MLB DFS Pitcher & Team Stacks Guide for Tuesday, September 16

Ryan Pohle takes a deeper look into team stacks and pitchers for Tuesday's MLB slate, including the Brewers' Freddy Peralta in a favorable matchup against the Angels.
MLB DFS Pitcher & Team Stacks Guide for Tuesday, September 16
SPECIAL OFFER

Get 50% OFF All-in-One

Find the best pickups with our waiver wire tool, optimize your DFS lineups, and find your perfect pick. This subscription has everything you need to win this NFL season. Ends 9/21. Use promo code ALL.
PROMO CODE ALL

Top DFS Pitching and Team Stacking Strategies for DraftKings

In this article, I'm going to take a deeper dive into pitching and team stacking options. Let's take a look at our optimizer's rankings of the pitchers for the DraftKings 11-game main slate, sorted by projected fantasy points.

Visit RotoWire's MLB Daily Lineups to find out where the hitters slot in!

*No rain delays expected.

Despite the large slate, we only have four pitchers priced over $9,000, with the obvious chalky option being Freddy Peralta. He's coming off one of his worst outings of the season but gets a great bounce back opportunity against an Angels squad that leads in the league in strikeout rate. Oh, and Peralta didn't allow a run in any of his previous five starts.

We've also highlighted Logan Gilbert, Eury Perez and Shane Smith in our optimizer. Perez is our top point-per-dollar starter as he gets a $1,200 discount compared to his FanDuel salary against a weak Rockies lineup. Then there's the tale of two pitchers in Gilbert and Smith, with the former having the far superior stuff compared to Smith who has the value salary and favorable Orioles matchup.

There are some pitching situations I'm going to avoid tonight. Tristan Beck is receiving his first start of the season and will be on a limited pitch count, while the Mets are starting Clay Holmes with Sean Manaea in bulk relief. It's difficult to imagine either going more than four innings. And then there's

Top DFS Pitching and Team Stacking Strategies for DraftKings

In this article, I'm going to take a deeper dive into pitching and team stacking options. Let's take a look at our optimizer's rankings of the pitchers for the DraftKings 11-game main slate, sorted by projected fantasy points.

Visit RotoWire's MLB Daily Lineups to find out where the hitters slot in!

*No rain delays expected.

Despite the large slate, we only have four pitchers priced over $9,000, with the obvious chalky option being Freddy Peralta. He's coming off one of his worst outings of the season but gets a great bounce back opportunity against an Angels squad that leads in the league in strikeout rate. Oh, and Peralta didn't allow a run in any of his previous five starts.

We've also highlighted Logan Gilbert, Eury Perez and Shane Smith in our optimizer. Perez is our top point-per-dollar starter as he gets a $1,200 discount compared to his FanDuel salary against a weak Rockies lineup. Then there's the tale of two pitchers in Gilbert and Smith, with the former having the far superior stuff compared to Smith who has the value salary and favorable Orioles matchup.

There are some pitching situations I'm going to avoid tonight. Tristan Beck is receiving his first start of the season and will be on a limited pitch count, while the Mets are starting Clay Holmes with Sean Manaea in bulk relief. It's difficult to imagine either going more than four innings. And then there's Houston's AJ Blubaugh, who pitched an inning Friday and isn't expected to see a normal starter's workload. Note that Cristopher Sanchez, Cam Schlittler and Zebby Matthews rank well in the metrics below. 

Here's how each pitcher ranks in key categories (stats are from 2025 season only):

PitcherFantasy PointsFIPK%Opponent K%
Freddy Peralta1551
Logan Gilbert23121
Merrill Kelly3111317
Eury Perez413122
Cristopher Sanchez521011
Shane Smith617143
Cam Schlittler79710
Zebby Matthews8694
Ryan Pepiot9181122
Andrew Abbott1071513
Dean Kremer1112178
Michael King128814
Eduardo Rodriguez1319169
Jose Berrios1420186
Michael Wacha154205
Michael McGreevy1610227
Sean Manaea1714320
AJ Blubaugh1821412
Caden Dana1922619
Kyle Freeland20162118
Shohei Ohtani211215
Tristan Beck22151916

Analyzing Team Stack Rankings for Maximum DFS Impact

Here is how each team ranks in implied runs, team OPS against opposing starter handedness and how popular we expect each team stack to be in GPPs:

TeamImplied RunsTeam OPS vs. HandStack Popularity
Brewers6.37High
Marlins6.021High
Yankees5.51High
Diamondbacks5.14Medium
Mariners4.98Medium
Rockies4.518High
Rays4.59Medium
Mets4.42Low
Blue Jays4.43Medium
Reds4.410High
Dodgers4.35High
Giants4.322High
White Sox4.220Medium
Orioles4.212Medium
Rangers4.116Medium
Cardinals4.019Medium
Royals4.015Low
Twins4.013Low
Padres3.911Low
Astros3.814Low
Phillies3.56Low
Angels2.617Low

My primary team stack targets

Marlins vs. LHP Freeland (4.31 FIP, 1.46 WHIP). Key pieces: Agustin Ramirez, Eric Wagaman, Xavier Edwards, Connor Norby, Dane Myers

Reds vs. RHP McGreevy (4.44 ERA, 14.2 K%). Key pieces: Elly De La Cruz, Gavin Lux, TJ Friedl, Noelvi Marte, Austin Hays

Yankees vs. RHP Matthews (5.06 ERA, 1.46 WHIP). Key pieces: Ben Rice, Cody Bellinger, Trent Grisham, Aaron Judge, Jazz Chisholm

Giants vs. LHP Rodriguez (4.46 FIP, 1.55 WHIP). Key pieces: Wilmer Flores, Casey Schmitt, Matt Chapman, Willy Adames, Heliot Ramos

Key Matchups and Batter vs. Pitcher Insights for DFS Success

Notable hitter matchups against the opposing starter today:

For up-to-the-minute updates on injuries, lineups, roster changes and more, head to RotoWire's Fantasy Baseball News & Latest MLB Updates or follow @RotoWireMLB on X.

Want to Read More?
Subscribe to RotoWire to see the full article.

We reserve some of our best content for our paid subscribers. Plus, if you choose to subscribe you can discuss this article with the author and the rest of the RotoWire community.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Ryan Pohle is a DFS Product Specialist at RotoWire and has written for the site since 2020.
RotoWire Logo

Continue the Conversation

Join the RotoWire Discord group to hear from our experts and other MLB fans.

Top News

Tools

MLB Draft Kit Logo

MLB Draft Kit

Fantasy Tools

Don’t miss a beat. Check out our 2025 MLB Fantasy Baseball rankings.