Cliff Lee

2013

Subscribe now to see our 2013 outlook.

2012

Lee proved to be worth every penny the Phillies gave him last season as he finished third in the National League Cy Young voting behind rotation mate Roy Halladay. Lee saw his strikeout rate spike last year with the move to the NL and he continued to display his excellent control. His only real disappointment to Phillies fans was his playoff performance. Lee should remain one of the safer investments in fantasy leagues again this year but you'll have to pay top dollar to obtain him.

2011

Lee lifted Texas to an appearance in the World Series after a midseason trade from Seattle. His lone struggles during the regular season came as he was battling some back issues, and he entered the offseason as the premier pitcher on the market. He decided to sign with the Phillies following a long courtship by both the Rangers and the Yankees, and gives the Phillies a dynamic rotation behind Roy Halladay and ahead of Roy Oswalt and Cole Hamels. He's been among the most durable and dependable starters since 2008 and there's no reason to think he won't remain so for several more seasons.

2010

Lee proved that his Cy Young season in 2008 was no fluke with very similar ratios in 2009. The only real difference was that his BABIP rose from .305 in 2008 to .326 in 2009, which helped to bump his ERA up a bit. Instead of signing a long-term deal with the Phillies, Lee was interested in testing the free-agent market after the 2010 season, so the Phillies traded him to Seattle for three prospects and elected to make a separate deal to acquire Roy Halladay from the Blue Jays. Back in the American League, Lee will likely slip back closer to the 6.5-7.0 K/9IP mark that he had with Cleveland from the 8.4 K/9IP he posted with the Phillies in the second half of 2009. Still, he figures to be a Cy Young candidate again with a strong defense and an improving club around him on the west coast.

2009

A rebound season could have been expected but nobody saw this one coming. Lee picked up the AL Cy Young award after a dazzling season. He had shown flashes of this back in 2005 as a 26-year-old but hadn’t come close to approaching those numbers since. He made his greatest strides in limiting right-handed batters to just a .245/.279/.343 line. If the improvement against righties is for real instead of being some year-long fluke, he could hold onto most of the gains he made, but it's hard to see a repeat performance. He'll be back at the front of the Indians' rotation in 2009.

2008

Lee was slowed by an abdominal strain in the spring which kept him sidelined for the first month of the season. From that point forward, it was a large dose of ugly until he was sent to Triple-A at the end of July. He didn't go out on a high note, losing his last four starts with an 11.70 ERA to bring his season to a close with a 5-8 record, 6.29 ERA and a 1.521 WHIP. It's pretty clear his 2005 was an outlier and he heads into spring having to battle Jeremy Sowers and Aaron Laffey and possibly Adam Miller for the last spot in the Tribe rotation after the team picked up the contract option on Paul Byrd. He's a decent rebound candidate if he can win and hold onto the fifth spot out of spring training but don't expect him to regain the form he had in 2005.

2007

Lee is the type of pitcher that drives fantasy owners nuts. He was abysmal for three months last season, while being unhittable in the other three. He will be given every opportunity to work himself back into 2005 shape and is entering his late 20s, were left-handers usually take the next step. Assuming he is destined to ramp up his game, Lee would most certainly be a worthwhile gamble come draft day.

2006

Had the Indians overcome the odds and made it to the playoffs with their late drive, Lee would have been a shoe-in for the Cy Young Award. Keeping his walks and home-run totals down, Lee turned in a beautiful 18-5 campaign that included a 9-1 record after the All-Star break. His peripherals promote caution, as his 1.218 WHIP, falling strikeout rate and 3.79 ERA display some fortunate bounces among those 18 wins. Post-season surgery on a hernia is expected to be healed in time for the spring.

2005

It was a tale of two seasons for Lee in 2004. Cleveland's young lefthander was 9-1, 3.81 before the All-Star break and 5-7, 7.91 afterward. Despite being lit up for 10 weeks, it was a positive season for Lee. He stayed aggressive in the second half, walking 30 men in his final 15 starts after dealing 51 walks in his first 18 starts. Lee ranked 11th in the AL in strikeouts and tied for eighth in wins. He has good stuff, a nice motion, and is on an up-and-coming team. Lee may need another couple of years to develop into a big winner, but that is where he is headed.

2004

Lee is highly touted for good reason, and was 10-4 between Triple-A and the majors, showing the ability to strike people out at both levels. As with any young pitcher, he will need to work on getting the ball over the plate on a consistent basis. Look for him to compete for a starting job in the spring, with the possibility that he bounces between Cleveland and Buffalo at the beginning of the season.

2003

Lee has ranked among the toughest pitchers to hit in the entire minors in both 2001 and 2002. Though he's a bit older than you'd like for a Double-A prospect, he possesses four quality pitches and above average command. He rocketed through the Indians' organization after the Bartolo Colon trade.