Took place on Tuesday, April 29
| Brandon Funston | Chris Liss | Mike Doria | Brad Evans | Lenny Pappano | Kyle Fisher | |
| Yahoo! Sports | RotoWire.com | RotoWire.com | Yahoo! Sports | DraftSharks.com | RotoWire.com | |
| 1 | LaDainian Tomlinson | Joseph Addai | Adrian Peterson | Brian Westbrook | Steven Jackson | Marion Barber |
| 2 | Steve Smith | Braylon Edwards | Michael Turner | Ronnie Brown | Reggie Wayne | Terrell Owens |
| 3 | Maurice Jones-Drew | Larry Fitzgerald | T.J Houshmandzadeh | Marques Colston | Jamal Lewis | Torry Holt |
| 4 | Drew Brees | Carson Palmer | Roy Williams | Wes Welker | Anquan Boldin | LenDale White |
| 5 | Antonio Gates | Reggie Bush | Thomas Jones | Rashard Mendenhall | Jason Witten | Derek Anderson |
| 6 | Travis Henry | Rudi Johnson | Hines Ward | Ben Roethlisberger | Julius Jones | Kevin Curtis |
| 7 | Laveranues Coles | Ahmad Bradshaw | Dallas Clark | DeAngelo Williams | Jerry Porter | Chris Cooley |
| 8 | Jerious Norwood | Chris Johnson | Donovan McNabb | D.J. Hackett | Vincent Jackson | Donald Driver |
| 9 | Bobby Engram | Reggie Williams | Donte Stallworth | Selvin Young | Justin Fargas | Chester Taylor |
| 10 | Ted Ginn Jr. | Nate Burleson | Ray Rice | Steve Slaton | David Garrard | Ronald Curry |
| 11 | Devin Hester | Jeremy Shockey | Vince Young | Todd Heap | Bryant Johnson | Kenny Watson |
| 12 | Aaron Rodgers | New York Giants | Limas Sweed | Jamaal Charles | Jake Delhomme | Cadillac Williams |
| 13 | Minnesota Vikings | Kenton Keith | New England Patriots | Green Bay Packers | Kevin Jones | Jason Campbell |
| 14 | Michael Bush | Shaun Alexander | Jacob Hester | Marty Booker | Tony Scheffler | Indianapolis Colts |
| 15 | Ben Watson | Kellen Clemens | Early Doucet | DeShaun Foster | Buffalo Bills | Alge Crumpler |
| 16 | Brandon Coutu | Lawrence Tynes | Neil Rackers | Josh Brown | Nate Kaeding | Robbie Gould |
| Erik Siegrist | Jeff Erickson | Andy Behrens | Dalton Del Don | Derek Van Riper | Michael Beller | |
| RotoWire.com | RotoWire.com | Yahoo! Sports | RotoWire.com | RotoWire.com | RotoWire.com | |
| 1 | Laurence Maroney | Randy Moss | Larry Johnson | Ryan Grant | Marshawn Lynch | Frank Gore |
| 2 | Darren McFadden | Willis McGahee | Brandon Jacobs | Andre Johnson | Clinton Portis | Tom Brady |
| 3 | Tony Romo | Earnest Graham | Peyton Manning | Jonathan Stewart | Chad Johnson | Brandon Marshall |
| 4 | Calvin Johnson | Greg Jennings | Santonio Holmes | Plaxico Burress | Marvin Harrison | Willie Parker |
| 5 | Lee Evans | Kevin Smith | Matt Forte | Roddy White | Tony Gonzalez | Dwayne Bowe |
| 6 | Fred Taylor | Jerricho Cotchery | Joey Galloway | Kellen Winslow | Edgerrin James | Felix Jones |
| 7 | Chris Chambers | Heath Miller | Anthony Gonzalez | Jay Cutler | Santana Moss | Javon Walker |
| 8 | Bernard Berrian | Eli Manning | Marc Bulger | Reggie Brown | Matt Hasselbeck | Cedric Benson |
| 9 | Patrick Crayton | Sammy Morris | Derrick Mason | Matt Schaub | Sidney Rice | Deuce McAllister |
| 10 | Greg Olsen | Mark Clayton | Kolby Smith | Ryan Torain | Ahman Green | Vernon Davis |
| 11 | Maurice Morris | Darrell Jackson | Owen Daniels | Pierre Thomas | Laurent Robinson | Tatum Bell |
| 12 | Chicago Bears | Leon Washington | Derrick Ward | Brandon Jackson | James Hardy | DeSean Jackson |
| 13 | Philip Rivers | San Diego Charg | Jacksonville Jaguars | Baltimore Ravens | Dallas Cowboys | Chris Brown |
| 14 | Seattle Seahawks | Jon Kitna | Ladell Betts | Devin Thomas | Mike Hart | Pittsburgh Steelers |
| 15 | Jeff King | Roydell Williams | Jacoby Jones | Matt Leinart | JaMarcus Russell | Mark Bradley |
| 16 | Rob Bironas | Shayne Graham | Nick Folk | Adam Vinatieri | Mason Crosby | Stephen Gostkowski |