This article is part of our Collette Calls series.
The first thing we discussed was the impact of "The Opener" strategy on fantasy baseball. I took the opportunity to once again beat the drum for the Times Through the Order Penalty (TTOP).
The Opener has lovers and haters; I fall in the former category. The haters will say that strategy only looked great for Tampa Bay because Blake Snell was incredible and heavily influenced the team's ERA. To wit, the team had a 3.49 ERA from the first time Sergio Romo opened a game until the end of the season. That figure was the third-best ERA over that time, trailing only the Dodgers (3.19) and Astros (3.37). If we remove Snell's contributions to that body of work, the Rays' ERA drops to 3.73, which would have dropped them to seventh best league-wide.
The simple fact is The Opener can work, depending on matchups early and the down-boxscore effect later. It allows the normal starter to miss the better bats in the lineup right out the gate, and limits those hitters from extra exposure to the normal starter within that game. I discussed this impact in an article just before the All-Star Break, but this is what the TTOP numbers look like for the 2018 season for starting pitchers: