FPL Gameweek 5 Rankings: Best Players & Captain Picks

FPL GW5 rankings with the best players and captain picks for Gameweek 5, based on projected points, expected minutes, fixtures and predicted lineups.
FPL Gameweek 5 Rankings: Best Players & Captain Picks
RotoWire
Win your week.
Every start/sit, every waiver, every trade, plus NBA and NHL all winter. We make the call.
Every start/sit, every waiver, every trade. We make the call.

FPL Gameweek 5 Rankings: Best Players & Captain Picks

Manchester City have the standout fixture of FPL Gameweek 5, hosting Sunderland as the biggest favorite on the slate with the strongest clean-sheet and scoring outlook. Newcastle also have an appealing home matchup against Hull City, while Nottingham Forest host Coventry and Everton face Ipswich.

Those fixtures should shape the top of this week's FPL rankings, particularly for captaincy and defensive targets. Arsenal remain firmly in the conversation away to Brighton, but Manchester City, Newcastle and Nottingham Forest have the most favorable setups on paper.

These are my FPL GW5 rankings, best players and captain picks based on projected points, expected minutes, predicted lineups, fixture difficulty, role and price. Use the rankings below to compare transfer targets, starting decisions and captain options across every position.

Set your squad before the Gameweek 5 deadline on Friday, Sept. 18.

Make sure to join the RotoWire FPL league.

FPL Gameweek 5 Fixtures (ET)

For detailed stats and odds, check out the

FPL GW5 Cheat Sheet: Lineups, Odds and Stats

FPL GW5 Captain Picks

Captaincy should start with Manchester City this week given the home matchup against Sunderland, but there are viable alternatives if you want to move away from the most obvious option.

Erling Haaland (Man City, vs Sunderland): The fixture puts Haaland immediately at the top of the captaincy conversation. City have the strongest scoring outlook of the week, and Haaland remains the most direct way to attack it.

Yoane Wissa (Newcastle, vs Hull City): Newcastle are in one of the better home spots of the slate and should generate plenty of attacking opportunities. Wissa is the most obvious forward to target, while Harvey Barnes offers another differential route into the matchup.

Bukayo Saka (Arsenal, at Brighton): Saka has already produced 30 FPL points through four matches despite plenty of attention going toward Arsenal's defence. Brighton remain short-handed, so Arsenal's attackers still carry plenty of upside despite playing away from home.

FPL GW5 Best Players by Position

A quick read on who to build around before the full rankings.

  • Forwards: Haaland is the obvious starting point because of the Sunderland matchup. Wissa has gained appeal with Newcastle's favorable run, while Thierno Barry and Liam Delap also have matchups that put them firmly in the conversation.
  • Midfielders: The biggest concern with Manchester City players outside of Haaland is minutes security. With Phil Foden suspended, Antoine Semenyo, Rayan Cherki and Iliman Ndiaye could benefit. Martin Odegaard and Saka remain strong options for Arsenal's trip to Brighton.
  • Defenders: City defenders have the best combination of win probability and clean-sheet potential, keeping Josko Gvardiol and Marc Guehi near the top of the pool. Arsenal's back line remains appealing despite the trip to Brighton, while Ezri Konsa continues to draw interest as his ownership rises.
  • Goalkeepers: Manchester City lead the clean-sheet outlook, while Newcastle, Arsenal, Forest and Everton offer several alternatives depending on price and expected saves.

FPL GW5 Rankings

Full Gameweek 5 rankings below, based on projected lineups, expected minutes, recent roles, fixtures and price. Sort by position, price, ownership or projected points to compare transfer targets, captain options and starting decisions.

For the full projected XI picture, see our FPL Gameweek 5 Predicted Lineups.

Overall RankFW RankMID RankDEF RankGK RankPlayerTeamMatchupPosPriceTSB%Pts
11   Erling HaalandMCIMCI v. SUNF15.673.27.02
2 1  Morgan Gibbs-WhiteNFONFO v. COVM8.015.76.31
3 2  Bruno FernandesMUNMUN at FULM12.040.36.05
4 3  Harvey BarnesNEWNEW v. HULM6.04.15.88
5 4  Rayan CherkiMCIMCI v. SUNM7.828.05.79
6 5  Dominik SzoboszlaiLIVLIV at BOUM7.034.65.75
7 6  Antoine SemenyoMCIMCI v. SUNM8.414.95.66
82   Dominic Calvert-LewinLEELEE v. CRYF6.025.45.63
9 7  Cole PalmerCHECHE at BREM9.726.95.59
10 8  Bukayo SakaARSARS at BHAM9.513.15.55
113   Liam DelapNFONFO v. COVF5.52.65.54
12 9  Mohamed BelloumiHULHUL at NEWM5.14.25.52
134   Kai HavertzARSARS at BHAF7.68.35.52
14  1 Neco WilliamsNFONFO v. COVD5.09.35.47
155   Yoane WissaNEWNEW v. HULF6.218.85.47
16 10  Elliot AndersonMCIMCI v. SUNM6.34.25.47
176   Thierno BarryEVEEVE v. IPSF5.67.65.46
18 11  Anton StachLEELEE v. CRYM6.02.75.39
197   Alexander IsakLIVLIV at BOUF9.121.85.32
20  2 Marc GuehiMCIMCI v. SUND6.018.55.29
21 12  James GarnerEVEEVE v. IPSM6.00.25.28
228   Igor ThiagoBREBRE v. CHEF7.89.05.26
23 13  Iliman NdiayeMCIMCI v. SUNM5.97.45.17
24  3 Josko GvardiolMCIMCI v. SUND5.725.65.15
259   Danny WelbeckCHECHE at BREF5.90.95.11
26 14  Vitaly JaneltBREBRE v. CHEM5.02.55.09
27 15  Kiernan Dewsbury-HallEVEEVE v. IPSM6.56.25.09
28 16  Marcus TavernierBOUBOU v. LIVM6.16.35.07
29  4 MurilloNFONFO v. COVD5.52.25.06
30  5 Tarik MuharemovicLEELEE v. CRYD5.04.45.06
3110   Gonzalo GarciaFULFUL v. MUNF6.03.65.05
3211   Oliver McBurnieHULHUL at NEWF5.52.05.04
33 17  Bruno GuimaraesARSARS at BHAM6.71.85.03
34 18  Morgan RogersCHECHE at BREM7.739.55.02
35  6 Matheus NunesMCIMCI v. SUND5.91.05.00
36  7 Sven BotmanNEWNEW v. HULD5.00.75.00
37  8 James TarkowskiEVEEVE v. IPSD6.114.44.98
38 19  Alex ScottBOUBOU v. LIVM6.15.84.95
39 20  Declan RiceARSARS at BHAM7.412.44.95
40  9 Daniel MunozNFONFO v. COVD5.46.14.94
41  10 GabrielARSARS at BHAD8.023.14.93
42 21  Noah OkaforLEELEE v. CRYM5.80.44.93
43 22  Cody GakpoLIVLIV at BOUM7.212.64.92
44 23  Ethan AmpaduLEELEE v. CRYM5.40.94.86
45 24  Lewis MileyNEWNEW v. HULM5.50.14.85
4612   EvanilsonBOUBOU v. LIVF6.03.24.83
47  11 Jan Paul van HeckeTOTTOT v. AVLD4.96.74.83
4813   Dominic SolankeTOTTOT v. AVLF5.80.94.82
49  12 Ousmane DiomandeNFONFO v. COVD5.40.54.73
50 25  Hayden HackneyEVEEVE v. IPSM5.50.24.73
51  13 James JustinLEELEE v. CRYD4.51.54.70
52 26  Kevin SchadeBREBRE v. CHEM6.17.34.70
53 27  Bryan MbeumoMUNMUN at FULM7.921.84.70
54 28  Martin OdegaardARSARS at BHAM6.819.84.70
55 29  Ao TanakaLEELEE v. CRYM4.90.34.68
56 30  Enzo FernandezMCIMCI v. SUNM6.93.54.67
57  14 Malick ThiawNEWNEW v. HULD5.02.24.67
58 31  James McAteeNFONFO v. COVM5.50.14.63
59 32  Jacob MurphyNEWNEW v. HULM5.90.14.62
60 33  Tyrique GeorgeEVEEVE v. IPSM5.51.04.60
61  15 Pedro PorroTOTTOT v. AVLD5.48.34.60
62 34  Xaver SchlagerNFONFO v. COVM5.00.14.59
63 35  Matheus CunhaMUNMUN at FULM7.95.84.59
64 36  RayanBOUBOU v. LIVM6.41.64.57
65 37  Youri TielemansMUNMUN at FULM5.81.54.55
66 38  Mamadou SangareBREBRE v. CHEM5.711.34.55
67 39  Alexis Mac AllisterLIVLIV at BOUM5.41.34.47
6814   Nicolas JacksonAVLAVL at TOTF6.51.24.47
69 40  Dan NdoyeNFONFO v. COVM5.50.84.47
70  17 Jayden BogleLEELEE v. CRYD4.65.64.46
71 41  Alex IwobiFULFUL v. MUNM5.40.74.45
72  16 Maxence LacroixCHECHE at BRED6.07.04.43
73 42  Shea CharlesFULFUL v. MUNM5.00.14.42
74 43  Granit XhakaSUNSUN at MCIM5.53.84.36
75  18 Riccardo CalafioriARSARS at BHAD5.850.24.36
76 44  Kobbie MainooMUNMUN at FULM5.51.64.36
77  19 Ola AinaNFONFO v. COVD4.52.64.35
78 45  Adam WhartonCRYCRY at LEEM5.50.84.35
79  20 Matteo RuggeriAVLAVL at TOTD4.50.14.34
8015   EmersonnIPSIPS at EVEF5.53.14.34
81 46  Christos TzolisARSARS at BHAM6.413.64.33
82   1Gianluigi DonnarummaMCIMCI v. SUNG5.57.94.31
83 47  Rodrigo BentancurTOTTOT v. AVLM5.50.24.30
84 48  Yasin AyariBHABHA v. ARSM5.40.44.29
85  21 Nico ElvediLEELEE v. CRYD4.50.04.29
86 49  Tyler AdamsBOUBOU v. LIVM5.00.34.29
87 50  Justin KluivertBOUBOU v. LIVM6.01.04.27
88 51  Sandro TonaliTOTTOT v. AVLM5.42.04.26
89  22 Harry MaguireMUNMUN at FULD4.99.54.25
90 52  Josh KingFULFUL v. MUNM5.51.84.25
91  23 Tyrone MingsAVLAVL at TOTD4.50.44.24
92 53  Julio EncisoIPSIPS at EVEM5.50.84.24
93  24 James HillBOUBOU v. LIVD5.50.84.22
94 54  Boubacar KamaraAVLAVL at TOTM5.00.34.21
95   2Matz SelsNFONFO v. COVG5.01.84.21
96 55  Exequiel PalaciosIPSIPS at EVEM5.00.14.21
97  25 Antonio SilvaBOUBOU v. LIVD5.00.44.19
98 56  Marcus RashfordMUNMUN at FULM7.01.64.19
99  26 Jarrad BranthwaiteEVEEVE v. IPSD5.52.34.18
10016   Omar MarmoushTOTTOT v. AVLF7.02.24.17
101  27 David AffengruberFULFUL v. MUND4.50.04.15
102   3David RayaARSARS at BHAG6.041.14.14
103  28 Virgil van DijkLIVLIV at BOUD6.516.44.12
104  29 Ruben DiasMCIMCI v. SUND5.51.94.11
105  30 Lewis HallNEWNEW v. HULD5.214.74.11
10617   Jorgen Strand LarsenCRYCRY at LEEF6.00.64.10
107 57  Florian WirtzLIVLIV at BOUM7.36.34.09
108  31 Vitaliy MykolenkoEVEEVE v. IPSD4.53.84.09
109 58  Matt GrimesCOVCOV at NFOM4.90.14.09
110  32 Jurrien TimberARSARS at BHAD6.50.34.08
111 59  Joao GomesAVLAVL at TOTM5.50.14.07
112 60  Emiliano BuendiaAVLAVL at TOTM5.90.94.06
113 61  Jaidon AnthonyBREBRE v. CHEM5.90.14.05
114  33 Honest AhanorCRYCRY at LEED4.50.04.05
115 62  Patrick DorguMUNMUN at FULM5.80.54.04
116  34 Ezri KonsaARSARS at BHAD4.518.74.04
117  35 Takehiro TomiyasuCRYCRY at LEED4.40.34.03
118  36 Gabriel GudmundssonLEELEE v. CRYD4.50.14.03
119  37 Antonee RobinsonFULFUL v. MUND4.51.44.03
120  38 Chris RichardsCRYCRY at LEED5.00.64.01
121 63  Mateus FernandesTOTTOT v. AVLM5.50.04.00
122 64  Enzo Le FeeSUNSUN at MCIM5.83.64.00
123 65  Yehor YarmolyukBREBRE v. CHEM4.80.74.00
124  39 Anan KhalailiCRYCRY at LEED5.00.33.98
125  40 Adrien TruffertBOUBOU v. LIVD5.53.13.98
12618   Charalampos KostoulasBHABHA v. ARSF5.50.93.98
127  41 Ethan PinnockCOVCOV at NFOD4.50.13.98
128 66  John McGinnAVLAVL at TOTM5.42.23.97
129  42 Jacob GreavesIPSIPS at EVED4.01.13.96
130 67  Matt CrooksHULHUL at NEWM4.50.53.95
131 68  Bradley BarcolaLIVLIV at BOUM8.01.93.95
132   4Zion SuzukiAVLAVL at TOTG5.01.83.93
133 69  Sasa LukicIPSIPS at EVEM5.00.13.93
134 70  Pascal GrossBHABHA v. ARSM5.720.43.91
135 71  Romeo LaviaCHECHE at BREM5.00.23.91
136 72  Brennan JohnsonEVEEVE v. IPSM5.90.13.89
137 73  Jack RudoniCOVCOV at NFOM4.90.13.89
138 74  Jack ClarkeIPSIPS at EVEM5.40.23.87
139  43 Bobby ThomasCOVCOV at NFOD4.08.73.85
140 75  Abdul FatawuIPSIPS at EVEM5.40.23.84
141 76  Ephron Mason-ClarkCOVCOV at NFOM5.40.13.83
142 77  Diego GomezBHABHA v. ARSM5.04.23.83
143 78  Regan SlaterHULHUL at NEWM4.55.53.82
144  44 Ainsley Maitland-NilesEVEEVE v. IPSD4.50.93.82
145   5James TraffordLEELEE v. CRYG5.05.53.79
146 79  Keane Lewis-PotterBREBRE v. CHEM5.51.83.78
147 80  Sander BergeFULFUL v. MUNM4.90.33.77
148 81  Quinten TimberCRYCRY at LEEM5.00.03.77
149 82  Frank OnyekaCOVCOV at NFOM4.90.13.75
150  45 John EganHULHUL at NEWD4.17.03.75
151   6Antonin KinskyTOTTOT v. AVLG4.518.23.72
152 83  SavioTOTTOT v. AVLM6.50.73.72
153 84  Daichi KamadaCRYCRY at LEEM5.00.53.70
154 85  Joe WillockNEWNEW v. HULM5.00.53.69
155  46 Micky van de VenTOTTOT v. AVLD5.04.03.65
15619   Brian BrobbeySUNSUN at MCIF5.85.63.64
157  48 Jeremy JacquetLIVLIV at BOUD5.03.23.63
158  49 Lisandro MartinezMUNMUN at FULD5.01.33.63
159 86  Pedro NetoCHECHE at BREM6.51.43.63
160  50 Jannik SchusterBREBRE v. CHED4.50.13.61
161 87  George HemmingsAVLAVL at TOTM4.51.33.60
162  47 Wesley FofanaCHECHE at BRED5.00.23.60
163  51 Ronald AraujoLIVLIV at BOUD5.42.93.58
164  52 Dara O'SheaIPSIPS at EVED4.02.83.54
165   7Jordan PickfordEVEEVE v. IPSG5.59.23.49
166 88  Malick YalcouyeBHABHA v. ARSM4.54.03.49
167  53 Levi ColwillCHECHE at BRED4.90.93.44
168  54 Semi AjayiHULHUL at NEWD4.214.13.44
169 89  Yeremy PinoCRYCRY at LEEM5.50.43.43
170  55 Maxim De CuyperBHABHA v. ARSD4.924.43.43
171  56 Daniel BallardSUNSUN at MCID4.92.73.43
172   8Lukas HornicekNEWNEW v. HULG5.01.53.42
173   9Carl RushworthCOVCOV at NFOG4.50.83.41
174  57 Issa DiopIPSIPS at EVED4.013.33.40
175 90  Oscar BobbFULFUL v. MUNM5.50.33.36
176  58 Nordi MukieleSUNSUN at MCID5.41.93.31
177  59 Timothy CastagneFULFUL v. MUND4.50.83.30
178   11Robin RoefsSUNSUN at MCIG4.92.63.30
179  60 Calvin BasseyFULFUL v. MUND4.50.73.28
180  61 Valentino LivramentoNEWNEW v. HULD4.90.13.28
181 91  Elliot StroudHULHUL at NEWM5.00.13.25
182   10Senne LammensMUNMUN at FULG4.910.33.22
183  62 Joel LatibeaudiereCOVCOV at NFOD4.00.03.22
184  63 Victor LindelofAVLAVL at TOTD4.50.33.18
185   15Kjell ScherpenIPSIPS at EVEG4.50.63.18
186   13Caoimhin KelleherBREBRE v. CHEG5.06.13.18
187   12Bernd LenoFULFUL v. MUNG4.53.13.17
188  64 Kristoffer AjerBREBRE v. CHED4.54.03.17
189   14Emiliano MartinezCHECHE at BREG5.04.93.17
190 92  Noah SadikiSUNSUN at MCIM4.90.23.09
191   16AlissonLIVLIV at BOUG5.53.93.03
192  65 Diogo DalotMUNMUN at FULD4.91.73.02
19320   Sidiki CherifCOVCOV at NFOF5.00.13.01
194  66 Tyrick MitchellCRYCRY at LEED4.56.13.01
195  67 Destiny UdogieTOTTOT v. AVLD4.40.33.00
196 93  Nilson AnguloSUNSUN at MCIM5.00.12.97
197  68 Kevin DansoSUNSUN at MCID5.00.22.97
198 94  Sean SteurNEWNEW v. HULM4.90.12.97
199  69 Matty CashAVLAVL at TOTD4.45.12.90
200   17Konstantinos TzolakisHULHUL at NEWG4.611.32.88
201  70 Leif DavisIPSIPS at EVED4.06.72.81
202  71 Luka VuskovicBHABHA v. ARSD5.03.12.75
203   18Djordje PetrovicBOUBOU v. LIVG4.53.02.73
204   19Bart VerbruggenBHABHA v. ARSG4.521.42.65
205  72 Milan van EwijkCOVCOV at NFOD4.09.62.65
206   20Walter BenitezCRYCRY at LEEG4.50.12.61
207  73 Milos KerkezLIVLIV at BOUD5.42.32.61
208  74 Jay DasilvaCOVCOV at NFOD4.00.72.58
209  75 Olivier BoscagliBHABHA v. ARSD4.50.32.53
210  76 Pep ChavarriaCHECHE at BRED4.90.12.46
211  77 Aaron HickeyBREBRE v. CHED4.50.12.46
212  78 Ryan GilesHULHUL at NEWD4.02.82.42
213  79 Ferdi KadiogluBHABHA v. ARSD4.41.62.25
214  80 Lucas HerringtonHULHUL at NEWD4.00.62.25
215  81 Lewis DunkBHABHA v. ARSD4.51.52.20
216  82 Trai HumeSUNSUN at MCID4.43.12.15
217  83 Adam SmithBOUBOU v. LIVD4.50.11.93
218 95  Valentin BarcoCHECHE at BREM5.40.11.91
219  84 Thomas MeunierSUNSUN at MCID4.50.31.62
220  85 Lewie CoyleHULHUL at NEWD4.00.71.29

Final Thoughts

Manchester City are the obvious team to prioritize in Gameweek 5, with the home matchup against Sunderland creating strong appeal across forwards, midfielders, defenders and goalkeeper.

Newcastle are the next team that stands out at home to Hull, while Nottingham Forest and Everton also have favorable home spots. Arsenal remain strong options despite traveling to Brighton, particularly for managers who already own their premium players.

The rankings should continue to move as expected minutes and predicted lineups change during the week, so the biggest thing to monitor before the deadline is role security rather than small differences in projected points.

More FPL Gameweek 5 Tips

Questions or a captain call you're stuck on? Find me on Twitter @RotoZdroik or in the subscriber Discord.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Adam, a multiple-time finalist for FSWA's Soccer Writer of the Year, is RotoWire's soccer editor. He runs RotoWire's Bracketology and partakes in various NFL content. He previously worked at ESPN and Sporting Kansas City, and he is a former Streak for the Cash winner and Michigan State graduate.
RotoWire Logo

Continue the Conversation

Join the RotoWire Discord group to hear from our experts and other Soccer fans.

Top News

Tools

MLB Draft Kit Logo

MLB Draft Kit

Fantasy Tools

Don’t miss a beat. Check out our 2026 MLB Fantasy Baseball rankings.

Related Stories