RotoWire Partners

Team Previews: 2009 Dallas Cowboys Preview

Erik Siegrist

Erik Siegrist is an FSWA award-winning columnist who covers all four major North American sports (that means the NHL, not NASCAR) and whose beat extends back to the days when the Nationals were the Expos and the Thunder were the Sonics. He was the inaugural champion of Rotowire's Staff Keeper baseball league. His work has also appeared at Baseball Prospectus.

By Erik Siegrist
RotoWire Staff Writer


The Cowboys headed into 2008 as presumptive Super Bowl contenders, if not favorites. The team boasted a high-powered offense that featured Tony Romo, Terrell Owens, Marion Barber, Jason Witten, first-round pick Felix Jones and the play-calling wizardry of coordinator Jason Garrett, who was paid handsomely not to take a head coaching job elsewhere. Add to that a sack-happy Wade Phillips defense led by force of nature DeMarcus Ware, and America's Team seemed poised to shake off the postseason disappointments of the previous couple of years.

Instead of a title run, however, the Cowboys failed to even make the playoffs. Injuries to Jones, Barber and particularly Romo didn't help, but the offense seemed sluggish even when the team's key personnel was on the field, damaging Garrett's burgeoning reputation as an offensive genius. The midseason acquisition of WR Roy Williams looked good on paper, but did nothing to improve matters. And while Ware emerged as the premier pass-rushing threat in the NFL, poor play by the secondary (in particular the safeties) led to too many extended drives by the opposition (the Cowboys were sixth-worst in the NFL in red zone appearances allowed) and dragged down the rest of the defense.

Frustrated owner/GM Jerry Jones resorted to an addition by subtraction approach this offseason in an effort to prevent another year of underachieving. Despite his third straight 1000-plus yard, 10-plus TD season, Terrell Owens was cut loose, as was injured and increasingly ineffective strong safety Roy Williams, in the hope that an improved attitude in the locker room would allow the roster to play up to its talent level. Reinforcements were few and far between, however. Jon Kitna replaces Brad Johnson and gives the Cowboys a more useful backup option at QB if anything were to happen to Romo again, and aging Keith Brooking fills in for the even more aging Zach Thomas at ILB, but the team didn't make a pick until the third round of the draft and the incoming class of rookies will mostly be counted on to provide depth on defense and the special teams coverage units..

There are still plenty of Pro Bowlers on the roster, however, and expectations in Dallas never dwindle too low. There is already the usual absurd grumbling among the fan base and media that Romo isn't a real leader, and that he isn't mentally tough enough to take a team to the promised land (the brothers Manning can relate). If the team fails once again to show any real progress towards a championship, further changes will be coming, starting with Phillips as head coach. Owens may be in Buffalo now, but that doesn't mean he took all the drama surrounding this team with him.


2009 Draft

Round, Overall, Player

3. (69) Jason Williams, LB, Western Illinois
Special teams force could replace Kevin Burnett at nickel LB.

3. (75) Robert Brewster, OT, Ball State
Massive college tackle should provide interior O-line depth.

4. (101) Stephen McGee, QB, Texas A&M
Has long-term potential, but will be the third QB in 2009.

4. (110) Victor Butler, DE/OLB, Oregon State
Special teams weapon probably won't see many snaps on defense.

4. (120) Brandon Williams, DE/OLB, Texas Tech
Pass-rushing specialist might need lots of development time after leaving college early

5. (143) DeAngelo Smith, CB, Cincinnati
Versatile DB could be moved to safety if he adds a few pounds.

5. (166) Michael Hamlin, S, Clemson
Hard hitter could compete for time at strong safety.

5. (172) David Buehler, K, USC
Kickoff specialist provides insurance in case Nick Folk's hip is an issue.

6. (197) Stephen Hodge, S, TCU
Yet another special teams specialist.

6. (208) John Phillips, TE, Virginia
Solid blocking tight end, but not a pass-catcher.

7. (227) Mike Mickens, CB Cincinnati
Speedy corner and special teams player could be this year's Orlando Scandrick.

7. (229) Manuel Johnson, WR Oklahoma
Undersized, but could fit as an elusive slot receiver.

Key Acquisitions

Keith Brooking, LB (Falcons)
Eight straight 100-plus tackle seasons in Atlanta.

Jon Kitna, QB (Lions)
A big step up from Brad Johnson as Tony Romo insurance.

Igor Olshansky, DT (Chargers)
Not an IDP asset but he should improve run defense.

Key Losses

Terrell Owens, WR (Bills)
Despite less overt drama in 2008, T.O. finally wore out his welcome in yet another locker room.

Chris Canty, DE (Giants)
Useful pass rusher will try to make a name for himself outside of DeMarcus Ware's shadow.

Anthony Henry, CB (Lions)
Steady veteran had trouble staying healthy in Dallas.



Perhaps the more accurate question would be, "Who other than Jason Witten will Romo throw to?" Romo drew criticism last season for keying in on his Pro Bowl tight end at the expense of his wideouts, and replacing Terrell Owens with Roy Williams as his No. 1 WR isn't likely to give him confidence in the abilities of his receiving corps. Even if Williams is able to step up and produce at Owens' level, the rest of the depth chart is still very thin. Patrick Crayton has proven to be little more than a possession receiver with a wandering focus, while the rest of the WRs are young and unproven. While the tight ends will benefit from that shallow WR talent pool, the offense may again struggle to put up points if opposing defenses can relax against the downfield threats and concentrate underneath.


Last year's toe injuries to Felix Jones and Marion Barber gave Tashard Choice a chance to demonstrate that he is a more than capable NFL running back, but it was still disconcerting for the Cowboys to see Barber break down the first time he was given a starter's workload and for Jones (considered potentially fragile coming out of college) to break down under any workload at all. If it's healthy, the Dallas backfield is as talented as any team's, featuring the prototypical combination of a relentless physical runner (Barber) and a game-breaking speedster (Jones), but the pair will need to prove that they can handle a 16-game schedule if the Cowboys' offense is going to approach its 2007 level of production.


The Cowboys' defense was expected to be a strength, and while DeMarcus Ware paced the NFL in sacks, Jay Ratliff emerged as a force from the NT spot in the 3-4 defense (an impressive feat all by itself) and Bradie James had a career year at ILB, the secondary was still too ineffective to take advantage of the league-leading pass rush, coming up with a miserable eight INTs and generally failing to make impact plays. The team will rely on the further development of second-year DBs Mike Jenkins and Orlando Scandrick to shore up the back end, but the key will be getting better safety play than they received from Roy Williams (cut and now in Cincinnati), Ken Hamlin (the aging veteran who could shift to strong safety) and Keith Davis (the special teams captain who isn't capable of handling a starting role). The fact that the Cowboys didn't use anything higher than a fifth-round pick to address the situation doesn't offer much encouragement that it will improve, however.


Rising: Patrick Crayton will once again have little competition for the second WR slot, and Roy Williams isn't a proven No. 1.

Declining: Tony Romo will probably be among the first QBs drafted thanks to his huge 2007 but doesn't have the receiving options to repeat it.

Sleeper: Felix Jones was dangerous every time he touched the ball last season. More touches, health willing, will mean a lot more production.

Supersleeper: Martellus Bennett has pass-catching upside and would benefit greatly if Jason Witten starts to break down after years of working in the trenches.


DeMarcus Ware, LB
20 sacks and 80+ tackles make him worth a spot, even as a LB.

Bradie James, LB
Set career high with eight sacks and 116 tackles last season.

Keith Brooking, LB
Tackling machine could start getting to the QB again in Dallas after zero sacks in 2008.

Team Defense:
RotoWire Rank: 7

Article first appeared 6/08/09