Fantasy Football
Fantasy Sports
DFS
Sports Betting
Picks & Props
Subscribe Now
The Composite RotoWire 200: Overall Rankings List

The Composite RotoWire 200: Overall Rankings List

Written by 
Chris Liss 
Updated on August 11, 2012 6:55AM EST
Four RotoWire Staff members weighed in with their top-200 overall players in a 12-14 team league with standard scoring (no PPR). Assume 1-QB, 2-RB, 3-WR, 1 FLEX (RB/WR/TE), 1 TE. (No K or Defense). We also averaged the four rankings into a composite rank and average. (Unranked players were counted as No. 225 for the purposes of the composite average).

Feedback is welcome.

RankJeff EricksonLuke HooverKevin PayneChris LissCompositeAverage
1Arian FosterAaron RodgersArian FosterArian FosterArian Foster1.25
2Ray RiceArian FosterRay RiceCalvin JohnsonRay Rice2.75
3LeSean McCoyRay RiceLeSean McCoyLeSean McCoyAaron Rodgers3.75
4Aaron RodgersTom BradyCalvin JohnsonRay RiceLeSean McCoy4.25
5Calvin JohnsonDrew BreesAaron RodgersAaron RodgersCalvin Johnson4.5
6Chris JohnsonChris JohnsonChris JohnsonChris JohnsonChris Johnson6
7Tom BradyCalvin JohnsonTom BradyTom BradyTom Brady6.25
8Drew BreesLeSean McCoyDrew BreesDrew BreesDrew Brees7.25
9Larry FitzgeraldJulio JonesDarren McFaddenMaurice Jones-DrewDarren McFadden11.75
10Darren McFaddenCam NewtonJimmy GrahamDarren McFaddenJimmy Graham13.25
11DeMarco MurrayJimmy GrahamCam NewtonCam NewtonCam Newton13.25
12Victor CruzMarshawn LynchDeMarco MurrayA.J. GreenLarry Fitzgerald14
13Jamaal CharlesVictor CruzAdrian PetersonJulio JonesVictor Cruz15
14Marshawn LynchJordy NelsonMaurice Jones-DrewLarry FitzgeraldMaurice Jones-Drew15.5
15Maurice Jones-DrewRob GronkowskiMarshawn LynchJimmy
Four RotoWire Staff members weighed in with their top-200 overall players in a 12-14 team league with standard scoring (no PPR). Assume 1-QB, 2-RB, 3-WR, 1 FLEX (RB/WR/TE), 1 TE. (No K or Defense). We also averaged the four rankings into a composite rank and average. (Unranked players were counted as No. 225 for the purposes of the composite average).

Feedback is welcome.

RankJeff EricksonLuke HooverKevin PayneChris LissCompositeAverage
1Arian FosterAaron RodgersArian FosterArian FosterArian Foster1.25
2Ray RiceArian FosterRay RiceCalvin JohnsonRay Rice2.75
3LeSean McCoyRay RiceLeSean McCoyLeSean McCoyAaron Rodgers3.75
4Aaron RodgersTom BradyCalvin JohnsonRay RiceLeSean McCoy4.25
5Calvin JohnsonDrew BreesAaron RodgersAaron RodgersCalvin Johnson4.5
6Chris JohnsonChris JohnsonChris JohnsonChris JohnsonChris Johnson6
7Tom BradyCalvin JohnsonTom BradyTom BradyTom Brady6.25
8Drew BreesLeSean McCoyDrew BreesDrew BreesDrew Brees7.25
9Larry FitzgeraldJulio JonesDarren McFaddenMaurice Jones-DrewDarren McFadden11.75
10Darren McFaddenCam NewtonJimmy GrahamDarren McFaddenJimmy Graham13.25
11DeMarco MurrayJimmy GrahamCam NewtonCam NewtonCam Newton13.25
12Victor CruzMarshawn LynchDeMarco MurrayA.J. GreenLarry Fitzgerald14
13Jamaal CharlesVictor CruzAdrian PetersonJulio JonesVictor Cruz15
14Marshawn LynchJordy NelsonMaurice Jones-DrewLarry FitzgeraldMaurice Jones-Drew15.5
15Maurice Jones-DrewRob GronkowskiMarshawn LynchJimmy GrahamA.J. Green17
16Trent RichardsonMatt StaffordLarry FitzgeraldVictor CruzJulio Jones17
17Jimmy GrahamLarry FitzgeraldA.J. GreenGreg JenningsMarshawn Lynch17.75
18A.J. GreenDarren McFaddenRob GronkowskiHakeem NicksRob Gronkowski18.25
19Greg JenningsSteven JacksonVictor CruzMatt ForteDeMarco Murray18.5
20Rob GronkowskiRyan MathewsJulio JonesRob GronkowskiMatt Forte23
21Cam NewtonA.J. GreenDoug MartinMichael TurnerTrent Richardson23.5
22Andre JohnsonDoug MartinSteven JacksonDeMarco MurrayDoug Martin24
23Matt ForteMatt ForteAhmad BradshawAdrian PetersonJamaal Charles24
24Michael TurnerMaurice Jones-DrewBrandon MarshallTrent RichardsonGreg Jennings24.5
25Doug MartinMatt RyanMatthew StaffordAndre JohnsonAdrian Peterson25.25
26Julio JonesTrent RichardsonJamaal CharlesJamaal CharlesBrandon Marshall26.75
27Brandon MarshallBrandon MarshallMatt ForteAhmad BradshawAndre Johnson27.25
28Ryan MathewsGreg JenningsTrent RichardsonDoug MartinSteven Jackson28.75
29Adrian PetersonDeMarco MurrayFred JacksonBrandon MarshallSteven Jackson28.75
30Marques ColstonBrandon LloydAndre JohnsonMarshawn LynchRyan Mathews29.5
31Percy HarvinJamaal CharlesRoddy WhitePercy HarvinMatthew Stafford29.75
32Wes WelkerAndre JohnsonMichael TurnerRyan MathewsMichael Turner30.25
33Roddy WhiteMarques ColstonMichael VickMarques ColstonJordy Nelson31.5
34Steven JacksonRoddy WhiteGreg JenningsRoddy WhiteRoddy White33
35Fred JacksonFred JacksonHakeem NicksWes WelkerFred Jackson34.25
36Jordy NelsonAdrian PetersonWes WelkerJeremy MaclinMarques Colston34.25
37Ahmad BradshawPercy HarvinIsaac RedmanJordy NelsonPercy Harvin34.75
38Dez BryantPeyton ManningRyan MathewsFred JacksonHakeem Nicks35.25
39Hakeem NicksEli ManningJordy NelsonDemaryius ThomasAhmad Bradshaw36.25
40Vincent JacksonEric DeckerPercy HarvinSteven JacksonWes Welker39.5
41Philip RiversDez BryantMarques ColstonDez BryantDez Bryant41
42Eli ManningAntonio GatesWillis McGaheeSteve SmithIsaac Redman46.5
43Matthew StaffordStevan RidleyFrank GoreMichael VickFrank Gore48.5
44Jason WittenMichael TurnerDez BryantFrank GoreAntonio Gates48.75
45Aaron HernandezPeyton HillisStevan RidleyVincent JacksonDeMaryius Thomas49.5
46Steve SmithDarren SprolesShonn GreeneDeSean JacksonEli Manning51
47Antonio BrownIsaac RedmanBrandon LloydMike WallaceSteve Smith52
48Steve JohnsonTony RomoMiles AustinDwayne BoweAaron Hernandez53
49Isaac RedmanHakeem NicksBenJarvus Green-EllisAaron HernandezDarren Sproles53.75
50Frank GoreDemaryius ThomasDarren SprolesAntonio GatesVincent Jackson55
51Beanie WellsShonn GreeneAntonio GatesMatthew StaffordPhilip Rivers55
52Antonio GatesBenJarvus Green-EllisMark IngramMiles AustinPeyton Manning55
53DeAngelo WilliamsJermichael FinleyDemaryius ThomasIsaac RedmanBrandon Lloyd55.25
54Darren SprolesJason WittenSteve SmithC.J. SpillerMichael Vick55.75
55DeSean JacksonWes WelkerReggie BushSteve JohnsonMiles Austin56
56Demaryius ThomasTorrey SmithDwayne BoweAntonio BrownAntonio Brown58
57Reggie BushFrank GoreJeremy MaclinRoy HeluStevan Ridley58.25
58Willis McGaheeAhmad BradshawPeyton ManningPhilip RiversWillis McGahee58.75
59Miles AustinAaron HernandezAaron HernandezPeyton ManningJeremy Maclin59.75
60Jeremy MaclinAntonio BrownPhilip RiversJonathan StewartJason Witten60.75
61Mike WallacePhilip RiversVincent JacksonEli ManningBenJarvus Green-Ellis61
62BenJarvus Green-EllisDarrius Heyward-BeyEli ManningReggie BushSteve Johnson61.25
63Tony RomoJonathan StewartSteve JohnsonBeanie WellsTony Romo61.75
64Michael VickLeGarrette BlountEric DeckerWillis McGaheeReggie Bush62.5
65Peyton ManningMiles AustinDonald BrownDarren SprolesShonn Greene63.75
66Jonathan StewartSteve SmithJames StarksStevan RidleyMike Wallace64
67C.J. SpillerJermaine GreshamJonathan StewartTorrey SmithJonathan Stewart64
68James StarksVernon DavisTony RomoTony RomoDwayne Bowe64.25
69Vernon DavisDonald BrownAntonio BrownVernon DavisEric Decker65.25
70Jermichael FinleyMikel LeshoureFred DavisMatt RyanMatt Ryan67.25
71Fred DavisWillis McGaheeDeSean JacksonJason WittenTorrey Smith67.5
72Brandon LloydMike WallaceTorrey SmithBrandon LloydC.J. Spiller68.25
73Dwayne BoweBen RoethlisbergerRyan WilliamsJames StarksDeSean Jackson70.5
74Malcom FloydVincent JacksonJason WittenEric DeckerDonald Brown72.75
75Torrey SmithC.J. SpillerBen TateBen TateVernon Davis73.5
76Pierre GarconReggie BushMike WallaceRobert GriffinDeAngelo Williams76.5
77Roy HeluBen TateC.J. SpillerDonald BrownJermichael Finley77.25
78Shonn GreeneRyan WilliamsGreg LittleMark IngramJames Starks78.75
79Stevan RidleySteve JohnsonDeAngelo WilliamsMalcom FloydBeanie Wells79
80Donald BrownDwayne BoweSantonio HolmesShonn GreeneFred Davis79
81Ben TatePierre GarconPierre GarconBenJarvus Green-EllisPierre Garcon80.75
82Darrius Heyward-BeyEvan RoysterReggie WayneRyan WilliamsDarrius Heyward-Bey81
83Eric DeckerMichael VickKevin SmithDavid WilsonRoy Helu85
84Michael CrabtreeFred DavisEvan RoysterDarrius Heyward-BeyRyan Williams88
85Anquan BoldinKevin SmithBeanie WellsPierre GarconKevin Smith88.75
86Vincent BrownJeremy MaclinToby GerhartDeAngelo WilliamsReggie Wayne90
87Matt RyanToby GerhartMatt RyanRobert MeachemSantonio Holmes90.75
88Ben RoethlisbergerDeAngelo WilliamsVernon DavisEvan RoysterRobert Griffin92
89Kevin SmithRoy HeluPeyton HillisSantonio HolmesMark Ingram93
90Jermaine GreshamJacquizz RodgersMichael BushSidney RiceGreg Little94.5
91Tony GonzalezReggie WayneBrandon PettigrewFred DavisEvan Royster94.75
92Greg LittleMichael CrabtreeNate WashingtonReggie WayneToby Gerhart95
93Santonio HolmesJonathan BaldwinJermichael FinleyJermichael FinleyPeyton Hillis95
94Kenny BrittMichael BushSidney RiceVincent BrownBen Roethlisberger95.75
95Reggie WayneRashad JenningsRobert GriffinMichael CrabtreeMichael Bush97
96Sidney RiceRobert MeachemDarrius Heyward-BeyKenny BrittMichael Crabtree97.25
97Denarius MooreMike WilliamsCarson PalmerDenarius MooreRobert Meachem99.25
98Robert MeachemRobert GriffinKenny BrittKevin SmithMikel LeShoure99.25
99Robert GriffinKyle RudolphDavid WilsonJonathan BaldwinMalcom Floyd99.5
100Jay CutlerJared CookDenarius MooreRandall CobbDavid Wilson100.25
101Carson PalmerSantonio HolmesAnquan BoldinGreg LittleJermaine Gresham101.5
102Michael BushCarson PalmerJay CutlerMichael BushSidney Rice102.5
103Toby GerhartPierre ThomasLaurent RobinsonRashad JenningsDenarius Moore104.25
104Mikel LeshoureTony GonzalezJonathan BaldwinToby GerhartAnquan Boldin106.5
105David WilsonDoug BaldwinJared CookRandy MossJonathan Baldwin107.5
106Ronnie HillmanMichael FloydMike WilliamsNate WashingtonKenny Britt108
107LeGarrette BlountGreg LittleJacob TammeSantana MossLeGarrette Blount109.25
108Brandon PettigrewJames StarksPierre ThomasBen RoethlisbergerNate Washington109.75
109Brent CelekIsaiah PeadMikel LeshoureRonnie BrownPierre Thomas110.75
110Nate WashingtonDeSean JacksonFelix JonesFelix JonesCarson Palmer111
111Doug BaldwinTitus YoungBrian QuickShane VereenMike Williams111.25
112Austin CollieAndrew LuckMalcom FloydPierre ThomasDoug Baldwin112
113Mike WilliamsShane VereenJermaine GreshamRobert TurbinRandall Cobb112.75
114Lance MooreDavid WilsonBen RoethlisbergerMikel LeshoureTony Gonzalez116.75
115Randall CobbRandall CobbDoug BaldwinPeyton HillisBrandon Pettigrew117.75
116Montario HardestyMark IngramRobert MeachemAnquan BoldinRashad Jennings119.25
117Rueben RandleBeanie WellsRoy HeluDoug BaldwinMichael Floyd119.5
118Michael FloydTerrell OwensMichael CrabtreeJustin BlackmonJay Cutler119.75
119Ryan WilliamsJacob TammeBrent CelekAustin CollieFelix Jones122.25
120Pierre ThomasVincent BrownJustin BlackmonAndrew LuckRonnie Hillman125
121Jacob TammeJonathan DwyerRandall CobbMike GoodsonShane Vereen128.25
122Owen DanielsMike GoodsonShane VereenJacquizz RodgersJustin Blackmon129
123Dallas ClarkDenarius MooreTony GonzalezTitus YoungAndrew Luck129.25
124Isaiah PeadAnquan BoldinSantana MossIsaiah PeadBrent Celek129.25
125Evan RoysterJay CutlerAndrew LuckAlex GreenLaurent Robinson129.5
126Mark IngramMatt SchaubMichael FloydJacoby FordRandy Moss130.75
127Josh FreemanKendall HunterRonnie HillmanRueben RandleJacob Tamme131
128Ryan FitzpatrickRonnie HillmanJacoby FordMichael FloydSantana Moss132.25
129Matt SchaubGreg OlsenLeGarrette BlountMike WilliamsIsaiah Pead133.5
130Daniel ThomasSidney RiceOwen DanielsChad JohnsonJared Cook133.75
131Peyton HillisNate WashingtonTitus YoungLance MooreTitus Young135.5
132Ronnie BrownLeonard HankersonRashad JenningsLaurent RobinsonRonnie Brown136.25
133Felix JonesMalcom FloydDustin KellerBrandon LaFellLance Moore136.25
134Jonathan BaldwinRandy MossMontario HardestyBrandon PettigrewJacquizz Rodgers136.5
135Brandon LaFellTim HightowerKendall WrightBrent CelekAlex Green138.75
136Justin BlackmonFelix JonesKyle RudolphJermaine GreshamBrandon LaFell139.25
137Terrell OwensSteven SmithKellen WinslowLeGarrette BlountTerrell Owens139.75
138Laurent RobinsonBrandon PettigrewAlex GreenStephen HillMike Goodson140.5
139Jacoby FordDustin KellerStephen HillRonnie HillmanDaniel Thomas142.25
140Randy MossJake LockerRonnie BrownDaniel ThomasBrian Quick142.5
141David NelsonBrandon LaFellRueben RandleTaiwan JonesMatt Schaub142.75
142Andy DaltonJustin BlackmonCoby FleenerLaMichael JamesRueben Randle144.75
143Alex SmithSantana MossTerrell OwensBrian QuickAustin Collie144.75
144Matt FlynnKenny BrittRandy MossCarson PalmerTim Hightower147
145Alex GreenLaurent RobinsonBernard ScottTim HightowerRobert Turbin147.5
146Lamar MillerLamar MillerBrandon JacobsEarl BennettMontario Hardesty147.5
147Rashad JenningsAlex GreenOwen DanielsBernard PierceLamar Miller151.5
148Jacquizz RodgersDaniel ThomasBrandon LaFellLamar MillerKyle Rudolph153
149LaMichael JamesRobert TurbinTim HightowerTony GonzalezCoby Fleener154.75
150Kyle RudolphLance MooreLance MooreBraylon EdwardsStephen Hill159
151Dustin KellerChad JohnsonDaniel ThomasCoby FleenerVincent Brown159.25
152Jared CookAndy DaltonDevery HendersonJay CutlerMario Manningham160
153Mario ManninghamMatt FlynnBrandon GibsonJake LockerJosh Freeman160.25
154Nate BurlesonBrent CelekMike GoodsonBrandon JacobsAndy Dalton163
155Santana MossCoby FleenerGreg OlsenMontario HardestyLeonard Hankerson167.5
156Devery HendersonEarl BennettMatt SchaubBrian HartlineKellen Winslow169.5
157Danny AmendolaDavid NelsonAlshon JefferyKendall HunterChad Johnson169.75
158Brian QuickBrian QuickVincent BrownKeshawn MartinEarl Bennett172
159Tim HightowerDamian WilliamsLegedu NaaneeDanny CoaleGreg Olsen172.25
160Andrew LuckGolden TateRobert TurbinMatt SchaubBrandon Jacobs173.5
161Earl BennettMario ManninghamDavone BessTerrell OwensBernard Scott174.75
162Steve BreastonKnowshon MorenoMario ManninghamEmmanuel SandersKendall Hunter175
163Braylon EdwardsStephen HillAndre RobertsSteve BreastonTaiwan Jones175.25
164Jerome SimpsonRonnie BrownDelone CarterMario ManninghamDavid Nelson177
165Mike GoodsonJosh FreemanMartellus BennettJoe McKnightKendall Wright178
166Taiwan JonesJacoby FordLamar MillerJason SnellingMatt Flynn178
167Shane VereenRyan FitzpatrickJosh FreemanJahvid BestJacoby Ford183.75
168Robert TurbinJoe FlaccoAustin CollieLegedu NaaneeLaMichael James185
169Brandon JacobsKellen WinslowTaiwan JonesSteve SlatonDion Lewis185.25
170Bernard PierceMohamed SanuJosh GordonKnowshon MorenoJake Locker185.75
171Coby FleenerBrandon SaineDanario AlexanderDavone BessJahvid Best186.25
172Lance KendricksJahvid BestBrandon TateJavon RingerJonathan Dwyer186.25
173Brian HartlineMike TolbertChad JohnsonTim TebowRyan Fitzpatrick186.25
174Ryan BroylesRyan GrantTony MoeakiAndy DaltonDelone Carter189.5
175Chaz SchilensJerome SimpsonJabar GaffneyLeonard HankersonDevery Henderson190
176Leonard HankersonJames JonesJacoby FordDion LewisJerome Simpson190
177Titus YoungBernard ScottIsaiah PeadJacob TammeBraylon Edwards190.75
178Kevin KolbAlex SmithJackie BattleJared CookDallas Clark191
179Joe FlaccoJosh MorganVincent BrownKellen WinslowBernard Pierce191.75
180Mark SanchezAustin CollieDion LewisGreg OlsenOwen Daniels192
181Jahvid BestAlshon JefferyDwayne HarrisAlshon JeffreyRashard Mendenhall192.25
182Bernard ScottScott ChandlerBrandon SaineJosh FreemanSteven Smith192.5
183Delone CarterOwen DanielsRyan BroylesSteven SmithAlex Smith192.75
184Bilal PowellRashard MendenhallAndy DaltonT.Y. HiltonSteve Breaston193.75
185Curtis BrinkleyMontario HardestyDavid NelsonNick ToonLegedu Naanee194.25
186Javon RingerT.Y. HiltonJacquizz RodgersDelone CarterBrandon Saine194
187Dion LewisChristian PonderLeonard HankersonOwen DanielsRyan Broyles194
188Rashard MendenhallMark SanchezLee EvansMohamed SanuBrian Hartline194.75
189Le'Ron McClainJohn SkeltonDonald JonesKendall WrightKnowshon Moreno195.5
190Vick BallardKendall WrightDanny AmendolaMatt FlynnDavone Bess195.5
191Kendall HunterSteve SlatonKeiland WilliamsDallas ClarkT.Y. Hilton198
192Jackie BattleCedric BensonRyan GrantCedric BensonDanny Amendola199
193Kellen WinslowEmmanuel SandersKevin KolbChaz SchilensEmmanuel Sanders201.25
194Heath MillerRueben RandleJoel DreessenChris IvoryDamian Williams201.5
195Chris CooleyRyan BroylesMike TolbertBernard ScottJavon Ringer202
196Stephen HillDavid GettisRashard MendenhallJames JonesMohamed Sanu202
197T.Y. HiltonDion LewisJerome SimpsonDamian WilliamsSteve Slaton202.5
198Kendall WrightMartellus BennettBrandon MyersA.J. JenkinsMartellus Bennett203
199Brandon SaineJosh GordonHarry DouglasJonathan DwyerRyan Grant204
200Jonathan DwyerMatt CasselRashard MendenhallChaz Schilens204.5
Mark Sanchez204.5
Mike Tolbert204.5
Josh Gordon205
Jackie Battle205
James Jones205.25
Kevin Kolb205.5
Brandon Gibson207
Nate Burleson207.25
Keshawn Martin208.25
Danny Coale208.5
Cedric Benson208.5
Andre Roberts210
Joe McKnight210
Jason Snelling210.25
Lance Kendricks211.75
Tim Tebow211.75
Brandon Tate212
Tony Moeaki212
Jabar Gaffney213
Josh Morgan213.5
Alshon Jeffrey214
Dwayne Harris214
Scott Chandler214.25
Bilal Powell214.75
Nick Toon215
Lee Evans216
Le'Ron McClain216
John Skelton216
Donald Jones216
Vick Ballard216.25
Keiland Williams217
Chris Ivory217.25
Joel Dreessen217
Chris Cooley217.5
David Gettis217.75
A.J. Jenkins218.25
Brandon Myers218
Harry Douglas219




Want to Read More?
Subscribe to RotoWire to see the full article.

We reserve some of our best content for our paid subscribers. Plus, if you choose to subscribe you can discuss this article with the author and the rest of the RotoWire community.

Get Instant Access To This Article Get Access To This Article
RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only NFL Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire NFL fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Chris Liss
Chris Liss
Chris Liss was RotoWire's Managing Editor and Host of RotoWIre Fantasy Sports Today on Sirius XM radio from 2001-2022.
NFL Draft Recap: Day 3 Instant Fantasy Reactions
NFL Draft Recap: Day 3 Instant Fantasy Reactions
10 Reactions From The First Round of the NFL Draft (Video)
10 Reactions From The First Round of the NFL Draft (Video)
NFL Draft Day 2 Recap: Draft Grades and Fantasy Analysis
NFL Draft Day 2 Recap: Draft Grades and Fantasy Analysis
NFL Draft Recap: Day 1 Instant Rookie Reactions
NFL Draft Recap: Day 1 Instant Rookie Reactions