William Karlsson

Karlsson provided 30 goals and 60 points in 70 contests last season, marking the first time since 2017-18 that he supplied at least 25 markers. Of course, his 2017-18 campaign was noteworthy for him netting 43 goals on the strength of an unsustainable 23.4 shooting percentage and he predictably declined afterward. His performance last season wasn't as extreme, but his 17.1 shooting percentage in 2023-24 was still well above his career average of 13 percent, so he probably did overperform again, and we should consequently anticipate another regression, albeit a lighter one than before. Temper your expectations for the 31-year-old by penciling him in for around 20 goals and 50 points. He doesn't stand out in terms of PIM or hits, but if your league values faceoffs, then he will provide you with a bit of extra help. He won 547 draws last season for a 56.2 winning percentage and, unlike his offensive production, it's reasonable to expect similar results from him in that category going forward.

Karlsson returned to the 50-point mark for the first time since 2018-19 with 14 goals and 39 assists in 82 contests last season. The Swede has settled in as a reliable all-situations center for the Golden Knights, capable of playing tough matchups and contributing solid offense. His offense mostly comes from assists -- he hasn't topped the 20-goal mark in four years, which puts a damper on his fantasy value. He's also finished on the positive side of zero in plus-minus for seven years running. Karlsson may not be a regular 50-point threat heading into his 30s, but he's a solid mid-to-late-round depth forward in fantasy leagues this year.

Karlsson's production has dropped each of his five years with the Golden Knights, with the recently completed campaign being his worst to date. In 67 games last season, Karlsson managed just a dozen goals and 35 points. It's been a steep, steady decline for a player who produced at nearly a point-per-game pace as recently as the 2017-18 season. The Swede won't be 30 years old until January, so there should still be plenty of gas left in the tank here, but Karlsson appears to be nothing more than a late-round fantasy dart throw until further notice.

Karlsson can blame a short season for setting a new low in scoring output (14 goals, 39 points in 56 games) in his Golden Knights tenure. All things considered, he's still the team's top center barring any blockbuster trades. The Swede likely would have exceeded his 46-point output from 2019-20 in a full campaign, and he could have challenged to return to the 60-point mark. The 28-year-old should remain involved in all situations heading into 2021-22, giving him some added appeal in formats that count shorthanded points. The rest of his offense will likely come down to how well his playmaking suits the other top-six forwards on the roster, namely longtime linemates Jonathan Marchessault and Reilly Smith.

We knew Karlsson's 43-goal season in 2017-18 was a fluke, but now we're wondering where his floor lies. His 15 goals and 46 points last season were his lowest totals as a Knight, and that performance was barely passable for a top-six center. He's a beneficiary of ice time on a team that lacks depth down the middle, but it's becoming increasingly clear Vegas will need someone more talented to take advantage of its star wingers. He's already been supplanted on the power play by the Golden Knights younger but more talented centers, and that will put a cap on his offensive production heading into 2020-21. There's not much risk with Karlsson, but at such a deep position, fantasy managers are probably better off taking chances on players with more upside in the middle rounds.

Flush with cash as a third-year club, Vegas signed Karlsson to an eight-year, $47 million contract in June. He and Senators castoff Mark Stone -- who inked an eight-year, $76 million deal of his own -- project to be the cornerstones of a young franchise that has already experienced unprecedented success, including a Stanley Cup Final appearance in its inaugural season. Karlsson dialed in 24 goals, 32 assists and 14 power-play points last year, but the output looks paltry compared to his numbers from 2018-19, when he stacked a career-high 78 points on top of a league-best plus-49 rating. The Golden Knights have a lot vested in "Wild Bill," so he should continue seeing plentiful man-advantage minutes while cementing his status as a set-and-forget fantasy option.

After being exposed by the Blue Jackets and getting selected by Vegas in the expansion draft, Karlsson was arguably the biggest fantasy surprise of 2017-18. Centering the top line with Reilly Smith and Jonathan Marchessault, Karlsson scored a whopping 43 goals last season. After recording just 15 goals in two seasons with Columbus, his transformation into an elite goal-scorer almost seems unfathomable. Karlsson and the Golden Knights avoided arbitration with a one-year, $5.25 million contract in the summer, as the centre will have to prove 2017-18 was no fluke. Karlsson is a special player, but expecting him to sustain his 23.4 shooting percentage and record another 40-goal season is unrealistic. While a regression is likely, look for Karlsson to still be a dynamic scorer on the top line and first power-play unit.

Karlsson put together a second straight quality campaign in 2016-17, filling a bottom-six role for the Blue Jackets that didn't provide him with many scoring opportunities but allowed him to show effective two-way play. The 24-year-old doesn't have any one elite skill, but his well-rounded game should provide him with a long NHL career, and he could put some extra points on the board in the right situation — like the one he now finds himself in after being selected by Las Vegas in the expansion draft. On a Golden Knights squad lacking established scoring threats up the middle, Karlsson may be receive more opportunities than he saw in Columbus.

Karlsson played a full NHL schedule for the first time in his young career last year and showed flashes of potential, but the 23-year-old still only managed 20 points while skating on the third and fourth lines for a poor Columbus team. The Jackets' lack of depth up the middle could allow him to sneak into a larger role at some point should injuries strike, and he could be productive if given a chance, but he mostly appears to be little more than an afterthought in a system flush with top prospects pushing their way toward the NHL.

The 21-year-old Karlsson will compete for the Ducks' third-line center job in training camp against fellow Swede Rickard Rakell. Should he fail to win the gig, a full season at AHL Norfolk likely awaits for Karlsson.