizona defense that somehow is even worse than the Lions when it comes to EPA allowed per dropback.
  • WR5: Nico Collins (at TEN). Has posted 7-75-1 and 7-118-2 receiving lines in his only two games this season. Don't let the record fool you: C.J. Stroud is BALLING, and there should continue to be plenty of volume here as long as this run game continues to, you know, suck. Don't be surprised if Collins joins DeVonta Smith (27.7) and Zay Flowers (25.8) with another 25-plus PPR-point performance against this Titans secondary.
  • WR6: Tee Higgins (at MIA). Dealing with an adductor injury. Do NOT say groin. It's an adductor injury. Not groin. Adductor. Anyways, we're assuming Ja'Marr Chase (concussion) is sidelined this week, setting up Higgins for double-digit targets against this bottom-5 pass defense in EPA allowed per dropback. Higgins has gone 3-49-1, 7-60-0, 9-148-0, 7-114-1 and 5-140-1 in five full games with Chase sidelined since 2022.
  • WR7: Chris Olave (vs. MIN). Hasn't missed this season: Olave has posted 10-182-0, 8-86-1, 9-107-0 and 8-116-0 receiving lines through four weeks, earning double-digit targets in every game along the way. Hell, that streak even continues two games into 2025. Trey McBride (4x) is the only man even close to that active six-game streak! This week's matchup isn't ideal against the blitz-happy Vikings, though we did see Christian Watson (6-147-2) and Matthew Golden (6-95-0) put forward nice performances against Brian Flores and company during their stiffest test in Week 1. I'm not moving Olave out of the top 10 — even if there's a fire — but do keep an eye on his practice participation after he seemingly suffered a lower-body injury at the end of Week 4.
  • WR8: Drake London (vs. BAL on SNF). Last week's 5-96-0 performance snapped a five-game streak of racking up triple-digit yards with Michael Penix under center. C'mon, Drake! In reality, the only reason why London hasn't posted even bigger numbers in recent weeks is because the Falcons have beaten their opponents down badly enough to essentially run out the clock in the fourth quarter. While that could again come to fruition against the Lamar Jackson-less Ravens on Sunday Night Football, there's still no reason to treat London as anything other than the upside WR1 he's been with Penix at QB.
  • WR9: Zay Flowers (at ATL on SNF). Nobody has averaged more yards per route run (6.29) during the first four weeks of a season over the last decade. Only 2025 Puka Nacua has averaged more targets per route run (39.3%). We are talking SPECIAL company here. While the expected absence of Lamar Jackson (ankle) is far from ideal, Declan Doyle has made Flowers THE engine of this passing game — I don't plan on taking him out of any starting lineups until we see any sort of evidence that suggests Flowers isn't playing like one of the best receivers on the planet.

Key question: Who have been the best real-life receivers this season on a per-route basis?

The below chart denotes the top receivers in yards and targets per route run this season (min. 50 routes):

Flowers continues to absolutely crush it, while additional kudos are deserved to Jaxon Smith-Njigba and Drake London, who still finds himself third in yards per route run despite spending his first two games with Cooper freaking Rush.

Some surprisingly not-so-good ranks in yards per route run to start the season: Amon-Ra St. Brown (WR40), Ja'Marr Chase (WR42), Michael Wilson (WR47), Jaylen Waddle (WR48), George Pickens (WR51) and Jameson Williams (WR58). Of course, the volume part of the equation has been just fine for the former three receivers, while it seems like a matter of when, not if, the latter three start racking up some big plays.

Tier 2: Week-Winning Upside

  • WR10: Malik Nabers (at WSH). Nabers' breakout 6-112-1 Week 4 included a ridiculous contested catch that proved Jameis Winston is still down to say, "F it, Malik down there somewhere." Of course, that great catch did also feature Nabers (again) bang up his shoulder. This week's matchup is salivating against a Commanders defense that is one of just five groups allowing 40-plus PPR points per game to wide receivers, but I wouldn't be against selling high on Nabers for the right price given the potential for, 1) his shoulder, and/or, 2) J.J. McCarthy, to eventually mess things up. 
  • WR11: Justin Jefferson (at NO). Treat Jettas as his usual WR1 self if healthy enough to suit up, though maybe the Vikings take things easy and rest their superstar wide receiver with a Week 6 bye on the horizon. Jefferson is only ranked this low because of concerns under center. While Kyler Murray got better as last week got on … it was against the Dolphins … and we are talking about someone who ranks *checks notes* dead-ass last in adjusted net yards per attempt this season. 
  • WR12: Michael Wilson (vs. DET). Has posted 11-89-1 and 7-95-0 receiving lines on a combined 30 targets (!) the last two weeks. Up next is a Lions secondary that has allowed monster performances to Tetairoa McMillan (45.2 PPR points), Chris Olave (28.2), Garrett Wilson (26.7) and Devaughn Vele (19.9) through four weeks. Nobody has allowed more passing yards (1,216) this season. That's the worst mark of any defense over the last half-decade!
  • WR13: Davante Adams (vs. BUF on MNF). Fell back to earth in Week 4, though Adams dropped a TD in the back of the end zone and was (again) overthrown on what could have been a chunk gain deep after breaking free on a double-move. It'd be surprising if Adams has another down game ahead of this Monday Night Shootout: The Bills-Rams' 54.5 game total is tied for the highest of the season!
  • WR14: George Pickens (vs. TB on TNF). This is the week. The boom game is happening THIS week. Not next week, THIS week. Recent trades on Yahoo have featured Pickens getting acquired straight-up for Ladd McConkey, Jaylen Waddle, Cam Skattebo, Saquon Barkley and Ashton Jeanty. I'm in. The Cowboys have been everything we hoped for as an offensive juggernaut, while their defense continues to push them into four-quarter shootouts. Get this 25-year-old talent on your roster before he hangs 100-plus yards and two touchdowns on this Buccaneers secondary Thursday night.
  • WR15: Garrett Wilson (vs. CLE). Went from 10-107-1 in Week 3 to 3-27-0 in Week 4. That'll happen when your offense only manages to run 32 freaking plays the entire game! The only concern in Week 4 is the presence of Denzel Ward, though, per Fantasy Points, we didn't see the Browns go out of their way to have Ward shadow Tetairoa McMillan (48.9%), Emeka Egbuka (36.4%), DK Metcalf (25%) or Parker Washington (20%). Wilson remains a great real-life talent who continues to project for double-digit targets in normal game scripts as long as Adonai Mitchell (finger) remains sidelined. That's good enough for upside WR2 treatment.
  • WR16: Parker Washington (vs. PHI in London). Streak of big-time games finally ended in Week 4, but even then Washington's 1-7-0 dud featured a (tough) dropped 36-yard TD and another chunk gain that was taken off the board after Washington barely stepped out of bounds. Chop wood, wear white cleats, Parker! Anyway, Washington remains Trevor Lawrence's No. 1 pass-game option and now gets a Philly defense that has allowed the second-most PPR points per game to slot wide receivers this season. Don't be surprised if this Sunday morning we spell redemption: P-a-r-k-e-r.
  • WR17: Christian Watson (vs. CHI). Both Watson (WR5) and Golden (WR12) have worked as WR1s this season. Hell yeah! These ranks accordingly feel low, but the Packers' brutal offensive line (RotoWire's 32nd-ranked group at the moment) and Ben Johnson's willingness to play bully-ball/keepaway has me concerned about the overall play volume that will be afforded here. To be clear: I fully plan on starting Watson and Golden on every fantasy team that I am lucky enough to have them on, but there are enough (fellow) talented pass-catchers in better situations for me to rank both as more of upside WR2 types in this spot — we'll try to squeeze both inside the top 12 for next week's Sunday night matchup against the Cowboys.
  • WR18: Matthew Golden (vs. CHI).

Key question: Who have been the position's best surprises this season?

In terms of total PPR points through four weeks …

  • Packers WR Christian Watson (WR5) and Matthew Golden (WR12) have posted legit WR1 production after being drafted with Yahoo ADPs of WR27 and WR55, respectively.
  • Unc still got it! Deebo Samuel stands as the WR13 after four weeks. The longtime beastly breaker of tackles looks lean and mean out on the gridiron; Samuel has been an underrated key piece of this devastatingly awesome 49ers offense.
  • Michael Wilson (WR15) has very much proved that his second half boom in 2025 was far from a fluke.
  • Devaughn Vele! WR16!
  • The first-round rookie receivers might be a little slow to get started, but nobody said anything about Round 3 rooks! Shoutout Denzel Boston (WR17) on his hot start.
  • Jalen Coker (WR19) moves all the way up to WR12 if you look at things on a per-game level.
  • Kalif Raymond is somehow the WR23 despite last week's dud.

Tier 3: You Should Probably Start Them

  • WR19: Mike Evans (at SEA). Only the Chiefs have allowed fewer fantasy points to WRs than the Seahawks this season. Mike Macdonald has generally brought out the worst in opposing passing games, and Brock Purdy hasn't exactly been a massive exception over the years. Now, Evans continues to look good despite playing through a painful rib injury — he was a better ball and three feet away from having two touchdowns against Patrick Surtain and the Broncos last week — but it's a difficult enough matchup for me to drop him into this tier of No. 1 WRs with at least one concern.
  • WR20: DJ Moore (at LAR on MNF). Similar to Nabers: I sure don't love the fact that this shoulder injury continues to pop up! Not similar to Nabers: We're still looking at an offense led by Josh Allen. Moore's volume has been awesome … when he's managed to stay on the field. This week's matchup against the Rams isn't ideal — they haven't allowed a wide receiver to gain more than 50 yards in a game this season! — but it is only Week 5, and there's so much scoring upside in this likely Monday night shootout.
  • WR21: Jaylen Waddle (at LAC). Three games with 35 or fewer yards certainly wasn't what alleged fantasy experts such as myself had in mind for Waddle when we dubbed him as a breakout candidate this season. That said, this Broncos passing game has nowhere to go but up, and the targets are even more consolidated around the ex-Dolphin with Pat Bryant (ankle) expected to miss a few weeks. This has been a tough schedule, and will continue to be against the Chargers this week and Seahawks next, but we do see things start to open up a bit afterward as the offense *hopefully* gets back on track (and maybe has a new play-caller). I wouldn't say I'm rushing to trade for Waddle in the same manner as George Pickens, but I do like his side of recent one-for-one trades featuring Emeka Egbuka, RJ Harvey and Deebo Samuel.
  • WR22: Luther Burden III (at GB). Has gained north of 60 yards in three of four games this season and stands as the WR25 in total PPR points. Not bad, not amazing, but Burden has looked good with the football in his hands (tied for the position lead in total tackles avoided this season), and perhaps Sunday will be the boom fantasy managers have been hoping for against a Packers defense that has been pretty rough against the pass (24th in EPA per dropback) through four weeks. One last non-stat-based note: Burden really seems to hate the Packers, and I'm here for it! Get your popcorn ready for Sunday!
  • WR23: DK Metcalf (vs. IND). As we discussed last week, Metcalf is a boom-or-bust WR3 who did more busting than booming to start the year, so it's natural to expect some better days ahead — especially with Aaron Rodgers and this passing game coming to life a bit recently. Also like last week, we probably shouldn't overrate the presence of his tough on-paper cornerback matchup. Overall, Sauce Gardner has played 202 snaps as the defense's right outside cornerback this season, and *one* on the left side. The Steelers should be able to get whatever matchup they want, and hey, maybe they don't care after watching Treylon Burks and Dyami Brown give Gardner the business last week. In fact, I'm referring to him as Ahmad Gardner until we get an interception. The man has *one* interception over the last four seasons combined!
  • WR24: Jameson Williams (at ARI). It was nice to see Jamo hang 102 yards on the Panthers last Sunday night, but the performance was nearly even bigger considering Williams alligator-armed a potential 89-yard touchdown down the sideline. Still, we're looking at someone actively getting fantasy-friendly downfield shot plays designed for him inside anyone's idea of a top-5 passing attack in the NFL looking at one of the week's better matchups and overall game environments. One of nine players with 25-plus targets and *zero* receiving touchdowns, even if Williams is more of a boom-or-bust WR3 than locked-in WR1 this season — this is the spot to expect more good than bad. 
  • WR25: Stefon Diggs (vs. NYG). And I wouldn't blame you for wanting to rank Diggs higher with Terry McLaurin (hamstring) presumably out of the picture! Diggs has commanded nine, six, seven and most recently nine targets in his first four games in Washington, returning solid PPR WR18 production along the way. The Commanders find themselves as a sneaky-solid fantasy environment due to their: 1) Inability to run the football, and 2) Inability to slow down non-Daniel Jones-led passing attacks. 
  • WR26: Romeo Doubs (vs. LV). I didn't think it would take injuries to A.J. Brown *and* Mack Hollins before we could feel good enough about Doubs to treat him as a borderline WR2, but hey, we made it! The ex-Packers' nine targets in Week 4 were just two fewer than he had in Weeks 1-3 combined; Doubs is suddenly the only show in town inside a Drake Maye-led passing attack that proved capable of not sucking in Week 4. Up next is a Maxx Crosby-led Raiders defense that has looked FAR more human in Weeks 3-4 against the Saints and Chiefs (15th in EPA allowed per dropback) than they did in Weeks 1-2 against the Dolphins and Chargers (1st!).

Key question: Which defenses look like pass funnel units through four weeks?

The below chart shows every defense's performance in EPA allowed per dropback and per rush this season:

Teams like the Cowboys, Lions, Bills and Saints have largely been rough in all facets of defense this season, but the Cardinals, Dolphins, Titans, Texans (!), Jets and Commanders stand out as the groups who have been solid enough against the run BUT rank 21st or worst in EPA allowed per dropback.

These pass funnel groups are exactly what we want to look for when making tough start/sit decisions at the position. Obviously you feel good about all Lions (vs. ARZ) this week, but guys like Dohnte Meyers (vs. MIA), Denzel Boston and KC Concepcion (vs. NYJ), Stefon Diggs and Antonio Williams (vs. NYJ) and maybe even Jaylin Noel (vs. TEN) deserve some underappreciated love in their respective Week 5 matchups.

Tier 4: WR3s with Upside

  • WR27: Denzel Boston (at NYJ). Has 57 percent of Boston's receiving yards come on three plays this season? Yes. Is every player bad if you decide to not consider all of their good plays? Also yes. Additionally, Boston's 46- and 55-yard receptions in Weeks 1 and 2 were thanks to the rookie being a stone-cold baller; only his 60-yard catch in Week 4 was more of a busted coverage moment. Ultimately, Boston is in AWESOME company when looking at who has gained the most receiving yards in their first four career games in last decade, Deshaun Watson is somehow playing something close to good football again and the Jets are not a matchup to be afraid of. That's good enough for upside WR3 treatment for me!
  • WR28: Devaughn Vele (vs. MIN). The WR16 in PPR points this season! I'm not lying! And that doesn't seem too fluky considering Vele's 31 targets are tied for the 13th most at the position. Now, the 28-year-old, third-year talent (lol) isn't exactly a big-play machine nor someone we should expect to keep on keeping on if/when No. 8 overall pick Jordyn Tyson is back in the picture, but this pass-happy Saints offense is currently doing enough to keep Vele and TE Juwan Johnson as very fantasy-relevant pieces alongside Chris Olave. I'd have Vele ranked even higher if it wasn't for this week's brutal matchup against Brian Flores and the Vikings' league-best scoring defense.
  • WR29: Deebo Samuel Sr. (at SEA). Deebo looks good, man! He's averaging his most yards per reception (13.2) since 2023 alongside a whopping 10.6 yards per rush — Samuel's most since his rookie season! The veteran has been a handful to get to the ground along the way: He leads the league in yards after contact and tackles avoided per carry! "Small sample size? What's he have, seven rushes?" Whatever, NERD. Moral of the story: Deebo looks good and the 49ers offense looks great: That's more than enough to warrant top-30 treatment with room to grow if we get more consistent volume.
  • WR30: Malik Washington (vs. CIN). Has 15 targets and four rush attempts the last two weeks with De'Von Achane out of the picture. Is it incredibly sad that the 2026 Dolphins are running their offense through Malik Washington? Yes, but hey, those short receptions add up in a hurry in full-PPR land! Washington also deserves credit for making some fun plays after the catch: He's tied with Luther Burden for the position lead in tackles avoided this season. WR1-worthy boom weeks are unlikely, but Washington could fool around and finish as a volume-based WR3 when this season is all said and done.
  • WR31: Carnell Tate (vs. HOU). Turned 12 targets into a breakout 9-145-0 receiving line in Week 4. The only 21-year-old wide receivers with more in a game since 2020: Ja'Marr Chase, Justin Jefferson and Malik Nabers. Decent company if you ask me! While this week's matchup with the Texans could be tough if Tate gets shadow treatment from Derek Stingley, the stud corner hasn't consistently traveled with No. 1 WRs this season and has spent 79 percent of his snaps as the defense's outside left cornerback. Tennessee should be able to let Tate feast on Kamari Lassiter if it desires — he's allowed the fourth most receptions (21) and sixth most yards (244) among defensive players this season. 
  • WR32: Ladd McConkey (vs. DEN). Exited after just 24 snaps while trying to play through a foot injury in Week 4. And now the Chargers could be without both of their starting tackles. And Justin Herbert has been downright bad all season. McConkey is a certifiably #good receiver who has been pretty much the lone bright spot in this offense all season, but any sort of uncertainty surrounding his game status and health will make it difficult to start him with any level of confidence against a Broncos secondary that has limited him to 4-43-0, 6-87-0 and 4-41-0 receiving lines over the years. Note that the Chargers play the Broncos in the late afternoon slate this week.
  • WR33: Josh Downs (at PIT). Downs turning in a season-low effort in usage and production in an island game without Alec Pierce (foot, IR) or Keenan Allen (groin) is what fantasy football is all about. While I don't doubt Downs' standing as a very good real life receiver, it is becoming increasingly clear that Daniel Jones is a shell of his best self in the year 2026. The ex-Giant has never been worse in terms of QBR (37.4) and yards per attempt (5.7) through four weeks. This, combined with Ashton Dulin and Laquon Treadwell unironically being the team's deep threats, has made it easy for defenses to zero in on Downs and Tyler Warren in the underneath areas of the field. This doesn't exactly profile as a great get right spot: Pittsburgh has allowed the sixth-fewest PPR points per game to slot receivers this season.
  • WR34: Tre Tucker (at NE). Had a case of the butterfingers last week, but still has posted solid enough 5-119-1, 4-43-0 and 4-44-0 receiving lines across his last three games. Expecting more of the former outcomes while Brock Bowers is alive and well is probably wishful thinking, but then again, Kirk Cousins is suddenly playing awesome football again, so maybe his No. 1 WR can at least provide upside WR3 numbers? Note that I'm way more willing to buy into that idea if ace Patriots CB Christian Gonzalez (shoulder) remains sidelined. Additional note: Jalen Nailor (concussion) is tentatively expected to join Jack Bech (forearm, IR) on the sideline this week.
  • WR35: Jakobi Meyers (vs. PHI in London). Meyers being the PPR WR36 this season is the most Jakobi Meyers thing ever. Bigger days could be ahead if anyone out there ever forces the Jaguars into a back-and-forth shootout, but for now it's tough to get too optimistic about the ceiling here with fewer than five targets in all but one game this season. That said, if you see Trevor Lawrence make an awesome throw into tight coverage over the middle, there's a good chance Meyers will be on the receiving end.
  • WR36: Rome Odunze (at GB). Turned in season highs across the board in his 6-94-0 effort in Week 4. Maybe Odunze and T-Bag simply have a great connection? The problem with expecting too much consistency here is the reality that the Bears continue to use Odunze as their primary downfield threat. Overall, 54 wide receivers have run 100 routes, and only six have an average route depth of more than 11 yards: Jameson Williams, Rashod Bateman, Marvin Harrison Jr., Rome Odunze, Courtland Sutton and Kayshon Boutte. Sensing an archetype here? That said: Credit to Odunze for posting the fourth-most average separation yards among WR. Up next is a Packers defense that Odunze has averaged 42-scoreless yards against in three career meetings.
  • WR37: Courtland Sutton (at LAC). The absence of Pat Bryant (ankle) gets this passing game back to the Jaylen Waddle and Courtland Sutton show … but are we positive Sutton isn't, you know, REALLY washed at this point? Career lows in … literally everything … is one thing, but the film looks rough, and only Marvin Harrison Jr., Makai Lemon and Bryce Lance have averaged fewer yards per route run.

Key question: Which wide receivers have the best and worst upcoming schedules?

The below chart denotes every team's Weeks 5-10 matchups in terms of their opponent's PPR points per game allowed to opposing WRs. Blue signifies an easy on-paper matchup, while red is tough:

The easiest matchups go to: The Giants (please stay healthy, Malik Nabers), Jaguars (chop wood, carry water), Rams (please stay healthy, Puka Nacua), Ravens (please get healthy, Lamar Jackson), Vikings (please get good again, Kyler Murray) and Titans (keep it rolling, Carnell Tate!).

The toughest on-paper matchups go to the Falcons, Seahawks, Patriots, Broncos, Chiefs and Panthers. Fortunately, most of these situations feature clear-cut No. 1 volume-hogs who will continue to be ranked highly regardless of the tough assignment. Remember: Tough perceived matchups are more of a tiebreaker for close start/sit decisions than something to revolve your entire strategy around.

Tier 5: We're Saying there's a Chance

  • WR38: Jordan Addison (at NO). Would get into the top-30 conversation if Justin Jefferson is again sidelined, but it was disappointing to see just six targets last week without the team's No. 1 WR. Similar to Jefferson: My lukewarm ranking is far more due to Kyler Murray looking like one of the league's worst passers to anyone not named T.J. Hockenson than any sort of indictment to the talent level of these receivers.
  • WR39: Dohnte Meyers (at MIA). Caught 7 of 9 targets for 82 yards against the Jaguars in Week 4 … and looked really good? The 26-year-old former undrafted talent is suddenly looking at a full-time role with Ja'Marr Chase (concussion) presumably sidelined. I could see myself going as high as WR30 if Tee Higgins (adductor) is also out! The Bengals have a Week 6 bye, so don't expect this to last too long, but hey.
  • WR40: KC Concepcion Jr. (at NYJ). Only Carnell Tate (32) has more targets than KC (28) without a receiving touchdown. The rookies are due, damnit! Good news: Concepcion has racked up 17 targets in the last two weeks inside a Browns passing game that inexplicably isn't that bad. I'm still holding the talented first-round pick on my bench in fantasy leagues of most shapes and sizes.
  • WR41: Keon Coleman (at LAR on MNF). Trails only Zay Flowers and Drake London in yards per target this season if you get wonky with the target threshold. But hey, 16 isn't even that weird! I would move Coleman up inside the top 30 if DJ Moore (shoulder) is unavailable for Monday night's potential shootout against the Rams. Credit to the much-maligned 23-year-old talent for largely doing nothing other than keeping his head down and making plays this season. He played a season-high 78 percent of the offense's snaps last week and looks to have won out over Joshua Palmer for No. 3 WR duties. Shakir's ranking wouldn't move as much; he's his usual PPR-friendly WR4 self ahead of Monday night.
  • WR42: Khalil Shakir (at LAR on MNF).
  • WR43: Wan'Dale Robinson (vs. HOU). Scored in back-to-back weeks, and Cam Ward didn't look THAT bad in Week 4. Progress for the $70 million receiver! This passing game certainly flows through Carnell Tate first and foremost, but Wan'Dale is deserving of WR4 treatment in full-PPR formats.
  • WR44: Emeka Egbuka (at DAL on TNF). Scored 12 PPR points in a game *once* in his last 16 games. Last week Egbuka barely got to 12 yards. That said: The matchup is winnable, and Jalon Daniels didn't look completely lost in his first career start.
  • WR45: DeMario Douglas (vs. LV). Looks poised to see something close to a full-time role with Mack Hollins (calf) joining A.J. Brown (ankle) on the sideline. The artist known as Pop has always been a threat in the open field, and now he could be Drake Maye's No. 2 target behind only Romeo Doubs. Add it all together, and you get a low-end WR4.

Key question: Who have been the best and worst defenses against WRs this season?

Let's find out!

The Cowboys, Commanders and Lions stand out as the biggest defenses to target. I'm still not completely sold on Houston suddenly sucking — it's played the Bills, Bengals, Cowboys (and Colts) to start the season. That said: Derek Stingley isn't traveling with No. 1 WRs, so it's certainly not a matchup we need to overly shy away from.

Similar "start em if you got em" mindsets can be applied to matchups against the Cardinals, Bills, Falcons and even the Browns considering Denzel Ward hasn't made a habit of traveling with No. 1's as well. DK Metcalf and Roman Wilson nearly combined for 200 yards last Thursday night, after all!

Elsewhere, the Chiefs, Seahawks, Raiders, 49ers and even the Dolphins have been the toughest tests, although Miami's inclusion feels like more so a case of game script to me.

Tier 6: The Other Guys

  • WR46: Marvin Harrison Jr. (vs. DET). Scored a TD last week, got another end zone target on a contested slant and dropped a would-be second TD that he also drew a DPI on. Progress! The matchup lifts Marv into the boom-or-bust WR4 conversation.
  • WR47: Rashid Shaheed (vs. SF). Electric 28-yard rushing TD last week featured Shaheed lined up as a true RB. Maybe more is to come with this Seahawks backfield remaining so banged up? Similar to Marv, I'm mostly just elevating Shaheed thanks to the potential shootout game script here.
  • WR48: Kalif Raymond (at GB). Came crashing back to earth right as managers finally worked up the courage to start him. That's fantasy football in a nutshell right there!
  • WR49: Chris Godwin (at DAL on TNF). That matchup.
  • WR50: Jaylin Noel (at TEN). Leads the league in yards per reception (23.3) and is averaging a HEALTHY 15.5 yards per target. That only trails Zay Flowers! Let's throw the football to Noel more often and see what happens.
  • WR51: Keenan Allen (at PIT). Pending recovery from his groin injury (not an adductor injury).
  • WR52: Roman Wilson (vs. IND). 3-60-1 and 3-74-1 performances the last two weeks! People are saying Wilson might be the best NFL player from that Michigan national championship team! (Editor's note: Nobody is saying that).
  • WR53: Antonio Williams (vs. NYG). Set season highs in targets (8) and snaps (69%). The rookie has a LONG TD called back by an illegal shift and (iffy) holding penalty; Williams continues to flash with his opportunities and is looking at more of them with Terry McLaurin (hamstring) potentially sidelined this week.
  • WR54: Michael Pittman Jr. (vs. IND). Revenge game!
  • WR55: Dontayvion Wicks (at JAX in London). Just 50 combined yards across the last two weeks in this broken offense.
  • WR56: Tre' Harris (vs. DEN). 53, 76 and 60 yards in his last three games.
  • WR57: Darius Cooper (at JAX in London). Has snatched Isaac TeSlaa's chain as the league leader in most fun per reception.
  • WR58: Makai Lemon (at JAX in London). Yet to reach 30 yards in a game or find the end zone inside this broken offense.
  • WR59: Malachi Fields (at WSH). Sometimes Jameis might get confused and mistake Fields for Malik Nabers.
  • WR60: Ryan Flournoy (vs. TB on TNF). Remains one of the best handcuff receivers in football.

Fantasy Pass
Want to Read More?
The Fantasy Pass unlocks this article and every other one.

Season-long rankings, start/sit calls, and waiver advice from the analysts who wrote this piece. Subscribers can also talk it through with the author in the comments.

Season-long rankings, start/sit calls, and waiver advice from the analysts who wrote this piece.