Carl Pavano

2013

Subscribe now to see our 2013 outlook.

2012

Pavano's numbers declined last season (his wins fell to nine from 17 in 2010; and his ERA jumped to 4.30 from 3.75), but he was largely the same pitcher. Pavano has outstanding control (sixth-lowest walk rate among starters in baseball) and generates groundballs (50.6 percent). He was also durable despite his injury-plagued past by going six or more innings in 25 of 32 starts and tying a career high in innings pitched. The difference was that the defense behind him was terrible (the Twins were last in team defensive efficiency) and the bullpen struggled. If the Twins can put better fielders behind him and the bullpen improves, Pavano could bounce back. Still, his upside is limited given his anemic strikeout rate (4.14 K/9IP) that was the second worst among all starters. He'll enter the season as Minnesota's No. 2 or No. 3 starter.

2011

Pavano's career appeared almost over in 2008 as he came back from Tommy John surgery and the weight of his failures with the Yankees after signing a large contract. But Pavano revived his career in 2009 with the Indians and improved when traded later that summer to the Twins. He continued that revival in 2010 with his best season since 2004. Pavano won 17 games last season with outstanding control (third-lowest walk rate among starters in baseball) and by getting groundballs (51.2 percent of batted balls). He was also durable despite his injury-plagued past by going six or more innings in 27 of 32 starts and nearly matching his career high in innings pitched. Still, there are some signs he didn't pitch as well as his ERA or win total indicated as he had an anemic 4.8 K/9IP and also had a low .286 BABIP. He will enter 2011 as the No. 2 starter in Minnesota's rotation, but given worrying signs in his peripheral numbers, his age (35 this season) and checkered injury history, be wary of paying for his 2010 stats.

2010

Pavano revived his career last season and enters 2010 as one of the top three starters for Minnesota. Pavano's four-year, $39.95 million contract with the Yankees may have been one of the worst contracts of the decade as he struggled with injuries and the media spotlight. Once free of the Bronx, he won a job in Cleveland's rotation and pitched well before being traded to the Twins in August. He helped the Twins win a playoff spot by stabilizing the rotation and had a strong outing in his one playoff start (two earned runs in seven innings). While Pavano's 5.10 ERA wasn't overly impressive, he had good secondary numbers with strong control (147:39 K:BB ratio) and slightly above average strikeout (6.6 K/9IP) and groundball rates. He looks like an innings-eater/league average starter that could stabilize the young Minnesota rotation. However, he comes with considerable injury risk since last season was the first time he pitched more than 100 innings since 2004 amid hip, elbow (including Tommy John surgery), back and shoulder problems.

2009

Pavano's four-year, $39.95 million deal with the Yankees finally came to an end after the 2008 season. Calling him a complete bust might be a friendly approach given his combination of injuries to pure ineffectiveness. He'll get a chance to start in Cleveland after signing a one-year deal with the Tribe in January, but the upside for fantasy owners is extremely limited given his shaky recent history and that he's never been one to miss many bats. Don't expect much.

2008

Hailed as the greatest contractual disaster in team history, the Yankees still owe Pavano $11 million for 2008 or a $1.95 million buyout if they release him. The option at press time was doing the latter and re-signing Pavano to a minor-league deal to at least have his arm at the team's disposal if he returns from Tommy John surgery this season. Either way, you know by now to avoid Pavano at the draft table.

2007

Pavano suffered cracked ribs last August in an unreported automobile accident, after he'd been rehabilitating a back and buttocks injury, which was preceeded by an elbow injury. The good news is an orthopedic specialist believes there is some science behind his injury problems. Pavano apparently suffers from a hip dysfunction, which caused one leg to become longer than the other, and resulted in nagging back problems. The disappointing righty has been working extensively to get ready for the 2007 season, but he'll have to earn a role with the Yankees this spring if he isn't moved prior to the start of camp.

2006

Pavano was a complete bust after signing a big free agent contract with the Yankees. He was mediocre for much of the first half before missing the second half with a shoulder problem that seemed to get worse as time went on. Still, he's not as bad as he showed last year, and in the Yankees rotation is a major rebound candidate. He won't be the pitcher he was in Florida in 2004, though.

2005

Pavano signed a $40 million contract with the Yankees in the offseason - not bad for a guy who's only had two good years in his career. To be fair, they've been the last two years and Pavano shows every sign of having overcome his injury problems and found his groove. It'll be interesting to see how he handles the pressure in Yankee Stadium.

2004

Pavano had far and away the best year of his career, setting new highs in innings, strikeouts and wins. If he's put his injury woes behind him, he should be a dependable middle-of-the-rotation starter. Until he does it again, though, assume that's a big 'if'.

2003

Pavano actually set a career high in innings in 2002 with 136, which just about says it all for him. He'll never live down the fact that he was traded for Pedro, but right now he's still having trouble just salvaging a decent career. He's the kind-of-talented but combustible pitcher you never want to lose track of entirely, but you want to see a month of solid starts from before you consider a free-agent bid.