The RotoWire Blog has been retired.

These archives exist as a way for people to continue to view the content that had been posted on the blog over the years.

Articles will no longer be posted here, but you can view new fantasy articles from our writers on the main site.

The Problem With Drafting Billy Hamilton

Me: Hamilton went $28 in NL

Fellow Writer: Godspeed my friends

Fellow Writer: Here's the problem I have with Hamilton

Fellow Writer: 1. Can he earn it, period, but also...

Fellow Writer: 2. if you draft him, you're almost committing to |STAR||STAR|avoiding|STAR||STAR| speed with every other pick

Fellow Writer: Your tactical options become very limitd with him, very quickly

Fellow Writer: He's the Adam Dunn of speed

Me: He's the linchpin of an entire offensive category. You will either finish 1st or last in steals, all dependent on him

Fellow Writer: Right

Fellow Writer: And that's not good

Me: You're going to take your Fielders, Cruz's, etc around him for power, so if the kid flops, you have nothing

Me: easier in Tout since you can trade, but in NFBC, man that's risky

Fellow Writer: Yep

Fellow Writer: He's on my no-fly list this year

Fellow Writer: No scenario where I end up with him on any team

Me: Omar Moreno stole 60 bases with a sub .300 OBP, but will the Reds let him play that much? I think they have to because as bad as he may be, he's still the best CF on that roster by far

Me: I have him as a rookie keeper in my home league - only way I'm owning him

Fellow Writer: They don't have any other options, really

Fellow Writer: Heisey and Bruce are emergency backups, but who can play out there regularly? Schumaker? Ah, no

Me: yep, which is why the PT concerns really aren't an issue for me. They'll give him a lot of leash unless they find some alternative via the final weeks as rosters get trimmed

Fellow Writer: But here's another thing... let's say he plays 145 games or so

Fellow Writer: is that 60 steals? 80? 100? He's unprojectable

Fellow Writer: There are no comps for him to determine what a realistic expectation is, and his PT last year was so specific that you can project against that

Me: I have him at a 45 steal floor

Fellow Writer: I have him at 80 for my projection/ranking purposes, but since I'm not drafting him anyway it kinda doesn't matter :-)

Fellow Writer: That's maybe even |STAR||STAR| conservative|STAR||STAR| based on his MiLB numbers

Normal 0 false false false EN-US X-NONE X-NONE